5,594,077 Members 46,570 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

Otterbox Commuter & XO Skins Screen protector Review w/ PICS!

Tip us?
 
k20igor
Old
#1  
k20igor's Avatar
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 12
Posts: 62
Join Date: Jan 2012
Talking Otterbox Commuter & XO Skins Screen protector Review w/ PICS!

Hey xda members, 2 days ago i got my Otterbox Commuter case, and today i recieved my XO Skins screen protector.

This is my first time writing a review, so please bare with me lol

So I've been using the otterbox case for a few days now and i must say I LOVE IT!
the fit is very nice, looks great, and feels awesome. I have read that some people find it to be too slippery, but for me its great. I likke how it has the flaps for the charger port and headphones jack, helps keep out dust and such. It sits very nicely in the hand, i found the phone without any case to be a little slim and i felt like it was going to slip out everytime I held it. The one concern I have with this case is the power button, and those that have this case please let me know if it's the same with yours, i can't feel the button actually push in, it feels more like I just touch it and the screen comes on or off. Not sure if I like it or not but i am getting used to it now. The volume buttons on the other hand feel fine. At first i was worried that the case would make the phone look and feel bulky, as i had one for my X2, but i was surprised this doesn't add too much bulk. The phone, to me at least, feels perfect in my hand. Also this case covers up the the prongs below the power button, i don't mind or care about it but some of you might so keep that in mind. Also i do have the extanded battery 2100mAh too and did try it with this case and it's not a nice fit. There are some gaps on the sides and the buttons seem like they are pressed in at times so i would not recommend this case with the extended battery.

And just a few hours ago I recieved my XO Skins screen protector in the mail and put it on right away. My previous screen protector I had just before i put this one on was the verizon one, and it sucked. Cut outs were bad and too large for the toop speaker and there was about a mm of space on the edges of the screen, which i didn't like. The XO on the other hand is fantastic. The screen protector is almost invisible unless you look at the cutout for the front cam and light sensor. It goes right to the very edge of the screen which i like. The quality is also fantastic. The material feels somewhat like that of the ZAGG but no orange peel what so ever, which i also like. I did however order the ZAGG as well for the full body just to be safe lol.

Overall I recommend this case with this screen protector to anyone, both are a great combination. The case i got on ebay for 29.50 and free shipping and the screen protector i got from the XO website, and somewhere on here someone posted some discount coupons which i wish i would have seen before i bought mine but no biggy it was only 13.xx i believe plus 2.99 shipping

I also have on the way and SGP Neo Hybrid case which i will post a review once i get it. Got the Reventon Yellow.





^The cutouts are really nice and precise unlike the verizon one i had




Also, you can't really tell here but the XO skins doesn't affect the quality of the screen what so ever. took that pic on the Nexus actually hood of my car very nice pics even though some people complain.

If someone would like to know something more or see more pics let me know.
Thanks
The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to k20igor For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
trainplane3
Old
#2  
Member
Thanks Meter 4
Posts: 34
Join Date: May 2010
Looks great! Is that the case fit or regular XO Skin?
 
k20igor
Old
#3  
k20igor's Avatar
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 12
Posts: 62
Join Date: Jan 2012
Quote:
Originally Posted by trainplane3 View Post
Looks great! Is that the case fit or regular XO Skin?
its the regular fit. i dont like the case fit because it doesnt go all the way to the edges of the screen

(Verizon)
Previous Phones:
Moto Droid X2
htc Incredible

My Reviews:
Otterbox Commuter
SGP Neo-Hybrid in Reventon Yellow
 
zephiK
Old
#4  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 3262
Posts: 10,197
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: New York, NY

 
DONATE TO ME
Looks like a lot of lint / dust is attracted to the case.
Twitter -- If you actually need to get in contact with me just tweet me rather than PMs its more efficient and I can get back to you faster.

Nexus 5 (D820): Carbon | Franco Kernel
Nexus 4 (E960): Carbon | Franco Kernel
Older devices: Galaxy Nexus, ASUS TF101, Nexus S, Samsung Vibrant, G1
 
k20igor
Old
#5  
k20igor's Avatar
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 12
Posts: 62
Join Date: Jan 2012
Quote:
Originally Posted by zephiK View Post
Looks like a lot of lint / dust is attracted to the case.
actually not really, i just used a microfiber towel and it left that behind. im picky about that stuff too and the case doesnt actually attract that much if any.

(Verizon)
Previous Phones:
Moto Droid X2
htc Incredible

My Reviews:
Otterbox Commuter
SGP Neo-Hybrid in Reventon Yellow
 
jonnyg1097
Old
#6  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 118
Posts: 1,425
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Toronto
Question about the XO skin (not directed towards the topic creator but I just figured that since this thread is somewhat related to it I could ask it here), how does the lifetime replacement warranty work? Is it like, you order it and get it but you apply it wrong somehow and it gets ruined they will send you back a new perfect one for you to apply?
 
k20igor
Old
#7  
k20igor's Avatar
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 12
Posts: 62
Join Date: Jan 2012
Quote:
Originally Posted by jonnyg1097 View Post
Question about the XO skin (not directed towards the topic creator but I just figured that since this thread is somewhat related to it I could ask it here), how does the lifetime replacement warranty work? Is it like, you order it and get it but you apply it wrong somehow and it gets ruined they will send you back a new perfect one for you to apply?
i dont think so, but i'm not 100% sure. maybe someone else could say

(Verizon)
Previous Phones:
Moto Droid X2
htc Incredible

My Reviews:
Otterbox Commuter
SGP Neo-Hybrid in Reventon Yellow
 
CBMC
Old
#8  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 40
Posts: 369
Join Date: Apr 2009
Quote:
Originally Posted by jonnyg1097 View Post
Question about the XO skin (not directed towards the topic creator but I just figured that since this thread is somewhat related to it I could ask it here), how does the lifetime replacement warranty work? Is it like, you order it and get it but you apply it wrong somehow and it gets ruined they will send you back a new perfect one for you to apply?
I sent them a email. They sent me a link to order a replacement with a rma #. You have to pay $3 and some change for shipping. They tell you too send back the original skin, but for me they sent the replacement upon payment for the shipping. Note that they don't send you any more solution so if you don't have any left you can order more from the site for $3. Not sure if the adding of the solution will increase the shipping costs since I didn't order it. Basically they sent the skins in a regular envelope for regular first class postage of $.44. So they really don't lose anything because they make about $3 on the postage.


Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
 
zephiK
Old
#9  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 3262
Posts: 10,197
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: New York, NY

 
DONATE TO ME
Quote:
Originally Posted by k20igor View Post
actually not really, i just used a microfiber towel and it left that behind. im picky about that stuff too and the case doesnt actually attract that much if any.
That's good to hear. The CM Tough Case's silicon always attracted lint/dust, it appears this one seems better to avoid it.
Twitter -- If you actually need to get in contact with me just tweet me rather than PMs its more efficient and I can get back to you faster.

Nexus 5 (D820): Carbon | Franco Kernel
Nexus 4 (E960): Carbon | Franco Kernel
Older devices: Galaxy Nexus, ASUS TF101, Nexus S, Samsung Vibrant, G1
 
D3TH METAL
Old
#10  
D3TH METAL's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 51
Posts: 1,019
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Orange County,CA
Is the power button easy to depress with the commuter? My isn't clicky like the volume buttons. I do have a replacement coming soon.

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes


XDA PORTAL POSTS

Configure Your System Settings on a Per-App Basis

Do you ever like to make sure that certain device settings are enabled prior to entering a … more

How to Hack An Android App (Don’t Try This at Home) – XDA Developer TV

Listen, don’t cheat in your games. So don’t … more

Windows Phone 8.1 Developer Preview Now Available!

About two weeks ago at the BUILD conference in San Francisco, Microsoft unveiled Windows … more