New Proposed HD2 Forum Hierarchy. Your votes are Important!!!

dharvey4651 · Jan 2, 2011

EVERYONE CHECK THIS OUT:
http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=910761

This should help to keep the forum organized. As more and more OS's are ported to and working on the HD2, the forum WILL be forced to grow. The site administration thinks the HD2 forum is just fine as it is so please vote so we can make it happen!!!!

Please vote and let your voice be heard!!

Proposed HD2 Forum Hierarchy(Proposed by XDA User: "mattwaddy" first, tweaked by me to better suite the forum):

FINAL DRAFT BELOW
Not accepting other suggestions from this point on.

(BOLD = Forum Title - Forum description is below title and is not bold)

HTC Leo: HD2
(International, T-Mobile US)

HD2 General Discussion
General Discussion about the HTC HD2 - Unrelated to available OS's.

HD2 Accessories
Accessories for the HTC HD2 (Cases, screen protectors, batteries, etc)

HD2 WM6.5(x)
General Discussion, Q&A, Themes, Apps and ROM Development

--------------> WM6.5(x) Q&A and General Discussion
--------------> For all your questions and General Discussion regarding WM6.5(x) on your HTC HD2
--------------> WM6.5(x) Themes & Apps
--------------> Themes & Apps for your WM6.5(x) HTC HD2
--------------> WM6.5(x) ROM Development
--------------> ROM Development for your HTC HD2 - WM6.5 & WM6.5(x)

Click to expand...

Click to collapse

HD2 Android
General Discussion, Q&A, Themes, Apps and ROM Development

--------------> HD2 Android Q&A and General Discussion
--------------> For all your questions and General Discussion regarding Android on your HTC HD2
--------------> HD2 Android Themes & Apps
--------------> Themes and apps for your Android HTC HD2
--------------> HD2 Android SD ROM Development
--------------> Development of Android to be run off the SD Card on the HTC HD2
--------------> HD2 Android NAND ROM Development
--------------> Development of Android to be run from NAND on the HTC HD2

Click to expand...

Click to collapse

HD2 Ubuntu
General Discussion, Q&A, Themes, Apps and ROM Development

--------------> HD2 Ubuntu Q&A and General Discussion
--------------> For all your questions and General Discussion regarding Ubuntu on your HTC HD2
--------------> HD2 Ubuntu Themes & Apps
--------------> Themes and apps for your Ubuntu HTC HD2
--------------> HD2 Ubuntu ROM Development
--------------> Ubuntu ROM Development for your HTC HD2

Click to expand...

Click to collapse

HD2 Meego
General Discussion, Q&A, Themes, Apps and ROM Development

--------------> HD2 Meego Q&A and General Discussion
--------------> For all your questions and General Discussion regarding Meego on your HTC HD2
--------------> HD2 Meego Themes & Apps
--------------> Themes and apps for your Meego HTC HD2
--------------> HD2 Meego ROM Development
--------------> Meego ROM Development for your HTC HD2

Click to expand...

Click to collapse

HD2 WP7
General Discussion, Q&A, Themes, Apps and ROM Development

--------------> HD2 WP7 Q&A and General Discussion
--------------> For all your questions and General Discussion regarding WP7 on your HTC HD2
--------------> HD2 WP7 Themes & Apps
--------------> Themes and apps for your WP7 HTC HD2
--------------> HD2 WP7 ROM Development
--------------> WP7 ROM Development for your HTC HD2

Click to expand...

Click to collapse

Click to expand...

Click to collapse

simax · Jan 2, 2011

i think that would be the right way

oops delete me, just read only vote sry

DHARQAXIAN · Jan 3, 2011

Please delete.

Sorry didn see the instructions saying not to post till too late and now I cannot delete it

dharvey4651 · Jan 3, 2011

DHARQAXIAN said:
Vote Yes or No = YES.

I'm not sure I follow... If you vote "Yes" your vote will be pinned to yes. If you vote "No" your vote will be pinned to no.

atomical007 · Jan 3, 2011

Voted.

Oh! Sorry.I just saw the instruction above.You should wrote it at the first line and highlight it.

psyCORe · Jan 3, 2011

I think its good idea
Im proposing for TM HD2 version merge under HD2 sub (because they were sharing with same Android developement

michael9196 · Jan 3, 2011

Mybad-------

ATomCZ · Jan 3, 2011

I'm a little bit disappointed. I hoped that will be possible new android build try first time from SD and then best of them flash to NAND, because of testing on SD card is a much easier. But now development of SD and NAND is completely separated. I don't think that this is best, but I understand that too much thread is not good.

AS78 · Jan 3, 2011

Perfect - a no-brainer: simple, organised, categorised and scalable. Do it!

stami1234 · Jan 3, 2011

very good idea!!

stephandelaat · Jan 3, 2011

Maybe @ Ram roms, other then that it looks perfect. I definately voted yes!!!

HD2 Android

--------------> HD2 Android General Discussion
--------------> HD2 Android Q&A
--------------> HD2 Android Themes & Apps
--------------> HD2 Android SD Build/ROM Devlopment
--------------> HD2 Android RAM Build/ROM Devlopment
--------------> HD2 Android NAND Build/ROM Devlopment

dazza9075 · Jan 3, 2011

its a sound idea, i would actually love to read what it is that admins etc do not like about ideas like this, its clear it makes sense and as things go mental with WP7 and android running from NAND its only going to get worse in the existing structure.

Logic i fear does not come in to it and i suspect it'l be something along the lines of...."you people (by that i mean us) are all too stupid to work out where to post"

Thats the kind of mentality they have with everything else so id love to actually hear from the horses mouth their reasoning.

myx4ever · Jan 3, 2011

stephandelaat said:
Maybe @ Ram roms

HD2 Android

--------------> HD2 Android General Discussion
--------------> HD2 Android Q&A
--------------> HD2 Android Themes & Apps
--------------> HD2 Android SD/RAM Builds/ROM Devlopment
--------------> HD2 Android NAND Build/ROM Devlopment

My guess is that in time, with nand android becoming more and more reliable all these SD/RAM ver will merge to NAND.
People who like dual-booting will find the best suited SD ver and keep it for a longer period and will not want to flash everyday but only when major updates are available.
So my suggestion is to only differentiate SD/RAM to NAND builds.

In time NAND will be the way to go and SD will fall behind.

As for the entire HD2 tree, I'm not sure if it's necessary to create meego, ubuntu, etc sections.
i would make only wm6.5/android/wp7/other builds subsections.

jetsetwilly · Jan 3, 2011

Looks good to me but what happens when people start having builds which use RAM and NAND or NAND and SD?

stoolzo · Jan 3, 2011

I voted YES for this as i believe the forum needs a rethink but, just to open a possible can of worms... separating SD from NAND may mean cooks concentrate on one type of build rather than both, probably NAND leaving those SD users out in the cold -because cooks might not want to post two separate threads for a release.

Another suggestion:

HD2 GENERAL

HD2 Winmo ROM dev
HD2 Winmo Q&A
HD2 Winmo Apps and Themes

HD2 NAND Android Dev
HD2 NAND Q&A

HD2 MULTIBUILD (NAND/SD/RAM) ROM Android Dev
HD2 MULTIBUILD (NAND/SD/RAM) ROM Q&Q

HD2 SD & RAM ROM Dev
HD2 SD & RAM ROM Q&A

HD2 Android APPS & THEMES
HD2 GENERAL

WINPHONE 7 DEV
WINPHONE 7 GENERAL

MEEGO DEV
MEEGO GENERAL

MEGO GENERAL

mattwaddy · Jan 3, 2011

The original idea I posted in the NAND Poll thread was this, I think we can work things out to get something that would be more future proof than the current setup. I think someone has linked to this thread from there as I seemed to have stirred up some discussion in there also

HD2 General
HD2 Q&A
HD2 Accessories
HD2 WM6.5
--------------> General Discussion
--------------> Q&A
--------------> Themes & Apps
--------------> Build Development
HD2 Android
--------------> General Discussion
--------------> Q&A
--------------> Themes & Apps
--------------> Build Development
>>>>>>>>>>>>---------------->NAND Builds
>>>>>>>>>>>>---------------->SD Builds
HD2 Ubuntu
--------------> General Discussion
--------------> Q&A
--------------> Themes & Apps
--------------> Build Development
HD2 Meego
--------------> General Discussion
HD2 WP7
--------------> General Discussion

dazza9075 · Jan 3, 2011

too late, they did something already, NAND has its home

lezink · Jan 3, 2011

jetsetwilly said:
Looks good to me but what happens when people start having builds which use RAM and NAND or NAND and SD?

Basically, I think that the most simple is to concentrate on how the rom boots :

if it boots from SD => subforum SD android, nevermind if it is pure SD or SD+RAM (could be written in the topic's subject for example)

if it boots from NAND => subforum NAND android, nevermind if it uses a Ramdisk or SD for data.img (idem. could be mentionned in the subject)

Considering this, I wonder if a subforum "RAM android" is really necessary as a RAM android is either based on SD build or based on NAND build

just my 2 cent....

VinZ

fuzzmello · Jan 3, 2011

I propose each new section include a header for thanks, uncontrollable urges to make personal comments and the like. Trying to follow a thread can become all but impossible to do amid the high-fiving competitions. I'm happy that there's a spirit of community here and I'm thankful that the moderators foster that community, but it does get in the way of trying to learn something.

shubh.27hd2 · Jan 3, 2011

Nice idea..

New Proposed HD2 Forum Hierarchy. Your votes are Important!!!

Should the HD2 Forum be re-organized like shown below?

Yes.

No.

Retired Senior Moderator

Senior Member

Senior Member

Retired Senior Moderator

Senior Member

Senior Member

Member

Senior Member

Member

Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Member

Senior Member

Similar threads

Top Liked Posts