5,814,981 Members 39,855 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

Gear 2 Neo or Sony Smartwatch 2?

Tip us?
 
affenzeit
Old
#1  
affenzeit's Avatar
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 4
Posts: 75
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Dallas
Default Gear 2 Neo or Sony Smartwatch 2?

I'm debating between the Samsung Gear 2 Neo and the Sony Smartwatch 2. The Sony is only $140 on Amazon right now and it appears to most of the features I would actually use. The one big concern about the Sony is that it doesn't have the IR blaster, so the remote is out (but meh, I've got my S5 set up with my TV, so no big deal). My big concern with the Samsung is that when I get ready to upgrade my phone under T-Mobile's Jump, who knows if I'll get another Samsung (who am I kidding, I'll probably get another Samsung, but just in case I didn't...).

I'm having trouble finding a good comparison of the two that would sway me one way or the other. It would be nice to save the $60 on the Sony, but at the same time I really like the Neo look over the Sony. Any thoughts? I don't care that the Sony lacks voice commands. I'd probably never use it, and obviously I don't care about the camera or else I wouldn't be considering the Neo.

Thanks!
 
BigDanInTX
Old
(Last edited by BigDanInTX; 6th May 2014 at 04:30 PM.) Reason: Memory issues, need more coffee!
#2  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 34
Posts: 148
Join Date: May 2009
Location: League City, TX
It's too bad you couldn't jump in on the AT&T deal when it was 25% off with two other accessories. Saving $50 would have swayed you instantly. I am 100% glad I purchased this, as it provides exactly all of the functionality I need it to...

Vibrating alarm so I don't wake up my wife on her days off.
Notification and full text of SMS
Notification and full text of work Emails
Notification and full text of Appointments from my work calendar
Notifications are with just enough vibration so those around me don't know it went off
Don't show notifications until I look at the watch
Customizable watch faces depending on my mood for that day
Won't be overly susceptible to dings/scratches - it's got Gorilla Glass 3!

It also adds some things I didn't need, but use nonetheless
Pedometer (wish the pedometer allowed you to enter your stride length instead of estimating off height)
Heart rate monitor (a little wonky sometimes)
Exercise tracking
Tracks my sleep (when I remember to turn it on...or sometimes OFF...lol)
Backup Remote w/ the IR Blaster (need a way to add a Roku so I don't need either remote)
I can answer the phone and talk if I'm busy
I can reply to text messages with canned quick text responses
I can skip tracks and pause Pandora with my phone charging in the other room

If I had to pick a couple negatives...
Battery power is okay. I have to charge it every other day or at least top it off every day.
It would be nice if I felt more comfortable showering with it. Some people say it's possible and they have had no issues. I would rather not at this point.

All I know is I love it and I'll be using it for a while. I also have 3 coworkers who have Pebbles and they've all commented on how great it looks/acts. One of them is waiting for the LG G Watch to drop. I'll probably wait for the second gen of Android Wear before committing.

Best of luck to you in figuring out what it is you want/need. ;-]

EDIT: Just thought of a more significant con...

If you spend time at a desk typing, you may end up scuffing the clasp against the desk. This will cause wear on that clasp as well as metal transfer to the desk itself. It wipes off fairly easily, but the wear is very evident on the watch.
Samsung Galaxy SIII | Samsung Gear 2 Neo | Samsung Galaxy Tab 2 7.0
The Following User Says Thank You to BigDanInTX For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
admiral70
Old
#3  
admiral70's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 9
Posts: 155
Join Date: Dec 2006
I purchased the Sony SW2 to save money and had regretted it the whole time. Some of what I am about to say can be fixed with some modifications (Sony SW2) and apps but not out of the box. Not being able to raise my arm to active the watch was a negative. Not being able to take a simple phone call was a negative. The positive at the time was being able to change watch bands that is solved with the Gear 2 and Neo being able to change bands. The health monitoring of the Gear is nice as well.

The negative for Gear 2/neo is the limited app market. Since changing to Tizen not a lot of apps out there.

I am 100% happier with the Gear 2 Neo than I was with the Sony. For what that is worth.
SmartPhone: Currently using the Samsung Galaxy S5
Wearable: Samsung Gear 2 Neo
Tablet: Motorola Xoom tablet running EOS Stingray.
Google ChromeCast
The Following User Says Thank You to admiral70 For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
BigDanInTX
Old
#4  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 34
Posts: 148
Join Date: May 2009
Location: League City, TX
Quote:
Originally Posted by admiral70 View Post
The negative for Gear 2/neo is the limited app market. Since changing to Tizen not a lot of apps out there.
+1!!!
Samsung Galaxy SIII | Samsung Gear 2 Neo | Samsung Galaxy Tab 2 7.0
 
nrseife
Old
#5  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 2
Posts: 102
Join Date: Jun 2010
I also looked at the Sony before buying the Gear 2 (AT&T deal)...
What I did not like about the Sony is that besides watch functionality it only seems to be able to push notifications. If indeed true, the Gear 2 has much more potential to be used offline (running apps locally on the watch), once they are available of course...
The screen looks better on the Gear, but I like the Sony to be reflective (always on). Not sure if it suffers from the same issues as Pebble, such as the fact that with polarizing glasses you cannot see anything on it....
Also, I think the Gear 2 looks better overall, but that is just my personal opinion of course....

Sent from my GT-N5110 using xda premium
 
necr0manser
Old
(Last edited by necr0manser; 13th May 2014 at 05:10 AM.)
#6  
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 3
Posts: 20
Join Date: May 2014
I'm also debating between two of them right now. Seems like if I choose to save some money I should buy SW2, but I can also buy a used Neo so.
Because I was collecting information only about sony's watch, I'd like to ask a couple of questions to the Neo's owners.
1. Can I make (root,rom, hack,etc) the Gear 2 Neo to work with sony xperia z1c? And will all the functionality remain(for example, if sw2 is connected to a phone rather than sony, you cannot answer calls) if connected to sony instead of samsung. This is the main question.
2. Is the screen always on, like on sony sw2, so I can check the time.
3. Can it control the music being played on a phone, or is there an app for that.
4. Can it answer phone calls
5. How long does the battery last
I'm even thinking not to buy any smartwatches at all, because all of them seem imperfect. What I really would like is SW2's functionality in a better screen from samsung. On the other hand, I don't want to spend money on useless(for me) features like IR blaster or pedometer, or even heart rate sensor. I just need a smartwatch to control music on the phone, check notifications, and to answer calls with a headphones on. and maybe an alarm, if its really so useful. Maybe those are not the watches i'm looking for, so sorry for the off-topic.
Thank you in advance.
 
BigDanInTX
Old
#7  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 34
Posts: 148
Join Date: May 2009
Location: League City, TX
Quote:
Originally Posted by necr0manser View Post
1. Can I make (root,rom, hack,etc) the Gear 2 Neo to work with sony xperia z1c? And will all the functionality remain(for example, if sw2 is connected to a phone rather than sony, you cannot answer calls) if connected to sony instead of samsung. This is the main question
I have no experience on anything other than a Galaxy phone with this watch, but I do know there are some threads out there about getting the Gear 2 working on other phones. You may have to do some investigation.

Quote:
Originally Posted by necr0manser View Post
2. Is the screen always on, like on sony sw2, so I can check the time.
No, but you can set it to turn on when you look at the phone (as well as determine whether you want it to display the clock or the last screen you had up)

Quote:
Originally Posted by necr0manser View Post
3. Can it control the music being played on a phone, or is there an app for that.
There is a music player app for playing files on the watch itself. There is also a Media Controller app to control media players on your phone. Both of these are on the device out of the box.[/quote]

Quote:
Originally Posted by necr0manser View Post
4. Can it answer phone calls
Yes. it actually works really well. The person I tested it with said they couldn't tell it was anything other than a phone.

Quote:
Originally Posted by necr0manser View Post
5. How long does the battery last
This answer really depends on settings and what you have sent in terms of notifications. I get about 2 days out of mine, but I typically charge it in the evenings when I'm on the PC and again in the mornings while I shower.
Samsung Galaxy SIII | Samsung Gear 2 Neo | Samsung Galaxy Tab 2 7.0

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes


Change the Style of Your Notifications with HeadsUp

Head Up notifications is one of these upcoming features that Android developers hid deep … more

Google Play Store to Show Price Ranges for In-App Purchases

Google recently announced a change to Google Play Store policy that requires … more

XDA Xposed Tuesday: How to Shut Up Your Phone – XDA Developer TV

So many different applications want to send us notifications that … more

Add Some Power to First Generation Snapdragon CPUs

Some older devices still remain very popular. Phones like theHTC Desire, Sony Ericsson … more