Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,772,276 Members 44,982 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

The stock equalizer is complete garbage.

Tip us?
 
MarkMRL
Old
#1  
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 64
Posts: 408
Join Date: Jul 2011
Default The stock equalizer is complete garbage.

Have you tried the stock EQ on the Galaxy S4? I was messing with it earlier and man that thing is completely botched.

Basically, when you raise one of the frequencies on a legit equalizer, only that frequency gets enhanced and all the others remain unchanged.

In the Samsung EQ when you raise one frequency, that frequency doesn't actually change at all, the ones that change are all the others, which get LOWERED! Isn't this some bull****?

You can test this, and see that I'm right, if you raise all frequencies to the max, the sound will be identical to when all the frequencies are set at 0 (middle position). Another test you can do is raise any single frequency to the max, listen to the music for a bit, and then lower every frequency to the minumum and leave the frequency you raised before to default 0 position, the sound will be identical.

Long story short, this EQ can't raise any frequency even though the slider says +10dB - 0 - -10dB, all it can do is lower every other frequency so the one you raised is N dB higher than the others.
 
Andy0625
Old
#2  
Andy0625's Avatar
Member
Thanks Meter 9
Posts: 55
Join Date: Dec 2012
Quote:
Originally Posted by MarkMRL View Post
Have you tried the stock EQ on the Galaxy S4? I was messing with it earlier and man that thing is completely botched.

Basically, when you raise one of the frequencies on a legit equalizer, only that frequency gets enhanced and all the others remain unchanged.

In the Samsung EQ when you raise one frequency, that frequency doesn't actually change at all, the ones that change are all the others, which get LOWERED! Isn't this some bull****?

You can test this, and see that I'm right, if you raise all frequencies to the max, the sound will be identical to when all the frequencies are set at 0 (middle position). Another test you can do is raise any single frequency to the max, listen to the music for a bit, and then lower every frequency to the minumum and leave the frequency you raised before to default 0 position, the sound will be identical.

Long story short, this EQ can't raise any frequency even though the slider says +10dB - 0 - -10dB, all it can do is lower every other frequency so the one you raised is N dB higher than the others.
Would you able to list the model code of S4 you're using? I9500 or others?
 
sorg
Old
#3  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 568
Posts: 690
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: 台灣
Generally speaking, EQ is not a volume control.
With originally reserved gain, EQ can rise volume for selected frequencies which is the case for most home cinemas. For limited resources of phone, it's unpraxtical to reserve gain, so volume of zero is actually maximum possible volume. Rising volume over this point will produce distortion (or will produce sound louder than allowed by some countries). That's why this EQ lowering volume of non-selected bands. EQ is doing what is supposed to do - sound equalization. What it can't do - is to rise selected band above 0 (which is what you're expecting).
Samsung Galaxy S4 SHV-E330S: Optimus ROM (TW 4.4.2) & Kernel. CPU OC 2.7GHz, GPU OC 645MHz, non-KNOX bootloader, UHD/SM/360 Camera.
Samsung Galaxy S4 GT-I9500: Optimus ROM (TW 4.3), Perseus Kernel. CPU No-OC, GPU OC 700MHz, non-KNOX bootloader.
Past models: Samsung Galaxy SIII SHV-E210K & GT-I9300, Samsung Galaxy SII GT-I9100.
 
devgee
Old
#4  
devgee's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 190
Posts: 474
Join Date: Dec 2011

 
DONATE TO ME
All i can say viper4android

Gesendet von meinem GT-I9505 mit Tapatalk
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes