Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,781,073 Members 44,834 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

[Q] Mobile Network State: Disconnect. Is It Hardware Problem?

Tip us?
 
miogy
Old
(Last edited by miogy; 21st May 2014 at 06:39 AM.) Reason: Add the tittle
#1  
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 60
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Alor Star
Service [Q] Mobile Network State: Disconnect. Is It Hardware Problem?

Operator: U Mobile (Malaysia)
Rom: 2.3.6(4.5.1.41.MB860.ATT.en.US) flash with CWM using fruit cake rom.
Baseband: N_01.77.36P
Kernal Version: 2.6.32.9 a21`146@zch45Inxdroid55 #2
Status: Can make call and receive sms. Apn setting is good. Wifi and bluetooth also work fine. Only mobile data state is the problem.

Problem:

1.I got this Atrix last 3 week. When i put a sim card it cannot detect my data so i install TWEAKKER from Play Store and get the setting for my APN. Everything work fine.

2. After a week i unlock the bootloader, install Nottachtrix, and again using TWEAKKER to set my APN, have fun with lapdock (overclock it using faux kernal to 1.45ghz). Everything still work fine.

3. Last 5 days i start play around with Titanium backup and supercharged v6. I backup and remove system application that i think i dont need it. I end up with mess around with the system but since i already made a backup i just restore it to default and then i start notice i lost my data signal.

4. I reflash fresh nottachtrix rom using CWM but the data still disconnected. I try flashing other rom like ICS rom also same problem. And then i flash official rom using CWM (fruit cake method) and RSD method. Still no luck. But today i play around with HiAPN and i can connect to data again but it seem not stable. But i can receive Phone call and sms without problem.

5. I already check my sim card by put it to other phone and i got no problem with it.

Any suggestion what i need to do to make data work again normally?

Update 18 May 2014:
1. I reflash 2.3.4 rom using RSD. Mobile Network State still disconnect. I will buy a new sim with different operator to test either my phone got problem or is it the sim/operator problem. Old but powerfull phone. I hope i got change to use it as daily phone again.

Update 21 May 2014:
Already test with other operator also no luck. Flashing all the radio that i found also no luck. Guessing the hardware got problem but quit confuse because call and sms still can receive.
 
andresrivas
Old
#2  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 353
Posts: 1,033
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Córdoba
Quote:
Originally Posted by miogy View Post
Operator: U Mobile (Malaysia)
Rom: 2.3.6(4.5.1.41.MB860.ATT.en.US) flash with CWM using fruit cake rom.
Baseband: N_01.77.36P
Kernal Version: 2.6.32.9 a21`146@zch45Inxdroid55 #2

Problem:

1.I got this Atrix last 3 week. When i put a sim card it cannot detect my data so i install TWEAKKER from Play Store and get the setting for my APN. Everything work fine.

2. After a week i unlock the bootloader, install Nottachtrix, and again using TWEAKKER to set my APN, have fun with lapdock (overclock it using faux kernal to 1.45ghz). Everything still work fine.

3. Last 5 days i start play around with Titanium backup and supercharged v6. I backup and remove system application that i think i dont need it. I end up with mess around with the system but since i already made a backup i just restore it to default and then i start notice i lost my data signal.

4. I reflash fresh nottachtrix rom using CWM but the data still disconnected. I try flashing other rom like ICS rom also same problem. And then i flash official rom using CWM (fruit cake method). Still no luck. But today i play around with HiAPN and i can connect to data again but it seem not stable.

5. I already check my sim card by put it to other phone and i got no problem with it.

Any suggestion what i need to do to make data work again normally?
Not a smart advice, use it as last resource:

Find the radio version your phone have and flash it, or simply flash another radio. Be careful, tough as an incorrect version (not all radios work on every atrix) you may end with a nice hi-tech papeweight
Motorola Personal 501 -> Motorola StarTac -> Motorola v360 (1gb sd, iTunes, native, non-java apps) -> Motorola Rokr E2 (SDHC 8Gb, native apps, O.C., My own custom Rom, AWESOME PHONE) -> Motorola C115 (Custom Ringtones xD ) -> Motorola Milestone (A.K.A Droid) (Froyo, rooted, stolen :'( ) -> Motorola Atrix 4G (Blur ICS) -> Motorola Moto X


Yup. I've been a Motofan all my life so far...
 
miogy
Old
#3  
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 60
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Alor Star
Quote:
Originally Posted by andresrivas View Post
Not a smart advice, use it as last resource:

Find the radio version your phone have and flash it, or simply flash another radio. Be careful, tough as an incorrect version (not all radios work on every atrix) you may end with a nice hi-tech papeweight
I already flash:
a) Radio N_01.77.30P
b) Radio N_01.77.36P
c) Radio N_01.77.37P_usa_att_12dec2011
d) Radio N_01.100.00R

I found all the radio in fruit cakes link except for D. Still no luck. Is it a problem with my phone? I can receive call and sms normally. Only data not work and i believe my APN setting is correct.
 
miogy
Old
#4  
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 60
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Alor Star
Already call my operator services and they also can't help. Today will try another sim card with different operator that i will borrow from my friend to check either i need to upgrade my sim or not.

Still hope to get any expert help from XDA forum
 
miogy
Old
#5  
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 60
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Alor Star
Any expert? I got iPhone and windows phone but nothing can beat this atrix+lapdock.
 
iTaisHi
Old
(Last edited by iTaisHi; 17th June 2014 at 12:15 PM.)
#6  
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 6
Join Date: May 2014
Default Atrix 4g connectivity

Quote:
Originally Posted by miogy View Post
Any expert? I got iPhone and windows phone but nothing can beat this atrix+lapdock.
Quote:
Originally Posted by miogy View Post
Already call my operator services and they also can't help. Today will try another sim card with different operator that i will borrow from my friend to check either i need to upgrade my sim or not.

Still hope to get any expert help from XDA forum
Hallo miogy,
this is a well known issue,
i am experience the same problem with my atrix 4G,
i recently flash the CM9 of CyanogenMod , (android 4.0.4),
before that i had the 2.3.4 (GB) - in this version my atrix had restart himshelf every day.

on the current version (CM9), i experiencig strange things with the Network.
this is not only us that experiencig that - it is a very common and wide .
its called RIL bug (RIL --> Radio Interface Layer),

my phone can work fine 2 or 5 ot 8 hours, and suddenly the data connection disconnected.
i even once had connected to a Mobile Carrier that is not mine.

as much as i understand till now, this RIL bug is caused of a bug in the Kernel, adn the best guys here in the XDA, are trying to solve it.
i am waiting to this solution very much, because this atrix 4g is great phone, and i like the CM9 also.

you can see for example this thread:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/show....php?t=2603032
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes


Forums Added for the LG G Watch R and Samsung Gear S

A little over a week ago, LG “inadvertently” let the world know about the … more

Secrecy App Goes Open Source, New LG Android Wear Device! – XDA Developer TV

Secrecy encryption app goes open source! That and much … more

Pushbullet Updated with SMS Send Ability

Pushbullet is one of thoseapplications that every Android lover should have installed on his or … more

[OTA] Nvidia Shield Tablet Receives its First Update

The Nvidia Shield Tabletis the latest toy from one of the largest desktop graphics … more