Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,777,659 Members 44,096 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

[Q] Help needed - difference in volume between music apps

Tip us?
 
rob.allen78
Old
#1  
rob.allen78's Avatar
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 49
Join Date: Feb 2006
Question [Q] Help needed - difference in volume between music apps

Hi all, [I did a forum search using volume galaxy note 3; volume mod galaxy note 3 and didn't find anything related to my post below]

I have quite a bit of a head scratcher here and I'm not sure which way to go to resolve it....

I have an AT&T Galaxy Note 3 that is rooted running stock MJ5 firmware. When playing music using the speaker and built-in music app (or when setting up the sounds to use for ringtone, notifications, etc.), the volume output is decent respective to it's factory output level. However when I'm playing music via PowerAmp or JetAudio Plus - the volume output is not at the same level as it is with the built-in music app. I've made sure that AGC is off in JetAudio, de-selected the Limit option in PowerAmp, and checked and unchecked the Direct Volume Control option within the advanced audio settings in PowerAmp. In spite of all that I have checked - the volume output is not the same and it's driving me crazy. Here are all of the things that I've done so far (in no particular order) to see if I can 'fix' the problem:

1) Factory Reset my phone (from within the OS itself)
2) I've tried using the Volume Boosting Mods found in this forum post to see if that would correct anything.
3) Performed a FULL firmware restore (courtesy of this post) to see if I mucked something up along the way. (I kind of messed up my haptic feedback which was the catalyst for the restore. The volume restore was along for the ride at that point )

None of the above seems to work (EVEN with the firmware restore). Please note that with the firmware restore - I tested it out BEFORE loading my applications (except for JetAudio and PowerAmp). What makes the built-in music application different than apps such as PowerAmp, JetAudio, etc. that it accesses a different volume stream (say digital vs. analog)? (I know that last question was kind of confusing, but think of it as being analogous to Line Out vs. the 3.5mm headphone port for external sound output )

I know that the file used for modifying volume output levels is located in system/etc/snd_soc_msm (the file snd_soc_msm_Taiko_CDP is what's used to make the mods) but is there a specific line or lines contained within that file that control analog volume output for the built-in speaker?

I'm not sure how the PowerAmp or JetAudio app is configured to access volume output streams (if that makes any sense) but there seems to be something different because the volume output drops pretty badly when using either of these apps vs. the stock music player.

Has anyone else noticed this oddity (and found a way to fix it) or am I the odd man out here ?

Any help would be appreciated.
 
ShadowLea
Old
#2  
ShadowLea's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 777
Posts: 3,478
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: Enschede, The Netherlands
Silly question: Did you try disabling Adapt Sound?
SM-N9005 International Galaxy Note 3, DBT NB7 Stock
SM-G900F International Galaxy S5, PHN NCE Stock
SM-P905 NotePro 12.2 LTE Black, DBT NC3 Stock

The person who says it cannot be done should not interrupt the person who is doing it. –Chinese Proverb

Never underestimate the power of stupid people in large groups.

The simplest solutions are often the cleverest. They are also usually wrong.
 
rob.allen78
Old
#3  
rob.allen78's Avatar
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 49
Join Date: Feb 2006
Quote:
Originally Posted by ShadowLea View Post
Silly question: Did you try disabling Adapt Sound?
I don't recall having Adapt Sound enabled (I did see it but don't remember having any checkboxes ticked....). I'll reply back once I downgrade my phone back to JB (I was forced to take an OTA update to kitkat and I need root access).
 
rob.allen78
Old
#4  
rob.allen78's Avatar
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 49
Join Date: Feb 2006
Quote:
Originally Posted by rob.allen78 View Post
I don't recall having Adapt Sound enabled (I did see it but don't remember having any checkboxes ticked....). I'll reply back once I downgrade my phone back to JB (I was forced to take an OTA update to kitkat and I need root access).
So after going through a full factory reset (via ODIN), I can confirm that I'm not using Adapt Sound and have also ensured that I am not using any equalizers to enhance the sound in either application.
 
meawww
Old
#5  
meawww's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 446
Posts: 366
Join Date: Dec 2013
Location: Rome

 
DONATE TO ME
You cant compare PA or JA to the stock audio because those 2 apps using different drivers than a stock 1
 
rob.allen78
Old
#6  
rob.allen78's Avatar
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 49
Join Date: Feb 2006
Quote:
Originally Posted by rob.allen78 View Post
I don't recall having Adapt Sound enabled (I did see it but don't remember having any checkboxes ticked....). I'll reply back once I downgrade my phone back to JB (I was forced to take an OTA update to kitkat and I need root access).
Quote:
Originally Posted by meawww View Post
You cant compare PA or JA to the stock audio because those 2 apps using different drivers than a stock 1
Thanks for the info (The driver usage may be what the difference is respective to audio output.)

I wasn't really trying to compare the apps per se as more of a process of finding out if I have a unique hardware issue in which I would need to send my phone back to AT&T/Samsung for a warranty exchange.
Tags
jetaudio, poweramp, speaker, volume
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes


Add Bits and Pieces of Honami to Your Current ROM

In the last few months, we’ve talked about quite a few Sony Honami-related projects. … more

Always Enter the Correct Password with HideNoPasswords

If you’ve ever entered apassword on your mobile device, you’ve surely … more

Revert to Stock Recovery Effortless with Simple Recovery Switcher

Android updates released as OTA packages are very easy to apply,but they … more

Convert PNGs into RLEs Easily on Any OS with PNG2RLE

Unlike other operating systems, Android uses its own graphical image formats. Most of … more