I like the Droid 4 because I love having a physical keyboard. But the PenTile screen just makes my eyes sad.
I like the Droid Razr Maxx because I would love to have a full day of heavy use on the phone without needing to find an outlet. But I keep hearing people say that the battery life just isn't quite as good as advertised.
I like the Galaxy Note, because more screen real estate is always nice to have. But I'm afraid it's just a bit TOO big to be comfortable to use as a day-to-day phone.
I like the Galaxy S3 because it's pure cell phone bliss. But it's not out yet.
So, in other words...I'll stick with my DInc2 at least until the next generation of phones comes out. The level of advancement is so rapid in this field, that it's easy to burn through money to always have "the next big thing". If I'm satisfied with what I have, I just enjoy it as long I can.
LG G2 - Daily Driver - Stock, Rooted
Sony Xperia Play - GrooveIP WiFi home phone / Gaming Device - xEliteGamer 1.7
Kindle Fire - Hashcode Stock JB 4.2.2 / Hashcode kernel
Motorola Droid 4 - Work Phone - Stock, against my choice
Galaxy Nexus - Ubuntu Touch testbed
Retired: Droid Incredible 2, Droid Charge, EeePC Android x86, OG Droid, OG Droid #2