5,595,428 Members 48,257 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

Lost my Z1, so then i bought a....

Tip us?
 
stealthj
Old
#1  
stealthj's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 92
Posts: 490
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Silicon Valley, California
Unhappy Lost my Z1, so then i bought a....

.....
A few weeks ago, i misplaced my Z1 in a public shopping mall table... i think...

...anyways, I'm on T-Mobile USA.
When I first got the phone in September, T-Mobile offered me insurance on the phone.
I went ahead and did a claim, and they said they couldn't get me the z1, and that the closest thing they have ( in price and what not) would be a Note 3.
They sent that to me, they unlocked it, and i sold it...
Dilemma began.... buy another z1? wait for Z1s? Could not do that because their bootloaders are not unlock-able

So what did I do? I saved some money and went ahead with a white 32gb nexus 5 while a friend of mine went ahead and actually bought the Z1s yesterday , and HERE are my first impressions of the differences between the two....

Nexus 5 over the Z1(c6903 and z1s):

Brighter, better screen with better viewing angles
Stock android software
Smaller size, fits easier in hand
Optical image stabilization (opinion)
Easier to root, hack etc.but then again its a nexus and it SHOULD have that
Lighter than the Z1
Messaging app on Z1 STILL does not implement group MMS, but you could always use hangouts ( not a big deal for some)

Sony Z1 over Nexus 5:

Z1 Has a premium feel to it, it feels like you are holding an expensive phone, at least when compared to the nexus 5
Z1 has a bigger battery, I was able to go through a full day of HEAVY usage with it, cannot do this with the Nexus
Z1 is waterproof, dustproof and you can use the camera underwater
Z1 has a microSD card slot in addition to the 16GB (or 32gb for the Z1s) of internal storage
the Z1s has a STRONGER ANTENNA THAN THE NEXUS 5, therefore allowing for better and faster data coverage and better voice quality (On T-Mobile USA)
the Z1 is faster even though the NExus is clocked at a higher speed, tested this with browser tests, game load times etc...

How do i know this? I placed the Z1S side by side with my Nexus 5, verified that they were connected to the same tower on LTE, and di some tests...

the Nexus 5 gave me 2 bars of signal, while the Z1s had Full bars, speedtest.net San Jose,CA gave Z1 ~23megabits down , Nexus 5 around 12 megabits down. Same server, phones side by side.
That part made me think about the decision I made. I Knew about all the other pros and cons of getting the Nexus, and I knew the Z1 kills it in benchmarks and what not but that does not really matter to me

The cellular reception part bothers me. I've always considered the nexus 5 to be a "different" phone, not worse than the Z1.

I can now say that the Z1 is overall a better phone.
Its faster, snappier, and feeds more power to its antenna I'm guessing?

Now i Will stick with my Nexus until the next sony flagship

Don't lose your Z1. If you do, buy another one.
Samsung SCH-3500
Motorola NexteL i860
Samsung D807
Nokia n91
HTC Kaiser
Nokia n95
Nokia n82
Nokia N97
HTC Glacier 4G
Nokia Lumia 800
Samsung GT-I9100
Galaxy Nexus
Nokia N9 (android 4.1)
Nokia PureView 808
Nexus 4
Razr M

Nexus 7 2
Sony Z1
The Following 7 Users Say Thank You to stealthj For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
Hanozy
Old
#2  
Hanozy's Avatar
Member
Thanks Meter 6
Posts: 58
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Sweden

 
DONATE TO ME
Quote:
Originally Posted by stealthj View Post
.....
A few weeks ago, i misplaced my Z1 in a public shopping mall table... i think...

...anyways, I'm on T-Mobile USA.
When I first got the phone in September, T-Mobile offered me insurance on the phone.
I went ahead and did a claim, and they said they couldn't get me the z1, and that the closest thing they have ( in price and what not) would be a Note 3.
They sent that to me, they unlocked it, and i sold it...
Dilemma began.... buy another z1? wait for Z1s? Could not do that because their bootloaders are not unlock-able

So what did I do? I saved some money and went ahead with a white 32gb nexus 5 while a friend of mine went ahead and actually bought the Z1s yesterday , and HERE are my first impressions of the differences between the two....

