Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,737,266 Members 40,063 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

[BUG] USB OTG - could we get some N4 community members to help raise this issue

Tip us?
 
parker09
Old
#1  
parker09's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 159
Posts: 883
Join Date: Apr 2010
Default [BUG] USB OTG - could we get some N4 community members to help raise this issue

Hey, I purchased a 16GB model, with the intent of using USB OTG to use in conjunction with USB flash drives like we can with basically all other phones these days - but obviously it's still my fault for purchasing on the first day without knowing that USB OTG isn't supported on the Nexus 4.

Now that it's pretty much all but confirmed that USB OTG isn't working on Mako, maybe we could star the 'bug' on the official android bug report website, and maybe at a comment to voice opinions that some of you (as well as me).

If we all star it & maybe add a comment, it could help?

http://code.google.com/p/android/iss...sort=&id=40087


Primary devices:

..... LG/Google Nexus 5: Android 4.4.2
..... Acer W510: Windows 8.1

Retired devices:

..... LG/Google Nexus 4: Android 4.4
..... HTC HD2: Windows Phone 7.8
..... HTC Legend: Android 4.0
..... UG802 USB: Android 4.0
..... Acer A500: Android 4.3
eparker.me
 
wmm
Old
#2  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 65
Posts: 661
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Sudbury, MA
Please don't add a comment. As noted in that thread, adding a comment spams everyone who has previously commented or starred. If you have something new to add, fine, but if you're just posting "Yeah, this stinks!" or the equivalent, please refrain.

(Anyhow, I'm not sure how much that bug report will help; it seems most likely that the hardware just doesn't support USB host mode.)
 
parker09
Old
#3  
parker09's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 159
Posts: 883
Join Date: Apr 2010
Quote:
Originally Posted by wmm View Post
Please don't add a comment. As noted in that thread, adding a comment spams everyone who has previously commented or starred. If you have something new to add, fine, but if you're just posting "Yeah, this stinks!" or the equivalent, please refrain.
Okay.

Quote:
Originally Posted by wmm View Post
(Anyhow, I'm not sure how much that bug report will help; it seems most likely that the hardware just doesn't support USB host mode.)
I'm holding out hope that it's a software issue at this time until it's confirmed by Google. I know they wrote Mako can't supply 5V but even with a powered USB hub devices don't work.

http://support.google.com/nexus/bin/...9758&ctx=topic



Primary devices:

..... LG/Google Nexus 5: Android 4.4.2
..... Acer W510: Windows 8.1

Retired devices:

..... LG/Google Nexus 4: Android 4.4
..... HTC HD2: Windows Phone 7.8
..... HTC Legend: Android 4.0
..... UG802 USB: Android 4.0
..... Acer A500: Android 4.3
eparker.me
 
l3iggs
Old
#4  
Member
Thanks Meter 17
Posts: 31
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Palo Alto
I'm not entirely sure this is a bug. It may be a design choice combined with poor documentation.

Look here:
http://support.google.com/nexus/bin/...9758&ctx=topic
This page clearly says "USB is not supported for connecting such devices."

It appears to me that USB OTG is not supported on the nexus 4.
We can keep our fingers crossed that this is fixable via a software/firmware update. Although I'm concerned that that USB OTG is hardware incompatible with the Slimport display solution LG has chosen. Both USB OTG and slimport display use the micro USB connector's pin #4 for different purposes. USB OTG needs a cable that pulls it to ground to indicate to the phone that it should operate in USB host mode. I'm less familiar with slimport, but from what I've read it seems to perform some signaling on pin 4 to enable and stream video.

If the two really are mutually exclusive, I personally wish they had ditched slimport in favor of USB OTG since I can (eventually) mirror the display using miracast.
 
thesavvymage
Old
#5  
thesavvymage's Avatar
Member
Thanks Meter 3
Posts: 38
Join Date: Sep 2012

 
DONATE TO ME
Quote:
Originally Posted by l3iggs View Post
I'm not entirely sure this is a bug. It may be a design choice combined with poor documentation.

Look here:
http://support.google.com/nexus/bin/...9758&ctx=topic
This page clearly says "USB is not supported for connecting such devices."

It appears to me that USB OTG is not supported on the nexus 4.
We can keep our fingers crossed that this is fixable via a software/firmware update. Although I'm concerned that that USB OTG is hardware incompatible with the Slimport display solution LG has chosen. Both USB OTG and slimport display use the micro USB connector's pin #4 for different purposes. USB OTG needs a cable that pulls it to ground to indicate to the phone that it should operate in USB host mode. I'm less familiar with slimport, but from what I've read it seems to perform some signaling on pin 4 to enable and stream video.

If the two really are mutually exclusive, I personally wish they had ditched slimport in favor of USB OTG since I can (eventually) mirror the display using miracast.
They just updated that page today (dec 6 depending where you are). So it clearly says that... only after the phone has been out 3 weeks until today the documentation said it should work. they basically just said "yes it works" and then a month later said "lol jk no it doesnt"


Wishlist for a perfect android phone: Stock Android | MicroSD Slot | Big Battery | DONE!
Nexus 4 was so close...
 
taitony
Old
#6  
taitony's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 29
Posts: 214
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Taipei

 
DONATE TO ME
It is not the issue when ChainFire update his Stickmount to 2.1.


Phone:
Google Nexus 4 16GB
ROM: Stock Android 4.4 KitKat
Kernel: Stock

Tablet:
New Google Nexus 7 2013 (WiFi, 16GB)
ROM: Stock Android 4.4 KitKat
Kernel: Stock

Huawei S7 Slim (3G+WiFi, 8GB)

Netbook:
Acer AO722 running Windows 8.1 Pro

Follow me on Twitter
Joint me on Facebook
 
petraman
Old
(Last edited by petraman; 7th December 2012 at 04:59 PM.)
#7  
Member
Thanks Meter 3
Posts: 70
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: Granville, OH
Quote:
Originally Posted by taitony View Post
It is not the issue when ChainFire update his Stickmount to 2.1.
Quoted on the app's page in the play store...

Quote:
The Nexus 4 is not supported - this is an issue with the device, not with StickMount !
If you're holding out hope, I appreciate your optimism but it probably isn't going to happen... I'm considering calling up Play support and asking for a refund so I can get a 16gb, even though that probably won't happen for a few weeks,

BTW... just called the play store. They will NOT return your device because of this issue. Even for an exchange (I just wanted a 16gb) I don't understand their logic but because they changed their documentation, I guess that removes them of liability... IMO that does nothing of the source. I'm filing a BBB report now, which is something I never thought I'd do to google... this is BS.
 
@rbiter
Old
#8  
@rbiter's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 957
Posts: 4,056
Join Date: Dec 2011
Class action is probably the best way to handle this. I'd much rather have USB host mode.

I voided my warranty.
 
PoisonWolf
Old
#9  
PoisonWolf's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 472
Posts: 2,103
Join Date: Feb 2009
I bought the Nexus 4 under the assumption that I could at least get USB OTG to satisfy the lack of a micro SD card. FML.
Past successful purchases - kmdub with AT&T Palm Pre Plus(link).
-
 
USSENTERNCC1701E
Old
#10  
USSENTERNCC1701E's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 287
Posts: 1,235
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Logan
Quote:
Originally Posted by petraman View Post
Quoted on the app's page in the play store...



If you're holding out hope, I appreciate your optimism but it probably isn't going to happen... I'm considering calling up Play support and asking for a refund so I can get a 16gb, even though that probably won't happen for a few weeks,

BTW... just called the play store. They will NOT return your device because of this issue. Even for an exchange (I just wanted a 16gb) I don't understand their logic but because they changed their documentation, I guess that removes them of liability... IMO that does nothing of the source. I'm filing a BBB report now, which is something I never thought I'd do to google... this is BS.
Call again and talk to someone else, as long as you are within the return window, you can return for any reason at all, with a restocking fee.

Or you could scalp it on ebay to and make money on the whole deal :shrug: I'm just glad I didn't know about OTG when I purchased it, or I would have gone 8GB.

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes