Post Reply

Would You Guys Still Recommend the Nexus 5?

19th April 2014, 02:13 PM   |  #121  
KJ's Avatar
XDA: ASSIST
Recognized Contributor
Flag The boonies - southwest Ontario
Thanks Meter: 3,714
 
8,913 posts
Join Date:Joined: May 2011
More
Quote:
Originally Posted by shac0

It depends on the person. I don't care what anyone says, the Nexus line is lagging behind. The only thing that separated it from other OEM flagship phones was the fact that the OS was 100x better. But we are starting to see companies improve on Android, whether it be Motorola, HTC or even the questionable TouchWiz from Samsung. So who do I recommend the Nexus line to and those that I don't?

If for some reason you can't get a good plan. A lot of the times there is only 1 network in a certain area, and they force higher prices on the people. Especially if you sign a contract. The Nexus price tag gives you some leverage; then again the Moto G also gives you the same leverage.

If you are really into the update as soon as possible, I can understand the joy my fellow Nexus users get when there is a new update waiting for them...but for a lot of smartphones it really isn't needed. I only say this, because it is fully recognized that Google has started to detract from updating Android as frequently so there is less fragmentation. So there is no real added benefit from being in the Nexus program anymore for this reason...but some people still choose to focus on that point.

But the majority of the time, I don't suggest the Nexus line to most other people. Why? For the vast consumer base, rooting and what not is really not that fun. So why wouldn't I suggest it?
1. The camera. Google is not a "hardware" manufacturer. So the camera implementation and any other hardware implementation tends to be half baked and not as good as any other smart phone out there. [Even with the new updated camera]
2. There are no features. Yes...I said it. If what you want is a media consumption device...you don't look at the Nexus line. You look at HTC with boom sound speakers. If you want a good camera, look at the Lumia or S5. Each suggestion is based on what someone really wants.

Honestly, I love my Nexus 5. But it does feel like Google focuses on the software [which is understandable] tells and OEM to put a low budge phone together and throws that software into the phone. It feels like OEMs with flagship smartphones put more effort and thought into their phones and it translates over. So yes and no. I would suggest it...but only to a very few people, lol.

I never recommend the N5 to "normal" users. Why?? They want the frills the other phones offer. They don't care or know about root. They don't care about update times. They want stable...and features.

At the moment, just from experience...with mostly touchwiz and the moto x.....the moto x is my go to recommended phone.

Sent from my N5, N7, Moto X, G Tab 3 or S2.....
19th April 2014, 03:00 PM   |  #122  
vin4yak's Avatar
Recognized Contributor
Flag Mumbai
Thanks Meter: 2,181
 
3,708 posts
Join Date:Joined: Mar 2013
Donate to Me
More
Quote:
Originally Posted by kj2112

I never recommend the N5 to "normal" users. Why?? They want the frills the other phones offer. They don't care or know about root. They don't care about update times. They want stable...and features.

At the moment, just from experience...with mostly touchwiz and the moto x.....the moto x is my go to recommended phone.

Sent from my N5, N7, Moto X, G Tab 3 or S2.....

Touchwiz is as ugly as the sammy phone designs! The new touchwiz makes me wanna puke!
After experiencing stock android experience, I will never switch to any other!

@shac0

First of all Google doesn't manufacture the Nexus 5, LG does. LOL.
The camera on the Nexus 5 is great! Take a look at those threads in the General forum and see for yourself. You just need to know how to shoot it. However, no doubt it doesn't match up to the s5's camera!

How can anybody expect boom sound dual frontal speakers with 16mp camera on a $350 phone? I don't think the extra $200-300 premium is worth paying for those speakers/camera. May be because I'm not into too much photography and only take about 2-3 pics a day.
As for the media playback, the Nexus 5's speaker is decent and with a good sound mod like V4A, it becomes SWEET!

That being said, Nexuses aren't for everyone as @kj2112 said... Those who love Custom ROM Development and try a lot of new things and want quick updates usually buy Nexus devices and the slight trade off in hardware is acceptable when you look at that price tag!
The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to vin4yak For This Useful Post: [ View ]
19th April 2014, 07:17 PM   |  #123  
Junior Member
Thanks Meter: 0
 
5 posts
Join Date:Joined: Jun 2013
Quote:
Originally Posted by vin4yak

Touchwiz is as ugly as the sammy phone designs! The new touchwiz makes me wanna puke!
After experiencing stock android experience, I will never switch to any other!

@shac0

First of all Google doesn't manufacture the Nexus 5, LG does. LOL.
The camera on the Nexus 5 is great! Take a look at those threads in the General forum and see for yourself. You just need to know how to shoot it. However, no doubt it doesn't match up to the s5's camera!

How can anybody expect boom sound dual frontal speakers with 16mp camera on a $350 phone? I don't think the extra $200-300 premium is worth paying for those speakers/camera. May be because I'm not into too much photography and only take about 2-3 pics a day.
As for the media playback, the Nexus 5's speaker is decent and with a good sound mod like V4A, it becomes SWEET!

That being said, Nexuses aren't for everyone as @kj2112 said... Those who love Custom ROM Development and try a lot of new things and want quick updates usually buy Nexus devices and the slight trade off in hardware is acceptable when you look at that price tag!

I don't think I said Google manufactured the Nexus 5 lol..if I did oops. :P


The camera on the Nexus 5 is okay in well lit areas. If it isn't well lit, well then you start to notice large amounts of noise. And I mean any room that doesn't have proper lighting will experience terrible camera quality. It's expected from smart phones, but I have used a lot of other smart phones that don't have the noise issues.

Most typically people are on contract. If you aren't going to be on contract the Nexus 5 is a decent option. But there are other phones like the Moto g, Moto X, Find 7 etc. I love my Nexus 5, but there are flaws with it. If I was on contract, I would definitely get a better phone.
Post Reply Subscribe to Thread
Previous Thread Next Thread
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes


Top Threads in Nexus 5 Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting by ThreadRank