Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,780,205 Members 39,645 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

Sent my S2 in for warranty replacement.

Tip us?
 
scorpion667
Old
(Last edited by scorpion667; 8th September 2011 at 06:04 PM.)
#1  
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 133
Posts: 528
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Toronto
Default Sent my S2 in for warranty replacement.

I am thinking of selling it if it comes in a brand new box from Samsung. It was a manufacturer defect so I hope they won't send me a refurb. I just want to confirm if you guys are having the same issues I did as to gouge if I just had a bad sample or if the entire line has these issues.

Keep in mind I have spent tens of hours trying to correct these issues via various ROM's, Modems and Kernels, including KH3 which was the best.

My issues were as follows:
-Wifi can't connect at any McDonalds wifi. Works at starbucks, sometimes.
-4g/3g uploads always dip in the speedtest chart for 2 seconds then bumps right up
-Wifi sometimes says connected but doesn't actually work. Didn't happen too often.
-banding on the screen, blobs on screen in dark room/black image on screen.
-phone was warped, determined I just had a bad one as all the other ones at the store were perfectly flat.
-call volume extremely low even when using the secret code to bump it to 100%. my loaner phone a motorola droid is twice as loud as the s2. I can actually hear my girlfriend talk to me now and not have to say what? pardon? every 2 sentences.
-people can't hear me in calls if i'm talking in a low voice, like anyone would at the end of a long stressful work day. even with noise reduction off.
-stock rom has under 6 hours battery life under medium use, easily fixed with custom rom, but still it shouldn't be a necessity to void your warranty untill official firmware is released for your provider, just so you can use your phone for more than 6 hours.
-phone gets hot, can be solved by undervolting cpu/gpu.

Please confirm if you are also having these issues, to help me make a decision regarding what I should do when the phone comes back.

Cheers, Tony
Moto X [Rogers XT1058]
Stock 4.4.2, Rooted and heavily debloated
Moto X Debloat guide

Retired:
2x S2 i9100, iphone 4s, S3 I747, iphone 5, Nexus 4, HTC One
 
m2smoe
Old
#2  
m2smoe's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 65
Posts: 392
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: Grenoble
I am getting none of those issues. Haven't tested McD's wifi, but every other hotspot worked fine for me so far.
DEVICE: Sprint HTC One M7
ROM: ViperOne 6.2.1
 
JJEgan
Old
#3  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 4,418
Posts: 23,038
Join Date: Oct 2010
[QUOTE=scorpion667;17376601]I am thinking of selling it if it comes in a brand new box from Samsung. It was a manufacturer defect so I hope they won't send me a refurb. I just want to confirm if you guys are having the same issues I did as to gouge if I just had a bad sample or if the entire line has these issues.

Keep in mind I have spent tens of hours trying to correct these issues via various ROM's, Modems and Kernels, including KH3 which was the best.

My issues were as follows:
-Wifi can't connect at any McDonalds wifi. Works at starbucks, sometimes.

Nope always worked .
-4g/3g uploads always dip in the speedtest chart for 2 seconds then bumps right up
Nope
-Wifi sometimes says connected but doesn't actually work. Didn't happen too often.
Nope
-banding on the screen, blobs on screen in dark room/black image on screen.

Nope
-phone was warped, determined I just had a bad one as all the other ones at the store were perfectly flat.
Nope its flat
-call volume extremely low even when using the secret code to bump it to 100%


Nope fine but would not mind a bit more as standard .

-stock rom has under 6 hours battery life under medium use,

Nope stock about 20 hours on heavy use .

easily fixed with custom rom,

Custom rom makes little difference

but still it shouldn't be a necessity to void your warranty untill official firmware is released for your provider, j

Its your provider thats the slow path .


I would be quite happy to run the phone on stock rom and if i had the problems you posted phone would have been returned .


jje
 
scorpion667
Old
#4  
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 133
Posts: 528
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Toronto
Looks like I might keep it after all, hoping for a better sample. Thanks for your help guys.
Moto X [Rogers XT1058]
Stock 4.4.2, Rooted and heavily debloated
Moto X Debloat guide

Retired:
2x S2 i9100, iphone 4s, S3 I747, iphone 5, Nexus 4, HTC One
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes