Put mine on last night with no issues. There is very minimal orange peel. You have to turn off the screen and tilt it in the light to see it. In my opinion this depends on how hard you squeegee out the water. I did not apply a lot of pressure and I wrapped the cloth square it came with around the squeegee.
The rubbery feel is not an issue for me because I have somewhat oily hands. The spigen slim armor case worked perfect with this screen protector as well. I was using a terry cloth (used in the auto industry) to clean my previous screen protector but because of the stickiness of this protector I'm not able to. I'm still able to clean it easily with my shirt though. Overall I'm satisfied with this purchase.