My precious icon, my Legend.
I like the mechanical buttons... one nice thing about the Legend is it having a "menu" key - always in the same place, even in ICS.
This.
Part from the fact that my Menu button is slightly soft (almost like it's lost a pin that holds it's left side).
I've had it since... well almost 2 years as well and while it's slow and all that it's a great phone and even though I've had it on S-ON all this time I've installed and edited various ROMs and currently running CM7, but will install Blay0's awesome Sense ROM when I get my HTC One X.
Don't know if I will sell my Legend or let it collect dust.
If I decide to let it collect dust, it'll really become a legend since it was my first phone since Nokia 6500-S and first Android phone as well.
Don't hate the Legend, it hates you for giving up.
It's like a tsundere girl, hard to please and hard to manage but damn attached to you and vise versa.