Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,741,305 Members 42,260 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

[Q]-Is it safe to update if rooted?

Tip us?
 
NapalmDawn
Old
#1  
NapalmDawn's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 139
Posts: 751
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Raleigh

 
DONATE TO ME
Default [Q]-Is it safe to update if rooted?

I've got an Nvidia Note and the Shield. I noticed the Note has been mentioning an OTA update which likely means my Shield is due for it also. Since both are rooted, is it okay to update or will I wind up losing root?

I noticed on the front end that updating the shield OTA is playing hell with the SD cards. I don't have one in there yet but does the new OTA force you into having a root priv. file browser like root explorer?
------

My devices
Phone-G3-Wicked ROM
HP Touchpad-Schizoid
High use tab-Transformer 700-CROMI-X XBMC tab-Transformer 300-Cromi-X
Nexus 7-Purity ROM Galaxy Tab 3 7-Crash ROM
Gaming devices-NVIDIA Shield / Tegra Note
Blue Stacks for Windows Retired-HTC Flyer, Droid Eris, HTC Tbolt, HTC Rezound, Lenovo K1, Transformer 101, Transformer Prime, Nook Color, Dell Streak 7
 
redphazon
Old
#2  
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 11
Join Date: Dec 2012
Quote:
Originally Posted by NapalmDawn View Post
I've got an Nvidia Note and the Shield. I noticed the Note has been mentioning an OTA update which likely means my Shield is due for it also. Since both are rooted, is it okay to update or will I wind up losing root?

I noticed on the front end that updating the shield OTA is playing hell with the SD cards. I don't have one in there yet but does the new OTA force you into having a root priv. file browser like root explorer?
I don't know about the Note, but you will lose root by updating the Shield. I had no problems re-rooting it though (I rooted mine by loading CWM Recovery through fastboot and installing SuperSU from there; I don't know if the insecure boot method still works).

The Shield's latest OTA brings KitKat which restricts write privileges to external SD cards. If I'm understanding it correctly, it lets an app write to its own folder on the card, but no where else. This breaks general access apps like file explorers. To get around that, there's an app on the Google Play store called SDFix which removes these restrictions (requires root since it modifies system files).
 
NapalmDawn
Old
#3  
NapalmDawn's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 139
Posts: 751
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Raleigh

 
DONATE TO ME
Quote:
Originally Posted by redphazon View Post
I don't know about the Note, but you will lose root by updating the Shield. I had no problems re-rooting it though (I rooted mine by loading CWM Recovery through fastboot and installing SuperSU from there; I don't know if the insecure boot method still works).

The Shield's latest OTA brings KitKat which restricts write privileges to external SD cards. If I'm understanding it correctly, it lets an app write to its own folder on the card, but no where else. This breaks general access apps like file explorers. To get around that, there's an app on the Google Play store called SDFix which removes these restrictions (requires root since it modifies system files).
You did an adb push type thing in recovery or just flashed an su.zip type thing?
------

My devices
Phone-G3-Wicked ROM
HP Touchpad-Schizoid
High use tab-Transformer 700-CROMI-X XBMC tab-Transformer 300-Cromi-X
Nexus 7-Purity ROM Galaxy Tab 3 7-Crash ROM
Gaming devices-NVIDIA Shield / Tegra Note
Blue Stacks for Windows Retired-HTC Flyer, Droid Eris, HTC Tbolt, HTC Rezound, Lenovo K1, Transformer 101, Transformer Prime, Nook Color, Dell Streak 7
 
redphazon
Old
#4  
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 11
Join Date: Dec 2012
I didn't ADB push. I booted CWM recovery through fastboot (didn't flash it, I didn't want to bother removing it for future updates), chose the "choose zip from external sd" option, and installed this from my external SD card. I did have to hit the Play Store and download the SuperSU app from there as well, but it worked.

This post here is pretty much what I did minus the flashing part.
 
darkonex
Old
#5  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 16
Posts: 248
Join Date: Jun 2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by redphazon View Post
The Shield's latest OTA brings KitKat which restricts write privileges to external SD cards. If I'm understanding it correctly, it lets an app write to its own folder on the card, but no where else. This breaks general access apps like file explorers. To get around that, there's an app on the Google Play store called SDFix which removes these restrictions (requires root since it modifies system files).
I had read about KitKat breaking file explorers but honestly I didn't notice it make any changes to mine, think I'm using File Explorer Pro or something but it still lets me make dirs on SD, move/copy stuff, extract files, etc so not sure exactly what it was supposed to break? I'm not rooted either nor know how to do so yet :/
 
NapalmDawn
Old
#6  
NapalmDawn's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 139
Posts: 751
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Raleigh

 
DONATE TO ME
Quote:
Originally Posted by redphazon View Post
I didn't ADB push. I booted CWM recovery through fastboot (didn't flash it, I didn't want to bother removing it for future updates), chose the "choose zip from external sd" option, and installed this from my external SD card. I did have to hit the Play Store and download the SuperSU app from there as well, but it worked.

This post here is pretty much what I did minus the flashing part.
Thanks all. I'll pull down the OTA soon and see if I can recover root. I noticed OTA Rootkeeper wasn't thrilled because my shield has SuperSU and not superuser. Even though the app mentions being ok with SuperSU, it doesn't want to move along.
------

My devices
Phone-G3-Wicked ROM
HP Touchpad-Schizoid
High use tab-Transformer 700-CROMI-X XBMC tab-Transformer 300-Cromi-X
Nexus 7-Purity ROM Galaxy Tab 3 7-Crash ROM
Gaming devices-NVIDIA Shield / Tegra Note
Blue Stacks for Windows Retired-HTC Flyer, Droid Eris, HTC Tbolt, HTC Rezound, Lenovo K1, Transformer 101, Transformer Prime, Nook Color, Dell Streak 7
 
brandrobbart
Old
#7  
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 6
Join Date: Feb 2014
Location: Texas

 
DONATE TO ME
I rooted my Sheild by unlocking bootloader, then pushing the image with adb. I updated to Android 4.4 and root was gone, however bootloader remained unlocked. I pushed the image again and all is well. So go ahead and update!

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes


XDA PORTAL POSTS

Mod Lets You Have Stereo Speakers on Your Sony Xperia Z1 (Sort Of)

The stereo speakers onthe Sony Xperia Z2areprobably a relatively large … more

Give Your Screen Some Color with HexaTime Live Wallpaper

We don’t often cover very many live wallpapers here on the XDA Portal. You may … more

Android Wear App Review: Command Google Now with Commandr – XDA Developer TV

OK Google. Make Me a sandwich. How many times have you … more

Play Your Hits and Learn the Lyrics with NextGen Music Player

There are plenty of music players for Android available in Play Store. They … more