[DEV][SEMI-OFFICIAL][BETA-2.3] CyanogenMod 10

milindthakker · Dec 6, 2012

Ok. Removed the links and comments ..
Just felt that Adam needs to be recognized for all the efforts he has spent till now

AcidFX · Dec 6, 2012

It's a pity that Jef had such reaction/ Anyway he is waiting for Adam to contact him, to consider CM10 on GT-i9103.
2 Adam: You're great dev. We all understand how it hurts after many nights spent on this work. Anyway we need you with your support. No one can make R users so happy as you can!

Adam77Root · Dec 6, 2012

Answers

First of all, thanks everybody for the support! This means me a lot!

dman3285 said:
Do what you like.. Yes I started with your tree as a base, and you were given credit as such, I have given you credit for everything I used, but that's why android is an OPEN source community. Also, if you'll check the official device tree you will see that cm made me remove half of it because it wasn't necessary, the pfebuilt folder and kernel and modules, cm devices must build kernels inline. And they made me remove a lot of proprietary files they said were not necessary cause they're built in source. I was skeptical, but I made a build with the new tree and it runs perfect, better than before. The point is, don't give up.. I've been trying for months myself for official support, but I didn't give up... Your a great dev.. Keep going bro... Y'all have a great day...

Sent from my SGH-I927 using xda premium

Yes, you have given credit at the end of your thread. This is the preferred and the appreciated way of doing so. I don't have any problems with it.

Talking about credits:
http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?p=34332781#post34332781: Karthik's fix for camera and HW-acc. No credits.
http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?p=35008981#post35008981: New build released on 4th Dec. I updated my repo (commit: https://github.com/Adam77Root/andro...mmit/11d995fcc7666fda0a9012bc87bc04de85794668) on 2nd Dec. You credited for mobile data, but obviously all other fixes came from there.
http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?p=34924255#post34924255: You said that the extract-files.sh is not appropriate for the Glide. If I do a 'diff' on the two files (my one and that being on CM GitHub), I can only see changes told you by CM team. Others are all the same.

Regarding the 'diff': Here it is: http://pastebin.com/6EAzqXdd Done recursively on my latest GitHub files and CM GitHub files for Glide. There are some changes, it seems. They include:
-Changing device name from galaxyr to i927.
-Putting a './' at the beginning of each line in extract-files.sh.
-Removing some files from extract-files.sh (These are probably that you were sceptical about.).
-Adding some key layouts and modifying previous ones.

Yes, Android is an open source community. But as codeworkx says, this does not mean out-of-respect. Probably all of the changes they told you would be done for the SGR if it got supported. The changes are not difficult to do.

The only question remaining: Why does CM has a mail address to which developers can write if they don't care replying? Then they are pissed of by people writing on their G+ page. One of CyanogenMod's main goal is to support a wide variety of devices. How can they achieve this by such an attitude?

dman3285 said:
The cm team has to fork the tree and kernel source over to the cm github. Then pulled to the cm gerrit for review. I spent two days cleaning the tree up and removing repetitive entries and unnecessary files. And resubmitting. They would review and let me know what else had to be fixed. Then they forked it over. You just have to contact the right cm dev. I've been doing this a long time and many people to this day use my work and I say great as long as I'm given credit. If someone can take my work and make it better or make it work on their device , I'm all for it, that's what android is all about. I will talk to some of the cm devs and see what I can do...

Sent from my SGH-I927 using xda premium

I have to contact the right CM dev: So this means I should write to all of them and someone hopefully responds? Having that e-mail address just turns out again to be pointless.
If someone can take my work and make it better: If you had looked into my files a bit deeper, you would have working camera and torch. I have even posted the camera thing in your thread at some point.

Second, jellybean running on this device is a pretty large hack. (On top of the "hackiness", the device is still not even complete.)

(Quoted from the answer got by The-Droidster.)

The whole hack with the device tree is actually adding some feature. Samsung OMX libs cannot be used with official libs, because they don't have support for it. I wrote in my e-mail:

Core CM source was not modified with one exception. Another stagefright lib needs to be loaded, because the device uses Nvidia and Samsung codecs as well for hardware acceleration. I will push a Gerrit change about it at the weekend.

This clearly describes what is the "hack" about.

Finally: Sorry for making such a long post. You can now see what I talk about. It may be a bit harsh. I don't want to insult anybody. dman3285 is in the P.A.C. and AOCP team and must surely know what he does.

Indha Lezzio · Dec 6, 2012

Adam77Root... is it possible to make you a donation?

Enviado desde mi GT-I9103 usando Tapatalk 2

alfONES · Dec 6, 2012

Adam, please continue to develop CM10.1, but do not spread the source. Do all source closed. Then no one will be able to assign your work, and Glide left without CM10.1.

And, if necessary, say your wallet for donations!

Russia with you, buddy!

dman3285 · Dec 6, 2012

Adam77Root said:
First of all, thanks everybody for the support! This means me a lot!

Yes, you have given credit at the end of your thread. This is the preferred and the appreciated way of doing so. I don't have any problems with it.

Talking about credits:
http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?p=34332781#post34332781: Karthik's fix for camera and HW-acc. No credits.
http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?p=35008981#post35008981: New build released on 4th Dec. I updated my repo (commit: https://github.com/Adam77Root/andro...mmit/11d995fcc7666fda0a9012bc87bc04de85794668) on 2nd Dec. You credited for mobile data, but obviously all other fixes came from there.
http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?p=34924255#post34924255: You said that the extract-files.sh is not appropriate for the Glide. If I do a 'diff' on the two files (my one and that being on CM GitHub), I can only see changes told you by CM team. Others are all the same.

Regarding the 'diff': Here it is: http://pastebin.com/6EAzqXdd Done recursively on my latest GitHub files and CM GitHub files for Glide. There are some changes, it seems. They include:
-Changing device name from galaxyr to i927.
-Putting a './' at the beginning of each line in extract-files.sh.
-Removing some files from extract-files.sh (These are probably that you were sceptical about.).
-Adding some key layouts and modifying previous ones.

Yes, Android is an open source community. But as codeworkx says, this does not mean out-of-respect. Probably all of the changes they told you would be done for the SGR if it got supported. The changes are not difficult to do.

The only question remaining: Why does CM has a mail address to which developers can write if they don't care replying? Then they are pissed of by people writing on their G+ page. One of CyanogenMod's main goal is to support a wide variety of devices. How can they achieve this by such an attitude?

I have to contact the right CM dev: So this means I should write to all of them and someone hopefully responds? Having that e-mail address just turns out again to be pointless.
If someone can take my work and make it better: If you had looked into my files a bit deeper, you would have working camera and torch. I have even posted the camera thing in your thread at some point.

(Quoted from the answer got by The-Droidster.)

The whole hack with the device tree is actually adding some feature. Samsung OMX libs cannot be used with official libs, because they don't have support for it. I wrote in my e-mail:

This clearly describes what is the "hack" about.

Finally: Sorry for making such a long post. You can now see what I talk about. It may be a bit harsh. I don't want to insult anybody. dman3285 is in the P.A.C. and AOCP team and must surely know what he does.

I was going to talk to codeworkx about making the tree compatible for both devices but posts like this is just plain whiny. And being accused of stealing just pisses me off. This is rediculous. Don't want people using your stuff don't release the source. This is not what android is all about. Your a good dev but clearly don't get the meaning of AOSP.

Just keep supporting your community the android way of sharing open source. Don't abandon them.
You guys have a good day.

Sent from my SGH-I927 using xda premium

mj.vikram · Dec 7, 2012

Friend's i have spoken with one of the CM Developer and he is also Elite Recognized Developer on XDA and i have explained entire story and asked him for help and in return he replied me in this way.....

Both he and one more CM Developer examined the Adam's code and replied to me:

Code:

It's currently being discussed internally.

If i look at adams device tree, i can see that he also kanged a lot of our work (bdaddr_read, tvout, liblights and so on) without mentioning it in the commit messaged.
But that's not really needed since he left the copyright untouched where our names are on.
So basically he used all the hard stuff from us. Setting up a device tree with makefiles and copying config files in is "kinder garten".

I think it's not fair to start fighting against the i927 guy. Both of those guys reused other peoples work.

So CM Team is aware of Adam and Galaxy R, Give them some time to take decision....

lmali92 · Dec 7, 2012

So Adam let me tell u this.
We don't know if the CM team will give you the recognition u deserve but what u have done to the us Galaxy R users is priceless.
You gave us JB which I had no hope for when Samsung was delaying even ICS so much!
We really value your work and would love to make u a donation if you give us the details.

Sent from my Adam powered GT-I9103

Serp87 · Dec 7, 2012

as you can swap memory on CM10?

thefish07 · Dec 7, 2012

So, the question is, if both of the ROMs are not properly prepared by Devs, how could glide got official support?

Sent from my CM10/Adam77Root (Official for us) powered Galaxy R

Aquethys · Dec 7, 2012

Dman is part of the cyanogenmod team.
They are packaged correctly.

Can we please drop this now? This is a development thread

Sent from my SGH-I747 using Tapatalk 2

D™ · Dec 8, 2012

Serp87 said:
as you can swap memory on CM10?

yes you can swap it by editing build.prop file with 0 to 1 or 1 to 0 value. search it buddy. you will get it.

Serp87 · Dec 8, 2012

kataria.vikesh said:
yes you can swap it by editing build.prop file with 0 to 1 or 1 to 0 value. search it buddy. you will get it.

thanks i did and it worked

nilesh19932 · Dec 11, 2012

so adam has stopped working on our device ?:crying::crying::crying:

D™ · Dec 11, 2012

nilesh19932 said:
so adam has stopped working on our device ?:crying::crying::crying:

No buddy. He is taking rest & making his mind for releasing 10.1 for our device. I know he will do it for us. We (galaxy R Forum) are more valuable to him then CM Team.

Note: This is not the rumor i m spreading about 10.1 for our device. Adam is a great man & no CM kinda thing can break his aim for us. We love him, so he will come back with his new electrify energy.

karthik050782 · Dec 11, 2012

Yep! Got a pm from him... he is working on cm 10.1

Sent from my GT-I9103 using xda app-developers app

D™ · Dec 11, 2012

karthik050782 said:
Yep! Got a pm from him... he is working on cm 10.1

Sent from my GT-I9103 using xda app-developers app

Yes buddy. What can i say. He is my bro like u karthik buddy. Thats why i wrote. Soon we will get it. Coz he loves us more then CM guys.

Sent from my Samsung® Galaxy Royale(i9103)® with PAC Rom

alfONES · Dec 11, 2012

karthik050782 said:
Yep! Got a pm from him... he is working on cm 10.1

Adam, I LOVE YOU! :victory:

Pradeep21 · Dec 11, 2012

Adam UR GREAT

Adikbzik · Dec 11, 2012

That's impressive. Even when every world stay opposite he is still doing hes work. I wish to have strong will like you do Adam. Good luck.

Sent from my GT-I9103 using xda app-developers app

[DEV][SEMI-OFFICIAL][BETA-2.3] CyanogenMod 10

Senior Member

Senior Member

Inactive Recognized Developer

Senior Member

Member

Inactive Recognized Developer

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Retired Forum Moderator

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Similar threads

Top Liked Posts