I've tried several roms from XDA, and I gotta say the devs are amazing.
I'm using SCOMv3 right now
Smoothness: 9/10 , im experiencing lag within the browser not really sure why. otherwise its great.
Battery: not sure havent had it long enough
Features: 10/10 ove MIUI stuff you put on plus custom lock screens and the radio tweak is actually really good - is it KC1?
Theme: 7/10 not a big fan of red although a lot of you guys seem to love it
btw i think the status bar is way too transparant which makes the toggle buttons look awkward over the home screen.
Stability : Not sure, haven't had it long enough but so far so good
ICBINB:
Smoothness : 9/10 probably the fastest rom i used.
Battery: 9/10, battery life for icbinb was better for me than any other rom. used to have 50% left even after a full day of moderate use.
Features : 7/10 I'm not a fan of stock samsung but this rom was did exactly as advertised really stable and fast.
Stability: 10/10 dont think i ever FCed.
AOSP (airflip)
Smoothness : 9/10 scroll lagged time to time but other wise good
Battery : 8/10 not the ebst but certainly not the worst
Features : 9/10 great features, and no bloats.
Stability: 9/10 very stable almost never fced
Theme: 8/10 i like the lock screen and stock gingerbread better than anything stock samsung offers but still wish theme was more creative.
VB:
smoothness : 7/10 I had a lot of problems, it was either really smooth or really laggy for me.
Battery : 9/10 probably as good as ICBINB
Features : 9/10 i love all the ICS custom features, lock screens and DSP however the DSP caused a lot of skips.
Theme: 10/10 love ICS look - by far the cleanest and nicest theme on any roms.
Stability: 7/10 i kept crashing (specially using launcher pro), randomly restarting
I honestly hate MIUI despite the plethora of roms and eye candy its too much like iOS for me.
I love VB but i had a lot of stability issues can you guys recommend tweaks or radios you use with VB for better performance? I used lightning zap with vb and it bootlooped on me, i also used the vb booster which was good but did not get rid of FCs.