Default Google Restore not restoring from 4.3

So when I got my phone, restoring my google account didn't pull any of my settings from 4.3, like wifi passwords or game progress or anything like that. I figured I did something wrong and all my old settings were gone, but I got a tablet that I loaded 4.3 on it, and all my old settings were imported! So now its like I have two seperate backups, one kitkat and one jellybean. Any way to reconcile the two, or just get the jellybean backup on my phone/kitkat since it has a lot of stored passwords and progress saved?
Google Nexus 5 w/CM11 Official Nightly
Samsung Galaxy Note 10.1 w/CM11 Unofficial Nightly