CM10.0 Stable Review

Search This thread

Mekuso

Senior Member
Nov 15, 2012
54
24
CM10.0 stable was released a while ago on the HTC One S (S4). I've used it for a week nown and thought I'd write a review. Basically, I'm trying to create the thread I wish I'd find before I flashed CM10.0 Stable.

I came from stock 4.0.4 with Sense 4.1, so whenever I make comparisons, I compare it to that.

The Good
- Stability. I've really only encountered a single bug. That's actually better than stock for me. Definately stable enough to use as a daily driver. I am really impressed by this.
- Speed and smoothness. Everything flows really well, making the interface a joy to use.
- Battery life. For me, it has been notably but not dramatically better. I get about 3.5 h screen time (I got about 3 h on stock).
- The interface. Everything is prettier than Sense. I could never go back.
- The settings. The number of settings isn't as large as CM7 (which was a bit insane), but larger than stock. You can tweak more or less everything you care about.

The Bad
- A bug making volume wake unreliable. It's on the tracker: http://code.google.com/p/cyanogenmod/issues/detail?id=6720
This matters a lot for me since my power button is quite unresponsible. But it probably won't matter to most users (although I'd argue that waking the screen up with volume buttons is more comfortable than the power button)
- While it's great that you can cutomize the lock screen shortcuts, you can't move the "unlock". It's always to the right. You can install another lock screen if you want, though. It's a very minor issue.
- The contacts app doesn't seem to work with Facebook, so if you (like me) get all your contacts' pictures from there, you're out of luck. Slightly annoying. Third party apps like Haxsync can fix this though.
- The timer and the alarm are found in two different apps. And the timer app is a bit wierd, coming from stock. But it works.

Other notes
- Camera quality seems good enough. Taking photos is really fast, much like stock, but you can't just hold down the button to do burst mode.
- I don't miss Beats Audio. The DSP Manager, an included app, let's you activate bass boost in three different levels. For me, this gives more than good enough audio quality.


Conclusion
A great rom. Don't stay on stock :)

If you want me to add anything else, just ask :)
 
Last edited:

miggynuez

Member
Aug 3, 2012
33
2
Cebu City
Us villec2 users are stuck with laggy sense. :( Really hope that since cm10 on the s4 is now stable, a kind dev would port it out for us. I don't even have 4.0.4 yet! :(

Awesome review!
Great that CM10 is now good to go!

Sent from my HTC One S S3 using xda app-developers app
 

NQNH

Senior Member
Sep 15, 2011
1,178
433
Hamburg
Thanks for this great review.
Is it possible to shoot 8mpx widescreen pictures like in the stock rom ?
And is the battery life really better than stock? I've read that some users got a worse battery life on cm..
Did you experienced any wifi/2g/3g connection issues?
 

Kamilr97

Senior Member
Sep 9, 2012
61
28
Thanks for this great review.
Is it possible to shoot 8mpx widescreen pictures like in the stock rom ?
And is the battery life really better than stock? I've read that some users got a worse battery life on cm..
Did you experienced any wifi/2g/3g connection issues?

Sense roms don't take 8mp widescreen shots. To achieve the widescreen, they just crop the photos to something more like 6mp.
Battery life really depends on how you use your phone but for me its better on CM.
Other than the occasional disconnecting from wifi, everything is fine over here
 
  • Like
Reactions: NQNH

NQNH

Senior Member
Sep 15, 2011
1,178
433
Hamburg
Sense roms don't take 8mp widescreen shots. To achieve the widescreen, they just crop the photos to something more like 6mp.
Battery life really depends on how you use your phone but for me its better on CM.
Other than the occasional disconnecting from wifi, everything is fine over here

thanks for your answer, didn't know this cropping thing.
hm, maybe I will switch over to cm too :p
 

Mekuso

Senior Member
Nov 15, 2012
54
24
On Sense, the "8 Mpx" pictures are 3264 x 1840. On CM10, they are 3264 x 2448.

Also, I haven't had any WiFi issues yet on CM10. I did have a few random disconnects on stock Sense, though.
 

Spastic909

Senior Member
Dec 28, 2010
1,786
188
What's this stable cm10 you mention? Don't see it in dev section

Sent from my HTC VLE_U using xda app-developers app
 

i31us

Senior Member
Oct 14, 2011
187
19
Echo

Do anyone of you have noticed that the phone call receiver hears an echo? I do not hear it myself but anyone I call hears the echo and hang up. I switched to stock Sense ROM and the echo disappears.
The echo comes back on CM10, I might try some more ROMs and see
 

NQNH

Senior Member
Sep 15, 2011
1,178
433
Hamburg
Can someone tell me how much the radio take effect on the battery life?
I'm on stock Rom with radio 1.06es now
Or will a new radio be flashed with during the flashprogress of cm 10?
 

Mekuso

Senior Member
Nov 15, 2012
54
24
Do anyone of you have noticed that the phone call receiver hears an echo? I do not hear it myself but anyone I call hears the echo and hang up. I switched to stock Sense ROM and the echo disappears.
The echo comes back on CM10, I might try some more ROMs and see

I've made a few calls from CM10, and nobody has complained about echo.

Hello!!

As far as Facebook sync the best next thing is Haxsync in the market... Sooo worth it and it works great on CM10.

:)

I can confirm that Haxsync works really well!
 
Last edited:

fusk

Senior Member
Nov 9, 2010
802
74
Århus
I installed cm10 two days after i received the phone. There are a few annoyances, but i get good battery life, can run almost two days.
gsm and 3g works perfect, call quality is good, 3g speeds are decent, in my area i get about 1.1 mb/s down and 300 kb/s up.
System runs smooth and fast as default.

The things that annoy me is the bug where volume rocker doesn't wake the device, mentioned on first post.
Some sounds are too low, Alarm sounds compared to my Desire are lower, unlock/lock sounds as well.
When playing music, all info on lock screen is hidden, so you can't see time, weather or scheduled plans.
When you pause music from the lock screen, after about 3 seconds of silence, it'll play another 2 secs, then go silent again.

But, overall i'm happy, a few kinks which i'm sure they'll fix. It runs really well which is nice.
 

ridearoundsolo

Senior Member
Nov 17, 2011
1,040
138
I liked using this but something didn't feel right (too buggy for my tastes) and prefer sense, but I love cm on my nexus 7 its amazing on nexus devices

Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app
 

jdwash11

Senior Member
Feb 6, 2009
104
8
I've been using this for a couple days as well.

Battery life seems worse than the available Sense ROMs but not horrible. Although I can't say for sure that its due to the ROM. I did flash a different radio at the same time.

Also the sounds seem a little lower quality. Not sure if this is due to the lack of Beats Audio or what?

"Snapiness" feels about the same as Sense IMO.

I do agree that this is definitely usable as a DD

Sent from my HTC One S using xda app-developers app
 

KingofRadiance

New member
May 24, 2012
2
0
How would you compare photo quality between CM 10.0 Stable and Sense 4.1 ROMs? I understand that CM 10.0 cannot access the HTC ImageSense chip because it's proprietary but is there a noticeable difference in taking pictures between the two ROMs?
 

hipwell

Senior Member
Oct 6, 2011
76
0
just installed this.

for some reason the contacts app doesnt have a menu so i cant get in the settings to change my voicemail.

music playes for a few seconds after it has been paused.


currently in the process or wiping and reflashing stable to see if the problem persists
 

ridearoundsolo

Senior Member
Nov 17, 2011
1,040
138
How would you compare photo quality between CM 10.0 Stable and Sense 4.1 ROMs? I understand that CM 10.0 cannot access the HTC ImageSense chip because it's proprietary but is there a noticeable difference in taking pictures between the two ROMs?

Yes big difference IMO to me it was unacceptable and switched back to sense but it is what it is, maybe someday the sense camera can be ported

Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app
 
  • Like
Reactions: KingofRadiance

Top Liked Posts

  • There are no posts matching your filters.
  • 3
    CM10.0 stable was released a while ago on the HTC One S (S4). I've used it for a week nown and thought I'd write a review. Basically, I'm trying to create the thread I wish I'd find before I flashed CM10.0 Stable.

    I came from stock 4.0.4 with Sense 4.1, so whenever I make comparisons, I compare it to that.

    The Good
    - Stability. I've really only encountered a single bug. That's actually better than stock for me. Definately stable enough to use as a daily driver. I am really impressed by this.
    - Speed and smoothness. Everything flows really well, making the interface a joy to use.
    - Battery life. For me, it has been notably but not dramatically better. I get about 3.5 h screen time (I got about 3 h on stock).
    - The interface. Everything is prettier than Sense. I could never go back.
    - The settings. The number of settings isn't as large as CM7 (which was a bit insane), but larger than stock. You can tweak more or less everything you care about.

    The Bad
    - A bug making volume wake unreliable. It's on the tracker: http://code.google.com/p/cyanogenmod/issues/detail?id=6720
    This matters a lot for me since my power button is quite unresponsible. But it probably won't matter to most users (although I'd argue that waking the screen up with volume buttons is more comfortable than the power button)
    - While it's great that you can cutomize the lock screen shortcuts, you can't move the "unlock". It's always to the right. You can install another lock screen if you want, though. It's a very minor issue.
    - The contacts app doesn't seem to work with Facebook, so if you (like me) get all your contacts' pictures from there, you're out of luck. Slightly annoying. Third party apps like Haxsync can fix this though.
    - The timer and the alarm are found in two different apps. And the timer app is a bit wierd, coming from stock. But it works.

    Other notes
    - Camera quality seems good enough. Taking photos is really fast, much like stock, but you can't just hold down the button to do burst mode.
    - I don't miss Beats Audio. The DSP Manager, an included app, let's you activate bass boost in three different levels. For me, this gives more than good enough audio quality.


    Conclusion
    A great rom. Don't stay on stock :)

    If you want me to add anything else, just ask :)
    1
    Thanks for this great review.
    Is it possible to shoot 8mpx widescreen pictures like in the stock rom ?
    And is the battery life really better than stock? I've read that some users got a worse battery life on cm..
    Did you experienced any wifi/2g/3g connection issues?

    Sense roms don't take 8mp widescreen shots. To achieve the widescreen, they just crop the photos to something more like 6mp.
    Battery life really depends on how you use your phone but for me its better on CM.
    Other than the occasional disconnecting from wifi, everything is fine over here
    1
    Hello!!

    As far as Facebook sync the best next thing is Haxsync in the market... Sooo worth it and it works great on CM10.

    :)
    1
    Can someone tell me how much the radio take effect on the battery life?
    I'm on stock Rom with radio 1.06es now
    Or will a new radio be flashed with during the flashprogress of cm 10?

    You are not on 1.06es. Check about phone and you will see
    1
    How would you compare photo quality between CM 10.0 Stable and Sense 4.1 ROMs? I understand that CM 10.0 cannot access the HTC ImageSense chip because it's proprietary but is there a noticeable difference in taking pictures between the two ROMs?

    Yes big difference IMO to me it was unacceptable and switched back to sense but it is what it is, maybe someday the sense camera can be ported

    Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app