Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,772,940 Members 46,946 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

[Q] I dont know which moto x to pick for straight talk

Tip us?
 
mynamesucks100
Old
#1  
Junior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 5
Join Date: May 2010
Default [Q] I dont know which moto x to pick for straight talk

Hi everyone, I'm thinking about getting a moto x but I dont know which carrier version to pick.

I currently have a droid 4 on verizon and I'm looking to ditch verizon in favor of straight talk in june.
My issue is that they're having a sale on the moto maker site and I dont know weather to choose a Verizon one to use untill my plan stops or if I should get the T-Mobile or at&t version so it will work better with straight talk when the time comes to change.

Something to consider is that 1. T-Mobile has pretty spotty coverage in my area 2. I dont think the moto x can be activated as cdma for straight talk.
Some other questions I have are 1. will a T-Mobile version work just fine on at&t? 2. are there any reasons I should pick an at&t branded one? 3. Are there any reasons i shouldn't pick the verizon version?

thank you for your time
 
eksasol
Old
(Last edited by eksasol; 7th February 2014 at 08:20 AM.)
#2  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 692
Posts: 2,741
Join Date: Nov 2009
Correct me on this if needed, but all Verizon phones are sim unlocked and work with GSM per FCC agreement. So you could get that version, but I would check it first when receiving it to see if it work with a GSM sim, if not you can get an RMA for a refund. The Verizon edition have the 3G bands to work with ATT, it lacks T-Mobile AWS 3G band (1700). Also it only support LTE band 13, it doesn't support LTE bands 2, 4 or 17 that come with the GSM unlocked version, so you will not get LTE on ATT or T-Mobile.

There is zero reason to get the ATT version what so ever, none, zilch. It's sim locked (though you could ask ATT to unlock it I guess), cannot unlock bootloader. The T-Mobile version is actually the unlocked version, it support every bands required by ATT, both 3G and LTE. T-Mobile version have unlocked sim and bootloader, doesn't have carrier logo nor carrier bloatwares.

Then there is the unlocked GSM Developer Edition which allow you to unlock bootloader without losing warranty, is similar to regular T-Mobile unlocked edition, except that it lacks T-Mobile AWS 3G band. You can get the Dev edition for Verizon as well which have the same bands support as the regular Verizon version. You can not unlock the bootloader for the regular version of ATT and Verizon.

sent via my Le Motonovo X
The Following User Says Thank You to eksasol For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
mynamesucks100
Old
#3  
Junior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 5
Join Date: May 2010
Thank you for the clarification, looks like im going the t-mobile route
 
coreno
Old
#4  
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 17
Join Date: Jul 2009
Quote:
Originally Posted by eksasol View Post
Correct me on this if needed, but all Verizon phones are sim unlocked and work with GSM per FCC agreement. So you could get that version, but I would check it first when receiving it to see if it work with a GSM sim, if not you can get an RMA for a refund. The Verizon edition have the 3G bands to work with ATT, it lacks T-Mobile AWS 3G band (1700). Also it only support LTE band 13, it doesn't support LTE bands 2, 4 or 17 that come with the GSM unlocked version, so you will not get LTE on ATT or T-Mobile.

There is zero reason to get the ATT version what so ever, none, zilch. It's sim locked (though you could ask ATT to unlock it I guess), cannot unlock bootloader. The T-Mobile version is actually the unlocked version, it support every bands required by ATT, both 3G and LTE. T-Mobile version have unlocked sim and bootloader, doesn't have carrier logo nor carrier bloatwares.

Then there is the unlocked GSM Developer Edition which allow you to unlock bootloader without losing warranty, is similar to regular T-Mobile unlocked edition, except that it lacks T-Mobile AWS 3G band. You can get the Dev edition for Verizon as well which have the same bands support as the regular Verizon version. You can not unlock the bootloader for the regular version of ATT and Verizon.

sent via my Le Motonovo X
So you're saying I could get the Verizon Dev Moto X, and theoretically toss a ATT SIM in it and it will work on ATT (3G-only)? Has anyone tried this?
 
eksasol
Old
#5  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 692
Posts: 2,741
Join Date: Nov 2009
I can't guarantee it, but that should be the case, all new Verizon phones have unlocked sim on the GSM side, if they don't they would violate the FCC agreement.

We had a discussion on this, see here: http://forum.xda-developers.com/show....php?t=2551692

sent via my Le Motonovo X
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes