Introducing XDA:DevCon – A Conference For Developers By Developers
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum
Forgot your password?
 
Post Reply+
Tip us?
 
Falcyn
Old
(Last edited by Falcyn; 24th June 2012 at 08:02 PM.)
#1631  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 33
Posts: 338
Join Date: Jan 2010
The calibration app thing is a complete and total myth that's been directly debunked by Google.

All that app does is delete the batterystats.bin file, which has no bearing whatsoever on your battery life or even the battery level shown to you.

It is the literal definition of "placebo effect" and anyone who says otherwise is either lying or misinformed.

https://plus.google.com/105051985738...ts/FV3LVtdVxPT
 
o0BlacknesS0o
Old
#1632  
o0BlacknesS0o's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 1592
Posts: 2,246
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Fincastle, VA

 
DONATE TO ME
Quote:
Originally Posted by Falcyn View Post
The calibration app thing is a complete and total myth that's been directly debunked by Google.

All that app does is delete the batterystats.bin file, which has no bearing whatsoever on your battery life or even the battery level shown to you.

It is the literal definition of "placebo effect" and anyone who says otherwise is either lying or misinformed.

https://plus.google.com/105051985738...ts/FV3LVtdVxPT
Pretty sure there is absolutely nothing in my post that says it will increase your battery life.

Second, wiping the stats, and then letting your phone drain all the way down will give you a very accurate look at what is draining your battery

Third, how is the app a myth? You can download it in the market, it's real...and it does exactly what it says it does...deletes the battery stats

Fourth, it has been proven that fully charging, fully discharging, then fully charging again is not only good for your battery, it is highly recommended by anyone and everyone at least once a month

So, I'm thinking you should jump off your little soap box and make sure you actually read what is being posted before you try to tear it apart...Before anyone goes and spend money on a brand new battery, they should do some accurate researching about what is using power on their phone....could be a crazy app...could be low network signal, could be the kernel (which btw jco23 has found that the 0504 kernel is much more battery efficient than the other available kernels) etc...


Oh and btw...i used to get some random fluctuations in battery levels when i first flashed tweaked...i wiped my battery stats, cache and dalvik and everything calm down and no longer did my battery jump down oddly

Droid Charge energized by TSM Tweaked 2.2 ext4 PBJ w/ Transparent ICS 4.0
The Following User Says Thank You to o0BlacknesS0o For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
Reilly1812
Old
#1633  
Reilly1812's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 104
Posts: 328
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: West Long Branch, NJ
FWIW - batteries, even the extended ones, are cheap enough to keep a charged spare, regardless of the reason.

Toubleshooting simplified. Swap the battery. No problem? Toss it. Problem persists? It's not the battery and bonus - you've got a spare.
 
nismology
Old
#1634  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 27
Posts: 171
Join Date: Jul 2010
Completely discharging Li-ion batteries is not the best idea, even just on a monthly basis. And in my experience, charging the battery completely clears out the batterystats file every time so there's no need to use an app to do it.


Kernels are by far the biggest potential battery drain other than partial wakelocks and the stock FP1 kernel has given me phenomenal battery life and I prefer the way FP1 handles multitasking and memory management versus the method implemented in the 0524 PBJT kernel. I also freeze all the services that I have no need for like anything DRM-related, SDM, syncmlsvc, etc.
 
shrike1978
Old
#1635  
shrike1978's Avatar
Recognized Contributor
Thanks Meter 2962
Posts: 3,328
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Atlanta, GA

 
DONATE TO ME
Quote:
Originally Posted by o0BlacknesS0o View Post
Pretty sure there is absolutely nothing in my post that says it will increase your battery life.

Second, wiping the stats, and then letting your phone drain all the way down will give you a very accurate look at what is draining your battery

Third, how is the app a myth? You can download it in the market, it's real...and it does exactly what it says it does...deletes the battery stats

Fourth, it has been proven that fully charging, fully discharging, then fully charging again is not only good for your battery, it is highly recommended by anyone and everyone at least once a month

So, I'm thinking you should jump off your little soap box and make sure you actually read what is being posted before you try to tear it apart...Before anyone goes and spend money on a brand new battery, they should do some accurate researching about what is using power on their phone....could be a crazy app...could be low network signal, could be the kernel (which btw jco23 has found that the 0504 kernel is much more battery efficient than the other available kernels) etc...


Oh and btw...i used to get some random fluctuations in battery levels when i first flashed tweaked...i wiped my battery stats, cache and dalvik and everything calm down and no longer did my battery jump down oddly

Droid Charge energized by TSM Tweaked 2.2 ext4 PBJ w/ Transparent ICS 4.0
Maybe you need to do some research yourself. Figuring out what is using battery is a good idea, but all you need to do that is Better Battery Stats (search XDA for a free version). If you read Dianne Hackborn's post that Falcyn linked above, she very clearly debunks your second point. As nimsology said, the stats are wiped by the OS every time you fully charge your battery (and you can prove this for yourself just by watching the filesystem). All they do is track the stats needed to display your battery use stats in settings. They have nothing to do with the calibration of your battery or the display of the percentages. The app is a myth in the same way that wiping your battery stats is...it does nothing useful whatsoever. It just deletes the same file that the phone deletes itself on a regular basis.

LiIon batteries work best when you just use them noramlly. Full charge/discharge cycles are actually bad for them in the long run. Keeping them cool is actually more important than anything else, which is why they have temp sensors and overheat protection circuits. The only time you should purposefully drain them is when you are storing them for long periods of time, and even then, you shouldn't fully drain them because fully discharging in storage will kill the battery completely.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LiIon#P...tery_pack_life
My HTC Rezound Development:
CounterShrike (Heavily modified CM9 - Aroma Installer) - PAC-Man (CM10/AOKP/Paranoid Android hybrid) - Ermahgerd Kernel (ICS/JB AOSP kernel)

My smartphone history: iPhone (Retired) - iPhone 3G (Retired) - iPhone 3GS (Retired) - Samsung Droid Charge (Retired) - HTC Rezound (Dev phone) - Samsung Galaxy Note II (Current)

All of my work is open source: My Github
Donations are never expected, but always appreciated.
 
Ted A
Old
#1636  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 15
Posts: 125
Join Date: Aug 2009
Quote:
Originally Posted by shrike1978 View Post
ATK can cause problems...it works against the built in task killer. Autokiller just tweaks the built in low memory killer.

Sent from my SCH-I510 using Tapatalk 2
Quote:
Originally Posted by kynalvarus View Post
There seems to be something about the Droid Charge that just isn't quite right. No matter what I try (and I've tried all sorts of things from these and other forums!) it just won't stay long-term stable. No matter what I do, eventually the Android System process, running com.android.providers.security and com.android.providers.settings, takes up enough CPU (25%+) and enough memory to make the phone lag. Once it gets bad enough, the phone will either hot boot or freeze, requiring a reboot.

I believe that a great deal of the lag is coming from the memory manager, especially on phones where the users have installed more services than can stay in memory simultaneously (as I have.) I've experimented with a number of OOM kill thresholds using Auto Memory Manger, and so far 12,18,24,46,62,78 has served me best.

I've also been swimming against the "prevent hot boots" trend of upping the VM Heap Size limit above 64MB. In my experience, the hot boots are happening when the memory manager gets stuck badly enough that it has to kill the Android System process. This is annoying if it happens when I'm trying to use the phone, but it's actually a good thing in the long run, because after the hot boot the phone loses most of its lag, and Android System drops to more like 10% of CPU use. I've actually found that cranking the heap down has led to better performance and less lagginess. I've gotten it down to 32MB without any serious stability issues. 24MB and 28MB were both apparently too small, as the phone behaved erratically at these settings and many apps, including my Go Launcher EX, were crash-looping fairly quickly.

For reference, I'm now running Tweaked 2.1 with the imnuts 0524 PBJ Kernel, 48MB VM Heap, 1.2GHz, default voltages, smartassV2 scheduler, bfq IO scheduler, and the zipalign, CFS, and siyah tweaks from tweaktools. I've also been playing with renice levels.
Thank you both.

When I first installed Autokiller Memory Optimizer (and uninstalled ATK), I set it to Extreme setting but it caused Go Launcher to repaint more often than I can endure. Now I've been using your setting (12,18,24,46,62,78) for nearly a day since the last time I rebooted, and it's been smooth and zippy! I'll try it for at least 3 days before attempting to reboot, which is probably going to be too tempting to do; good or bad, it's become an old habit of mine. lol
 
o0BlacknesS0o
Old
#1637  
o0BlacknesS0o's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 1592
Posts: 2,246
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Fincastle, VA

 
DONATE TO ME
Quote:
Originally Posted by shrike1978 View Post
Maybe you need to do some research yourself. Figuring out what is using battery is a good idea, but all you need to do that is Better Battery Stats (search XDA for a free version). If you read Dianne Hackborn's post that Falcyn linked above, she very clearly debunks your second point. As nimsology said, the stats are wiped by the OS every time you fully charge your battery (and you can prove this for yourself just by watching the filesystem). All they do is track the stats needed to display your battery use stats in settings. They have nothing to do with the calibration of your battery or the display of the percentages. The app is a myth in the same way that wiping your battery stats is...it does nothing useful whatsoever. It just deletes the same file that the phone deletes itself on a regular basis.

LiIon batteries work best when you just use them noramlly. Full charge/discharge cycles are actually bad for them in the long run. Keeping them cool is actually more important than anything else, which is why they have temp sensors and overheat protection circuits. The only time you should purposefully drain them is when you are storing them for long periods of time, and even then, you shouldn't fully drain them because fully discharging in storage will kill the battery completely.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LiIon#P...tery_pack_life
Apparently you guys are having trouble reading....AT NO POINT DO I SAY...DO THIS AND YOUR BATTERY WILL LAST LONGER...AT NO POINT DO I SAY THAT

Yes the battery stats gets deleted, but if you read what she says...she says that it gets deleted one gets around a full charge...with battery calibration he can choose exactly when he wants to wipe the stats...and thus begin watching his battery withdraw from the exact moment he wants to start


Again what's the myth part...the app does exactly what it says it does...it deletes the battery stats...also if you watch while the app is open you can see more charge go into battery even after it's full and the phone tells you to unplug

And lastly, i can't remember where the article is, but it was an article discussing batteries in smartphones, tablets, etc. The article found that it is more common than one might think that (especially) after modifications or flashing new roms that often times the device well begin to misread battery level info i.e. saying it has 35% then being dead 10 minutes later for no reason...one of the simplest ways to straighten this out is to fully drain the battery and then fully charge the battery.

AGAIN, IN NO WAY DID I TELL ANYONE THAT DOING THESE THINGS WILL MAKE YOUR BATTERY LIFE BETTER

and yes there are prolly 1000 apps he could download to get a more in depth look at his battery, but i haven't used any if them, so i have no need to suggest any of them...the built in works perfectly fine for me



Droid Charge energized by TSM Tweaked 2.2 ext4 PBJ w/ Transparent ICS 4.0
 
Reno Skyy
Old
#1638  
Reno Skyy's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 24
Posts: 261
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Las Vegas
Vibrate isn't working on the key board for me any one else with this problem?

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
 
dwitherell
Old
(Last edited by dwitherell; 25th June 2012 at 06:18 PM.)
#1639  
dwitherell's Avatar
Recognized Contributor - OP
Thanks Meter 2702
Posts: 1,876
Join Date: May 2011

 
DONATE TO ME
Quote:
Originally Posted by Reno Skyy View Post
Vibrate isn't working on the key board for me any one else with this problem?

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Yeah the themed keyboard one I put in there (thanks to imnuts and his Infinity rom) has always had that issue for whatever reason - never really bothered me so I just left it as-is.

As an aside regarding the recent battery discussions - shall we all agree to disagree and move on? Or at least move the discussion on to another thread? Feels poised to go south in a hurry is all, and the thread here is already a bit cumbersome.
If you like what I've done... I like sammiches so feel free to buy me one!
 
cujo6801
Old
#1640  
cujo6801's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 700
Posts: 1,571
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: San Diego,Ca.
Agreed ...let's move on...
Let's talk about me..
The fact that I can't find anything to complain about....
Makes me unhappy ....

SENT FROM THE DOG POUND
SENT FROM THE DOG POUND

The Following User Says Thank You to cujo6801 For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
Post Reply+
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

report this ad
Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Go to top of page...