Just curious - is there any reason that root requires a modded kernel?
Would it minimally suffice to just flash CWM to a fresh i957 and then apply the correct su.zip from CWM? Or are there root apps that wouldn't work under those circumstances?
Or perhaps there is a mistake in the Method 1 instructions. When it says "7. Hit Start - the modded kernel should will be flashed to the tablet. Tablet will restart." should that be recovery rather than kernel?
When just flashing the recovery in Odin, does that trip the internal flash counter too?
Thank you for pointing that out. I made the change in method 1. Method one is stock kernel with only cwm and su.zip