Nexus 5 over the Z1(c6903 and z1s):

Brighter, better screen with better viewing angles
Stock android software
Smaller size, fits easier in hand
Optical image stabilization (opinion)
Easier to root, hack etc.but then again its a nexus and it SHOULD have that
Lighter than the Z1
Messaging app on Z1 STILL does not implement group MMS, but you could always use hangouts ( not a big deal for some)

Sony Z1 over Nexus 5:

Z1 Has a premium feel to it, it feels like you are holding an expensive phone, at least when compared to the nexus 5
Z1 has a bigger battery, I was able to go through a full day of HEAVY usage with it, cannot do this with the Nexus
Z1 is waterproof, dustproof and you can use the camera underwater
Z1 has a microSD card slot in addition to the 16GB (or 32gb for the Z1s) of internal storage
the Z1s has a STRONGER ANTENNA THAN THE NEXUS 5, therefore allowing for better and faster data coverage and better voice quality (On T-Mobile USA)
the Z1 is faster even though the NExus is clocked at a higher speed, tested this with browser tests, game load times etc...

How do i know this? I placed the Z1S side by side with my Nexus 5, verified that they were connected to the same tower on LTE, and di some tests...

the Nexus 5 gave me 2 bars of signal, while the Z1s had Full bars, speedtest.net San Jose,CA gave Z1 ~23megabits down , Nexus 5 around 12 megabits down. Same server, phones side by side.
That part made me think about the decision I made. I Knew about all the other pros and cons of getting the Nexus, and I knew the Z1 kills it in benchmarks and what not but that does not really matter to me

The cellular reception part bothers me. I've always considered the nexus 5 to be a "different" phone, not worse than the Z1.

I can now say that the Z1 is overall a better phone.
Its faster, snappier, and feeds more power to its antenna I'm guessing?

Now i Will stick with my Nexus until the next sony flagship

Don't lose your Z1. If you do, buy another one.
Lesson learnt, always go for the Z1.

Skickat från min C6903 via Tapatalk
-Hanozy



If I helped you, click thanks
The Following User Says Thank You to Hanozy For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
AK4TAY7BEN
Old
#3  
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 3
Posts: 23
Join Date: Dec 2012
I have a nokia lumia 521 but I can't choose between the z1s or N5. I want to tweak my phone but cell reception is very important for me because where I live the reception sucks.
 
stealthj
Old
#4  
stealthj's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 92
Posts: 490
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Silicon Valley, California
Quote:
Originally Posted by AK4TAY7BEN View Post
I have a nokia lumia 521 but I can't choose between the z1s or N5. I want to tweak my phone but cell reception is very important for me because where I live the reception sucks.
Hopefully if enough people buy the Z1s, development will speed up. Feel free to ask me any differences between the two
Samsung SCH-3500
Motorola NexteL i860
Samsung D807
Nokia n91
HTC Kaiser
Nokia n95
Nokia n82
Nokia N97
HTC Glacier 4G
Nokia Lumia 800
Samsung GT-I9100
Galaxy Nexus
Nokia N9 (android 4.1)
Nokia PureView 808
Nexus 4
Razr M

Nexus 7 2
Sony Z1
The Following User Says Thank You to stealthj For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
AK4TAY7BEN
Old
#5  
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 3
Posts: 23
Join Date: Dec 2012
Quote:
Originally Posted by stealthj View Post
Hopefully if enough people buy the Z1s, development will speed up. Feel free to ask me any differences between the two
Well the thing is I'm building a new computer and would like to get into development and theming myself. I know the nexus 5 is a great phone for developers but I would also like the phone to be practical for everyday use. I wish I could just get both... Anyways is the reception on the z1s that much better than on the n5? On my 521 it takes forever to send picture messages and to receive them.
 
scoobdude
Old
#6  
scoobdude's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 65
Posts: 634
Join Date: Jan 2008
Can you get actual db differences between the.and post here?would really like to see some hard numbers on signal vs bars.

Sent from my C6916 using xda app-developers app
 
stealthj
Old
#7  
stealthj's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 92
Posts: 490
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Silicon Valley, California
I will do that later tonight or tomorrow yes on the db

Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
Samsung SCH-3500
Motorola NexteL i860
Samsung D807
Nokia n91
HTC Kaiser
Nokia n95
Nokia n82
Nokia N97
HTC Glacier 4G
Nokia Lumia 800
Samsung GT-I9100
Galaxy Nexus
Nokia N9 (android 4.1)
Nokia PureView 808
Nexus 4
Razr M

Nexus 7 2
Sony Z1
 
sruba209
Old
#8  
Member
Thanks Meter 5
Posts: 39
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: chennai
Quote:
Originally Posted by stealthj View Post
.....
A few weeks ago, i misplaced my Z1 in a public shopping mall table... i think...

...anyways, I'm on T-Mobile USA.
When I first got the phone in September, T-Mobile offered me insurance on the phone.
I went ahead and did a claim, and they said they couldn't get me the z1, and that the closest thing they have ( in price and what not) would be a Note 3.
They sent that to me, they unlocked it, and i sold it...
Dilemma began.... buy another z1? wait for Z1s? Could not do that because their bootloaders are not unlock-able

So what did I do? I saved some money and went ahead with a white 32gb nexus 5 while a friend of mine went ahead and actually bought the Z1s yesterday , and HERE are my first impressions of the differences between the two....

Nexus 5 over the Z1(c6903 and z1s):

Brighter, better screen with better viewing angles
Stock android software
Smaller size, fits easier in hand
Optical image stabilization (opinion)
Easier to root, hack etc.but then again its a nexus and it SHOULD have that
Lighter than the Z1
Messaging app on Z1 STILL does not implement group MMS, but you could always use hangouts ( not a big deal for some)

Sony Z1 over Nexus 5:

Z1 Has a premium feel to it, it feels like you are holding an expensive phone, at least when compared to the nexus 5
Z1 has a bigger battery, I was able to go through a full day of HEAVY usage with it, cannot do this with the Nexus
Z1 is waterproof, dustproof and you can use the camera underwater
Z1 has a microSD card slot in addition to the 16GB (or 32gb for the Z1s) of internal storage
the Z1s has a STRONGER ANTENNA THAN THE NEXUS 5, therefore allowing for better and faster data coverage and better voice quality (On T-Mobile USA)
the Z1 is faster even though the NExus is clocked at a higher speed, tested this with browser tests, game load times etc...

How do i know this? I placed the Z1S side by side with my Nexus 5, verified that they were connected to the same tower on LTE, and di some tests...

the Nexus 5 gave me 2 bars of signal, while the Z1s had Full bars, speedtest.net San Jose,CA gave Z1 ~23megabits down , Nexus 5 around 12 megabits down. Same server, phones side by side.
That part made me think about the decision I made. I Knew about all the other pros and cons of getting the Nexus, and I knew the Z1 kills it in benchmarks and what not but that does not really matter to me

The cellular reception part bothers me. I've always considered the nexus 5 to be a "different" phone, not worse than the Z1.

I can now say that the Z1 is overall a better phone.
Its faster, snappier, and feeds more power to its antenna I'm guessing?

Now i Will stick with my Nexus until the next sony flagship

Don't lose your Z1. If you do, buy another one.

Lovely research.... deserves a thanks... Brought a Z1
 
epsix
Old
#9  
epsix's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 219
Posts: 1,710
Join Date: Aug 2010

 
DONATE TO ME
I can testified to this, I've put my GS4 and z1s side by side. On my GS4 I only get one bar LTE and on my Z1s I get three bar LTE in my store where the signal sux.

Sent from my C6916 using Tapatalk 2
 
stealthj
Old
#10  
stealthj's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 92
Posts: 490
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Silicon Valley, California
Yup, signal and battery.... sucks

Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
Samsung SCH-3500
Motorola NexteL i860
Samsung D807
Nokia n91
HTC Kaiser
Nokia n95
Nokia n82
Nokia N97
HTC Glacier 4G
Nokia Lumia 800
Samsung GT-I9100
Galaxy Nexus
Nokia N9 (android 4.1)
Nokia PureView 808
Nexus 4
Razr M

Nexus 7 2
Sony Z1

The Following User Says Thank You to stealthj For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
Tags
nexus 5, sony, t-mobile, z1s
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes