[Q] S5 ou LG G3

C

Canard caché

Senior Member

May 9, 2010

431

38

• Jun 12, 2014

• #1

Hello,

My biggest concern about ist the camera...
The S3 was incredible in his time... a real revolution for me.
The S4 was good in good conditions but the camera angle + the noise + low lights were ugly!

And now with this generation, what's the best?

The S5 ist incredible in good conditions BUT the noise ist so persistent!
And in low light ist only ugly...

Lg G3 can be better?

Thanx

 

M

mjjferreira

Senior Member

Dec 18, 2006

136

15

45

Oeiras

• Jun 12, 2014

• #2

No, the G3 in low light is also very noisy!

 

C

Canard caché

Senior Member

May 9, 2010

431

38

• Jun 12, 2014

• #3

mjjferreira said:

No, the G3 in low light is also very noisy!

Click to expand...

Click to collapse

So the s5 is a better choice?

 

M

mjjferreira

Senior Member

Dec 18, 2006

136

15

45

Oeiras

• Jun 12, 2014

• #4

Yes, but by a tiny margin.

 

C

Canard caché

Senior Member

May 9, 2010

431

38

• Jun 12, 2014

• #5

mjjferreira said:

Yes, but by a tiny margin.

Click to expand...

Click to collapse

ok how tiny...?
Because the aspect of the s5 is (for me) ugly... so

I use sometimes these photos (took by phonecam) in web project.

I bieleved taht the stabilizator and the laser autofocus might make the photos better in low light...

Edit:

When you see these (in low light): there is so more noise in s5...? http://www.cnet.com/news/lg-g3s-laser-equipped-camera-put-to-the-test/

 

Last edited: Jun 12, 2014

dondavis007

Senior Member

Aug 10, 2010

1,852

378

Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra

• Jun 12, 2014

• #6

Few phones of today is worse than the S5 in low light. The G2 was also horrible and looked like watercolor if the autofokus ever found the subject. What I have heard the G3 is clearly the better pic between S5 and G3. But... If you want to be able to use the phone better indoors you need a phone like One or iPhone, you can't beat those indoor. But the S5 is great outdoor for sure, but even the G2 was good to.

Sent from a mobile Gadget...

 

C

Canard caché

Senior Member

May 9, 2010

431

38

• Jun 12, 2014

• #7

dondavis007 said:

Few phones of today is worse than the S5 in low light. The G2 was also horrible and looked like watercolor if the autofokus ever found the subject. What I have heard the G3 is clearly the better pic between S5 and G3. But... If you want to be able to use the phone better indoors you need a phone like One or iPhone, you can't beat those indoor. But the S5 is great outdoor for sure, but even the G2 was good to.

Sent from a mobile Gadget...

Click to expand...

Click to collapse

Thx for the reply.... mmmmm i hesitate so much...
But i have a s4 so when ill go s5 or g3 i'll have a upgrade no?

 

N

neoxkid

Senior Member

Sep 12, 2009

153

12

• Jun 14, 2014

• #8

what about focus time in the dark? in my G2 it takes ages to focus on object and when it taking the photo it is already lost the moment. is it the same in G3?

 

dondavis007

Senior Member

Aug 10, 2010

1,852

378

Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra

• Jun 14, 2014

• #9

Use the G2 pro camera and you'll have a much better experience with the G2.

Sent from a mobile Gadget...

 

I

ipmanwck

Senior Member

Apr 9, 2012

3,090

555

England

Xiaomi Mi 11 Ultra

Google Pixel 7 Pro

• Jun 15, 2014

• #10

Thanks. Nice useful topic. Most camera phones will have motion blur with low light.

Sent from my HTC One X+ using XDA Premium 4 mobile app

 

C

Canard caché

Senior Member

May 9, 2010

431

38

• Jun 15, 2014

• #11

ipmanwck said:

Thanks. Nice useful topic. Most camera phones will have motion blur with low light.

Sent from my HTC One X+ using XDA Premium 4 mobile app

Click to expand...

Click to collapse

mmm ios + laser => less blurry photo

 

N

neoxkid

Senior Member

Sep 12, 2009

153

12

• Jun 16, 2014

• #12

Canard caché said:

mmm ios + laser => less blurry photo

Click to expand...

Click to collapse

But what about focus time in the night? is it better then G2?

 

A

amankapoor4

Senior Member

Mar 2, 2008

742

126

Bangalore

• Jun 16, 2014

• #13

S5 prices are on freefall, the touchwiz is a lag god. I would any day pick G3 over S5. Even in blind camera test in phonearena, S5 just finished 3 votes ahead of S5. So camera re identical, now look at better things, Bigger and the latest screen tech. Almost same weight(145 vs 149), more ram (3 gig vs 2 gig). S5 has finger print scanner which hardly works, the waterproofing is nifty though.

Lookwise G3 looks way better then S5, with S5 you never know if it is a grand or what.

 

C

Canard caché

Senior Member

May 9, 2010

431

38

• Jun 16, 2014

• #14

neoxkid said:

But what about focus time in the night? is it better then G2?

Click to expand...

Click to collapse

It seems (yeah not a lot!)

http://www.lesnumeriques.com/appareil-photo-numerique/face-a-face/70252224f05e498be0a18cff107f7c0f13c68ae9

 

Last edited: Jun 16, 2014

Baccer

Senior Member

May 12, 2010

97

8

Stuttgart

• Jun 16, 2014

• #15

amankapoor4 said:

S5 prices are on freefall, the touchwiz is a lag god. I would any day pick G3 over S5. Even in blind camera test in phonearena, S5 just finished 3 votes ahead of S5. So camera re identical, now look at better things, Bigger and the latest screen tech. Almost same weight(145 vs 149), more ram (3 gig vs 2 gig). S5 has finger print scanner which hardly works, the waterproofing is nifty though.

Lookwise G3 looks way better then S5, with S5 you never know if it is a grand or what.

Click to expand...

Click to collapse

another reason to buy the G3: 32GB internal memory for a good price. the G3 599 Euro with wireless charging device :good: @ Amazon.de and the S5 32GB not even available at amazon.de, other shops: black one 999 Euro, white one 712 Euro.