My Incredible still has jermaine151's In-Sensitive Minimalist ROM with GO EX Launcher and it can give an iPhone 4s a run for its money (actually, it has on several occasions with my relatives' phones), but a stock Galaxy S III generally runs circles around the Incredible (and, by extension, the iPhone 4s) without breaking a sweat.
I still adore the Incredible, but it had a h/w issue where reboots occur during web browsing or video recording at odd times and this turned out to be a not uncommon issue with that line. It fit perfectly in the palm of my hand and was perfect for stashing anywhere, even though I generally kept it in a holster. Mine is an early AMOLED version, which is of course terrific - my spouse's Incredible 2 was great all-around, but my smaller display beat it for clarity and richness quite markedly.
Nevertheless, my hand has adapted to the much larger Galaxy S III footprint in the past month and the larger display real estate has been a (previously unperceived) much-needed relief for these older eyes. Its everyday speed still amazes me - there's no way an Incredible could download 15 updates from Google Play in the background and not experience significant lag in foreground apps, but this Galaxy S III just whistles along.
I would defend the Incredible's historical strengths to extremes, but feel it's more than a stretch to say it remains competitive with my new Samsung - especially since a bootloader unlock method has been released.
- ooofest