5,605,835 Members 48,076 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

Quick Review of the Incipio NGP, AT&T Gel and Case-Mate Tough Case

Tip us?
 
LordGreylock
Old
(Last edited by LordGreylock; 24th April 2012 at 03:22 AM.)
#1  
LordGreylock's Avatar
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 4
Posts: 38
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Northwest CT
Default Quick Review of the Incipio NGP, AT&T Gel and Case-Mate Tough Case

I got 3 cases for my Lumia 900 and wanted to do a quick review of them so that it could help some of you guys decide one which ones to buy.
Prices listed are directly from the manufacturers website, I am sure you could find them cheaper elsewhere.

Incipio NGP
Price: $19.99

This case isn't too thick but it is thicker than the AT&T Gel case and will offer more protection against drops. Incipio's NGP is a TPU style case, so it's more stiff than traditional silicone cases and it doesn't attract any lint. The fit is very tight and leaves all the ports open, and covers all the buttons.
The only issue I had with this case was that the buttons are a bit tough to press. Especially when taking photos because it's hard to press the camera button on it's first stage for focus, I found it was a bit frustrating when using this case and taking photos. Other than that it's a very nice TPU style case that isn't too expensive.

AT&T Gel
Price: $20.00

This is more of a silicone type case, it's very flexible and has a smooth feel and doesn't attract lint. All the ports are left open, the buttons are covered.
This case is awesome if you like the look and feel of a naked phone because you can hardly tell this case is on the phone. The buttons are very easy to press. It does offer some protection but not as much as the Incipio NGP. I really enjoyed this case due to the fact that it feels like there's no case on the phone at all. It's not too pricey at 20 bucks.

Case-Mate Tough Case
Price: $35.00

This case has an inner soft silicone piece and an outer polycarbonate shell that fits over the silicone. The shell also has a rubbery coating. This case is the thickest of the three, it is also the most protective against drops. I really like this case due to the protection it offers. It fits very well.
This case seems like something Otterbox would have made, it reminds me of their commuter series cases. It leaves all the ports open, it covers the buttons and they are easy to press. The one thing to note is the camera cutout is much small than the other two cases which I personally like, that means that little chrome strip in the back is less likely to get scratched up.
The silicone on this case does collect a bit of lint which is kind of annoying. It's a bit of a trade-off for the protection. It fits very well and looks good. It does thicken the phone up a good amount but that doesn't bother me personally.
Overall it's a very nice case, and the best choice if you want protection, a little more expensive than the others but you are getting something more protective.

[Unfortunately I don't have enough posts to add my link to all the photos I took... :(
The Following User Says Thank You to LordGreylock For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
EggNogg421
Old
#2  
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 7
Join Date: Dec 2011
I also have the Incipio NGP case in Translucent Mercury and I have also noticed that it is hard to press the buttons. I'm not sure if my case is bad but it looks like the buttons on the case are about 1-2mm lower than the buttons on the phone which I think is causing the button problem.

I also have the casemate barely there case in black which matches with the phone color really well. My only problem with the case mate is the top and the bottom of the phone is exposed with no coverage. the only top and bottom protection seems to come from the case being a little longer than the phone causing a some what annoying over hang.

I'm kinda new here too so I can't post any pictures but I will try too when I am able too.
 
LordGreylock
Old
#3  
LordGreylock's Avatar
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 4
Posts: 38
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Northwest CT
I thought about purchasing the barely there case but it just doesn't offer the protection I need. I am pretty happy with their Tough Case though.
 
LordGreylock
Old
#4  
LordGreylock's Avatar
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 4
Posts: 38
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Northwest CT
I wanted to update this now and post the link to the photos, so here they are!
 
dfkd
Old
#5  
Member
Thanks Meter 2
Posts: 39
Join Date: Jan 2009
Thanks for the photos.

Just what I wanted to see.
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes