VSBenchmark 2007: Polaris vs. Wings

[NeoS]

I thought i'd test the infamous AtiD3D.dll in a benchmark test.
VSBenchmark (http://vsbench.virtualspaghetti.com/) tests 5 sections: Graphics, Jpeg, Games, Sound and Other.

I won't go into the details of the program, if you wanna know, follow the link, download it and test it yourself.

Here are the benchmarks:

Polaris Benchmark without ATID3D.dll:
Graphics - 0967
Others - 1595
Jpeg - 1991
Games - 1093
Sound - 0851

Total: 1299

Polaris Becnhmark With ATID3D.dll:
Graphics - 1013
Others - 1750
Jpeg - 2146
Games - 1135
Sound - 0796

Total: 1368

Polaris With ATID3D.dll and without SRS WoW
Graphics - 1097
Others - 1881
Jpeg - 2328
Games - 1255
Sound - 0666

Total: 1445

Wings (S730) Becnhmark Without ATID3D.dll:
Graphics - 0996
Others - 1802
Jpeg - 2278
Games - 1227
Sound - 1029

Total: 1466

Wings (S730) With ATID3D.dll:
Graphics - 1058
Others - 1780
Jpeg - 2292
Games - 1209
Sound - 1044

Total: 1476

Notice the better performance of the Wings in ALL sections (especially sound for some weird reason)! The biggest difference between these devices is that the Polaris is a pocketpc phone and the Wings is a Smartphone. I'll run a couple more benches to be sure, because the scores seem to fluctuate somewhat.
Just so you know...

[Bodisson]

Ummm...
What does ATID3D.dll give you in everyday use?
Benchmark is good, but real life is something completely different...

[raskell]

As shipped results:

Test1 1082
Test2 1713
Test3 2164
Test4 1211
Test5 0689

Overall 1371

[lazik]

My results (with SRS WoW):
Test 1 - 0978
Test 2 - 1667
Test 3 - 2065
Test 4 - 1101
Test 5 - 0811
Final score 1324

SKTools Benchmark:
Integer - 233,3561 Moves/25 usec
Floating point - 5,499 MWIPS
RAM access - 479 Speed index
Draw bitmaps - 720 Speed index
Main storage (write) - 10971,43 KB/sec
Main storage (read) - 11377,78 KB/sec
microSDHC (write) - 321,89 KB/sec
microSDHC (read) - 13100,21 KB/sec
File List - 793 Items/s
File List (microSDHC) - 3418 Items/s
SKTools loading - 3540 ms

Card - SanDisk 8GB microSDHC Class 4

[academic]

Here are the results (http://www.phonemag.ch/images/divers/vsb2007_result.html) of the full test on my Polaris

Not very impressive comparing to the Qtek 9100... HTC have a lot of work to make this device using all the power of the Qualcomm Processor !

By the way, what is this ATID3D.DLL and how to implement it?

[NeoS]

Hmm, i noticed a big drop when i removed the SRS WoW from my device. I'll reinstall it and do a new bench. See if it really helps.

[vasek77]

My results of HTC Polaris (with czech localization)
Test 1 Graphic: 1259
Test 2 Others: 2154
Test 3 JPEG: 2624
Test 4 Games: 1507
Test 5 Sound: 0580

Final Score: 1624