I've got both, they're both pretty great.
* Aluminum is great, so is the curved body
* Front speakers are phenomenal
* Display looks terrific
* There is a google play edition!
* Camer works great in low light and elsewhere
* The buttons are the dumbest decision ever
* Sense is pretty bad for the non google play edition
* Camera has low resolution
* Feels absolutely terrific in hand
* SOFTWARE BUTTONS!!!!
* Loud Speaker
* Dimple in the back!
* Touchless control and camera gesture
* AT&T logo and AT&T Address book.......
* Locked down tighter than fort knox on AT&T
* Camera is not good
* Pricing is a bit iffy
* Moto Support is clueless
It's hard to go wrong.