Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,805,892 Members 43,522 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

Custom ROMs - sharing a beginner's experience

Tip us?
 
CrisR82
Old
#1  
CrisR82's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 26
Posts: 123
Join Date: May 2011
Location: Segovia
Default Custom ROMs - sharing a beginner's experience

As a long time Android user and general nerd, I often hear from some of my friends about new and cool custom ROMs. It ranges from "amazing customization" to "blazing speed" and even "far better than anything stock in general".

So this weekend I decided that since my warranty is no longer valid anyway, and Samsung won't be updating the Galaxy S2 GT-i9100 anymore, I can go ahead and try something new and shiny, which could help me with my job.

And thus began my research and tests on Android custom ROMs...and oh boy, that was one hell of an experience.
Everything I heard from people about nearly everything was shattered right then and there.

As a reasonable person, I decided to try some of the more popular ROMs, trying to stick as much as possible to stable builds since everyday use is a big deal for me. So now I present to you, my experience with what I was told are the top-dogs of the custom ROM world and my impressions of each:
  • Omni 4.4.2
    This one actually surprised me in terms of it's video driver. As some might know, a bunch of Gameloft published games always show washed out colors on the Galaxy S2, but when used, this ROM showed the correct colors...quite shocking! ...however, it turned out to be highly unstable with apps crashing left and right all the time and often for no real reason. This ROM is not really advertised as "stable" so I guess that was understandable, so I decided to move on.
  • MIUI v5
    This ROM was just impressive. I absolutely love the UI (and I didn't even try the customization stuff, yet I say that!). It seemed really stable and I almost decided to stick with it...until I found out that 3 apps in particular I very much rely on don't work properly or at all (overlay issues it seems). This got me really disappointed but I figured functionality is more important than looks so once again, I decided to move on.
  • CyanogenMod 10.3.1
    This might be the biggest disappointment for all the wrong reasons. The buildup and hype I got from people about it created in my head "the ultimate ROM"...but after installing it and doing some tests...I have to say, the performance difference was just barely noticeable and i all honesty, not worth the trade for the bugs it also brings (although if it had the video driver from Omni I would've changed my mind). I really wanted to do a fair judgement since I know this is the top-dog of ROMs (or at least in popularity) so I even ran tests on it...and in games, the framerate difference between stock and CM10.3 was just 2-5fps.
  • Resurrection Remix 4.0.7
    This was...let me just say it out loud - the installation for this ROM should be a standard - just incorporate some stuff and have people chose what to get or don't get. Having stock stuff and then 10 additional flashable ZIPs while not really a big issue is just a time-waster for a lot of people in my eyes (although it would've been nice to know more about the modems when it asks you for a choice). Anyway, this ROM's keyboard just refused to work so I got rid of it after 2 flashes.
  • ReVolt JB 4.5
    ...keyboard didn't work on this one again, and after another 2 flash attempts, I scrapped it aswell.

At this point I pretty much just gave up and went back to the Samsung stock ROM for my region and was left with an empty feeling that custom ROMs all seem to have at least one or more huge flaws.
All the buildup and "legends" (lacking a better term) weren't even close to what I experienced (except the MIUI...well, UI) and it got me thinking...are custom ROMs meant for everyday users or they were always aimed at people willing to experiment? Personally, I decided that my journey through the custom ROM world has ended here at least for the time being (maybe someday I'll go back to MIUI but who knows), but I wanted to ask, does anyone feel the same way I do? That custom ROMs, while a really cool thing to be able to have is getting overhyped to the point where unless you really know what you're getting into will lead to just disappointment?

I would really like to hear other people's views on this, especially if you're not an expert user.
My Android gaming channel: http://www.youtube.com/user/crisr82
My Android game reviews: www.supergamedroid.com/author/kristian/
The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to CrisR82 For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
toxicro
Old
#2  
toxicro's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 133
Posts: 174
Join Date: Mar 2006

 
DONATE TO ME
NeatROM rulez, give it a try.

Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda app-developers app
Device: Samsung Galaxy S2
 
aaron_my
Old
#3  
aaron_my's Avatar
Member
Thanks Meter 12
Posts: 77
Join Date: Nov 2011
I'm using slimbean 2.2. It's seems better them any other ROM.

Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk 2
 
Gamer015
Old
#4  
Gamer015's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 27
Posts: 109
Join Date: Sep 2013
Resurrection Remix 4.0.7 worked fine for me. the only problem is the System UI that usually crashes when you messed up on something and it really need some reboot for that. ☺

Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
 
warpgamer
Old
#5  
warpgamer's Avatar
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 1
Posts: 13
Join Date: Oct 2012
Location: PARIS
Well, with custom roms comes both bugs and extended capacities.

First of all, having a rooted phone gives a lot of new possibilities.
Besides, custom roms give new content, like the latest android updates, which the constructors take time to port to their devices.
At last but not least, custom ROMs often let you.. customize as much as thou wish

I'm personally using Cyanfox (android 4.4), and I'm pretty happy about it

Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda app-developers app
Device: Samsung GT-i9100
ROM: CarbonRom KitKat Nightly
Recovery: CWM 6.0.4.7
 
mosespl
Old
#6  
mosespl's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 100
Posts: 335
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Wrocław
You schould try another 4.4.2 custom roms for egz pound rom(the best for me) or beanstalk which is good too

Wysłane z mojego GT-I9100 przy użyciu Tapatalka
The Following User Says Thank You to mosespl For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
CrisR82
Old
#7  
CrisR82's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 26
Posts: 123
Join Date: May 2011
Location: Segovia
Quote:
Originally Posted by warpgamer View Post
Well, with custom roms comes both bugs and extended capacities.

First of all, having a rooted phone gives a lot of new possibilities.
Besides, custom roms give new content, like the latest android updates, which the constructors take time to port to their devices.
At last but not least, custom ROMs often let you.. customize as much as thou wish

I'm personally using Cyanfox (android 4.4), and I'm pretty happy about it

Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda app-developers app
I actually just root my stock ROM with the SuperSU flashable ZIP-thingie...though I only need it for a firewall ^-^;;
But to me one of the biggest deal-breakers is how all the ROMs I did like don't support MHL (if only MIUI was capable of that )
My Android gaming channel: http://www.youtube.com/user/crisr82
My Android game reviews: www.supergamedroid.com/author/kristian/
 
iobling
Old
#8  
Member
Thanks Meter 3
Posts: 45
Join Date: Oct 2013
Since the warranty is gone i'm trying a bunch of roms to sede what nave to offer. So far i've only tried the omnirom and it's pretty good to me, except some minor bugs.
In my opinion you've to choose a stabile ROM if you don't want any problems
 
dredremon
Old
#9  
dredremon's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 359
Posts: 1,050
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Pasig City
im using cm10.1 stable linaro build most nearly perfect rom for me.

Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk
sorry in my english




DAYDREAM CM7 THEME original by Gspin
 
CrisR82
Old
#10  
CrisR82's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 26
Posts: 123
Join Date: May 2011
Location: Segovia
Quote:
Originally Posted by iobling View Post
Since the warranty is gone i'm trying a bunch of roms to sede what nave to offer. So far i've only tried the omnirom and it's pretty good to me, except some minor bugs.
In my opinion you've to choose a stabile ROM if you don't want any problems
Quote:
Originally Posted by dredremon View Post
im using cm10.1 stable linaro build most nearly perfect rom for me.

Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk
That's kind'a the thing, CM 10.3.1 is the one shown as stable and it seems to be...but it's missing features that the stock ROMs offer, and the performance difference is pretty much not noticeable enough to justify it for me.

All the ROMs except Omni were shown as "stable" but as i mentioned in my first post, all seem to have at least 1 big issue.

As a side question...I heard the newest version of MIUI actually had MHL/TV-out support on the S2...anyone know if that's true?
My Android gaming channel: http://www.youtube.com/user/crisr82
My Android game reviews: www.supergamedroid.com/author/kristian/

The Following User Says Thank You to CrisR82 For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
Tags
disappointment, experience, galaxy s2, i9100, rom
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes