Personally, I could never buy a device from a manufacturer who spends more energy and money on lawsuits and marketing than they do on making innovative devices. The S4 is an S3 with slightly better specks and some gimmicky software features. I thought the eye tracking stuff was cool, but after thinking about it for a while it doesnt actually make all that much sense. Im usually not looking at my device when im watching videos on the go anyways, and even if they get page scrolling with eye tracking i hardly doubt they could implement pinch to zoom, so youll need hands anyways, and hands have better control. Id rather have a few really solid useful features and stunning hardware. To me the S4 is simply not engineered or designed as well as the htc one. I will always support the manufacturer who brings the best of engineering and design. Thats why I bought the infinity, and its paid off, I have dropped my baby so many times on every face and corner. I dropped it directly on its corner onto concrete and it didnt even get dented. I dropped it into snow once, and its still good, still no lightbleed lol. I also dont case my devices, I buy the thinnest and lightest devices for a reason. I can deal with the software side on my own, thats why i use android. Allthough sense 5 is stunning (despite slightly different navigation). Its the only android skin i would ever consider actually keeping for a bit and playing with. Htc is moving in the right direction here, and seems more commited to improving and supporting android development than Samsung.
I still very much respect your decision though, we are all looking for different things. I dont need removable storage, everything is cloud based for me. I currently only have 1.5Gb of data on my tablet and 2.5Gb on external storage lol, makes setting up my tab from scratch easy at least. I could see why the removable battery is an issue. it would be nice on the one, but id rather have unibody design and zero gap engineering for an excellent feel. I have seen many reports and reviews stating that 25%-35% of battery is still left on the one after a day of heavy use. Thats more than enough for me. Ill never be away from a charger for more than a day and I dont do any gaming, so my battery use will be paltry, especially if i keep the screen brightness down.