Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,814,166 Members 45,903 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

Root without SU app?

Tip us?
 
tawheed12
Old
#1  
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 17
Posts: 181
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Edmonton, AB
Default Root without SU app?

I just rooted using towel root. Planning on staying stock just needed to make one modification. Everything is perfect including knox and flash counter. Is it okay to keep the phone rooted without having the SU app installed?

If I install supersu will it trip my flash counter? If I use it to unroot will it trip?

Thanks

Sent from my SM-G900W8 using XDA Free mobile app
 
fffft
Old
#2  
fffft's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 420
Posts: 1,578
Join Date: Jul 2013
Some questions are asked over and over. Which is why we can tell that you didn't do a search or take ten minutes to read a few threads - you couldn't have avoided finding the answers if you had. You'd also have gotten a quicker answer if you had tried searching.

Super SU won't increment Knox by itself. The flash counter per se can be reset. It's a widely respected and robust app and you didn't give any specific reason why you wouldn't want to use it. If you remove Super SU without manually adding more cumbersome alternatives, you won't be rooted anymore. If it is your intention to remove root, then go ahead. If you want to remain rooted, then you should do some reading as it would seem that you don't understand what Super SU does.

.
 
tawheed12
Old
(Last edited by tawheed12; 25th August 2014 at 07:00 AM.)
#3  
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 17
Posts: 181
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Edmonton, AB
Quote:
Originally Posted by fffft View Post
Some questions are asked over and over. Which is why we can tell that you didn't do a search or take ten minutes to read a few threads - you couldn't have avoided finding the answers if you had. You'd also have gotten a quicker answer if you had tried searching.

Super SU won't increment Knox by itself. The flash counter per se can be reset. It's a widely respected and robust app and you didn't give any specific reason why you wouldn't want to use it. If you remove Super SU without manually adding more cumbersome alternatives, you won't be rooted anymore. If it is your intention to remove root, then go ahead. If you want to remain rooted, then you should do some reading as it would seem that you don't understand what Super SU does.

.
Thanks for the quick reply. I actually Googled and read through the few rooting threads I found but couldn't find the answer for this specific question. Towelroot rooted the phone and supersu was not installed. I don't want to increase flash counter or have custom status as I want to continue to receive OTA updates. I only rooted to access a sql dB which I needed to modify.

I was never under the impression that SU will trip knox, I was wondering if it would trip my flash counter. Also, my question was based more on security. If I don't have supersu to allow root access I would assume any app can get it and would that be a security issue?


Sent from my SM-G900W8 using XDA Free mobile app
 
fffft
Old
#4  
fffft's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 420
Posts: 1,578
Join Date: Jul 2013
In might be a theoretical advantage to not be rooted. But you loose a lot of functionality for that security "gain". Pragmatically though there have been plenty of malware exploits that can root your device as part of their incursion. So it's hard to believe that you are gaining much security by avoiding root on your handset.

Your device will never be completely secure. Most of your risk is removed if you make a best effort to only use apps from legitimate sources and apply security updates. If you are keen you can also install a antimalware app like lookout or configure iptables.

.
 
tawheed12
Old
#5  
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 17
Posts: 181
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Edmonton, AB
Quote:
Originally Posted by fffft View Post
In might be a theoretical advantage to not be rooted. But you loose a lot of functionality for that security "gain". Pragmatically though there have been plenty of malware exploits that can root your device as part of their incursion. So it's hard to believe that you are gaining much security by avoiding root on your handset.

Your device will never be completely secure. Most of your risk is removed if you make a best effort to only use apps from legitimate sources and apply security updates. If you are keen you can also install a antimalware app like lookout or configure iptables.

.
Agree 100%. Hence my concern about being rooted currently and not having SuperSU installed to control what apps can gain and use root access. Installation of SuperSU was a byproduct of every other root method I've used and thus I was concerned about having rooted with towelroot and not having SuperSU installed.

Sent from my SM-G900W8 using XDA Free mobile app
 
gee2012
Old
(Last edited by gee2012; 25th August 2014 at 08:57 AM.)
#6  
gee2012's Avatar
Recognized Contributor
Thanks Meter 3,067
Posts: 8,382
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: Heerlen
Quote:
Originally Posted by tawheed12 View Post
Agree 100%. Hence my concern about being rooted currently and not having SuperSU installed to control what apps can gain and use root access. Installation of SuperSU was a byproduct of every other root method I've used and thus I was concerned about having rooted with towelroot and not having SuperSU installed.

Sent from my SM-G900W8 using XDA Free mobile app
If you choose to root your phone you should forget about OTA`s imo as this causes only issues in most cases and the loss of root. Disable/uninstall or freeze all system apps regarding OTA`s and flash an updated rom with Mobile Odin Pro and you`ll keep root BTW rooting has so much more advantages like AdAway adblocker, freezing all the unused Samsung apps/widgets, backup and restoring of apps with TB etc etc.
USE Search: /this thread /all threads/Google before posting your question, you`re most likely not the first one having this issue
 
JustPlayingHard
Old
#7  
JustPlayingHard's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 258
Posts: 762
Join Date: Jul 2013
Location: Coventry
You dont need SuperSU for root. Its on a handler for it. It stops malware accessing root without your notice....


[ My Devices ]

 
Some Cheap Phone -> HTC Desire HD -> HTC Sensation XL -> Sony Xperia Z -> Sony Xperia Z1



[ My Work ]


 
Lightning Speed - HTC Sensation XL

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes