SIM restrictions on unlocked European Note3

Search This thread

midnite_blue

Senior Member
Jul 13, 2013
191
68
Seattle
listening but not doing vs. doing and not listening

I have reached an impasse.... Low marks go to Samsung UK HQ and global management for ducking the issue and expecting it to go away.

I'm saddened to hear this, dxzh. You have, IMHO, made the most significant contributions to our understanding of the technical side of this issue... and done so in the most fair handed of ways. I can only imagine that you've engaged in your recent dealings with Samsung in the most clear and civil manner possible. If you can't get a decent response from Samsung UK's HQ, I believe it cannot be done.

It appears that Samsung UK is more afraid of Samsung Global than they are concerned about our understanding of what's going on. I shy from the cynicism of the following, but it seems unavoidable: UK management believes that losing loyalty and sales by stonewalling us is better than risking the ire of someone at Global by helping us with honesty and clarity. If crossing this person at Global wouldn't cause heads to roll in retaliation, at a minimum bonuses and promotions would be lost.

To the people at Chertsey reading this, I hope you have another Internet tab open looking for a better job, working for better masters. I have empathy for the dilemma you're in as on the one hand you look to maintain the lifestyle you, your spouse and your children have become accustomed to, while, on the other, you consider the cost to your personal values and your principles... to your beliefs in how to run a good company. I've been there myself. You're not unlike dxzh in a complementary sort of way, loyal to a vision of a firm you thought was better, an organization you know could be better, but bewildered about how to make it so.

The people put in a position supposedly to listen to us have been ordered to do nothing in response. The people capable of responding to us have no interest in listening.

And so as the veil of media promotion now gets pulled aside, we see the difference between what Samsung advertises itself to be... and the company it really is.
 
Last edited:

Limeybastard

Senior Member
I'm saddened to hear this, dxzh. You have, IMHO, made the most significant contributions to our understanding of the technical side of this issue... and done so in the most fair handed of ways. I can only imagine that you've engaged in your recent dealings with Samsung in the most clear and civil manner possible. If you can't get a decent response from Samsung UK's HQ, I believe it cannot be done.

It appears that Samsung UK is more afraid of Samsung Global than they are concerned about our understanding of what's going on. I shy from the cynicism of the following, but it seems unavoidable: UK management believes that losing loyalty and sales by stonewalling us is better than risking the ire of someone at Global by helping us with honesty and clarity. If crossing this person at Global wouldn't cause heads to roll in retaliation, at a minimum bonuses and promotions would be lost.

To the people at Chertsey reading this, I hope you have another Internet tab open looking for a better job, working for better masters. I have empathy for the dilemma you're in as on the one hand you look to maintain the lifestyle you, your spouse and your children have become accustomed to, while, on the other, you consider the cost to your personal values and your principles... to your beliefs in how to run a good company. I've been there myself. You're not unlike dxzh in a complementary sort of way, loyal to a vision of a firm you thought was better, an organization you know could be better, but bewildered about how to make it so.

The people put in a position supposedly to listen to us have been ordered to do nothing in response. The people capable of responding to us have no interest in listening.

And so as the veil of media promotion now gets pulled aside, we see the difference between what Samsung advertises itself to be... and the company it really is.

---------- Post added at 04:00 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:36 PM ----------






Your heart's in the right place, Ahmads001!

(I think artesea's is, too. He was just trying to figure out the mechanism for the lockout... it's a big part of what we do here... and, to be fair, he posted that almost a month ago, on the first day of this debacle, 1246 posts ago. :) Keep reading beyond his post #15 and you'll get a fuller picture of artesea's position on the lockout. And welcome to the forum!!)

A bit melodramatic aren't we now fella? I almost cried reading this.:crying:
 

midnite_blue

Senior Member
Jul 13, 2013
191
68
Seattle
3 pairs of questions for Samsung, part 2

3 pairs of questions for Samsung, part 2


3. why have so many units not unlocked when your official procedure was followed?

4. why have some units spontaneously unlocked while others haven't?


Silence breeds speculation. It looks like you have burdened a region-lockout design -- poorly conceived and disastrously implemented -- with overly complex variations:

a) which you don't want to reveal in a misguided attempt to control how we use our phones, and

b) which you yourselves no longer fully comprehend.


Some will assume that you are refusing to address these questions because you believe it's none of our business and that you don't value a collaboration with your consumer base.

Say it isn't so.
 

midnite_blue

Senior Member
Jul 13, 2013
191
68
Seattle
I believe it would just be a software restriction based on the IMSI of the SIM card inserted.

So, how does that solve the problem? IMSI
any real solutions? cos lots of people have real issues here!


Your heart's in the right place, Ahmads001!

(I think artesea's is, too. He was just trying to figure out the mechanism for the lockout... it's a big part of what we do here... and, to be fair, he posted that almost a month ago, on the first day of this debacle, 1246 posts ago.* :)* Keep reading beyond his post #15 and you'll get a fuller picture of artesea's position on the lockout.* And welcome to the forum!!)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

‹‹I've been having trouble with this site appending my posts to my last post, even with an hour or two between them... and it changes the timestamp of the original post. Anyway, I just separated this post from one earlier today.››
 

Ahmads001

Member
Dec 6, 2008
26
3
Lagos
sim restriction on galaxy note3 lte

Your heart's in the right place, Ahmads001!

(I think artesea's is, too. He was just trying to figure out the mechanism for the lockout... it's a big part of what we do here... and, to be fair, he posted that almost a month ago, on the first day of this debacle, 1246 posts ago.* :)* Keep reading beyond his post #15 and you'll get a fuller picture of artesea's position on the lockout.* And welcome to the forum!!)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

‹‹I've been having trouble with this site appending my posts to my last post, even with an hour or two between them... and it changes the timestamp of the original post. Anyway, I just separated this post from one earlier today.››

thanks for the insight.
but more seriously, can any one please supply me with credible sites where i can purchase the sim unlock code.
i emailed the Russian, but no replies till now. not even an acknowledgement of my mail.
i've also tried fastgsm.com, problem there is that youre supposed to pay usd25 via paypal, which does not operate in nigeria. i asked for an alternative modality of payment, but again, the guys at fast gsm just went mute on me!
my suppossedly "unlocked" sim-locked SM-N9005 arrived yesterday from saudi arabia. it was "activated" there with a saudi sim x1day, but still does not recognise any of my local provider sims here in nigeria- MTN, AIRTEL, GLO...!
can anyone please help

---------- Post added at 09:41 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:35 AM ----------

thanks for the insight.
but more seriously, can any one please supply me with credible sites where i can purchase the sim unlock code.
i emailed the Russian, but no replies till now. not even an acknowledgement of my mail.
i've also tried fastgsm.com, problem there is that youre supposed to pay usd25 via paypal, which does not operate in nigeria. i asked for an alternative modality of payment, but again, the guys at fast gsm just went mute on me!
my suppossedly "unlocked" sim-locked SM-N9005 arrived yesterday from saudi arabia. it was "activated" there with a saudi sim x1day, but still does not recognise any of my local provider sims here in nigeria- MTN, AIRTEL, GLO...!
can anyone please help
thanks for the insight.
but more seriously, can any one please supply me with credible sites where i can purchase the sim unlock code.
i emailed the Russian, but no replies till now. not even an acknowledgement of my mail.
i've also tried fastgsm.com, problem there is that youre supposed to pay usd25 via paypal, which does not operate in nigeria. i asked for an alternative modality of payment, but again, the guys at fast gsm just went mute on me!
my suppossedly "unlocked" sim-locked SM-N9005 arrived yesterday from saudi arabia. it was "activated" there with a saudi sim x1day, but still does not recognise any of my local provider sims here in nigeria- MTN, AIRTEL, GLO...!
can anyone please help
 

flygaren

Member
Oct 9, 2007
7
11
Ok, so now I have been in Thailand for a little over three weeks and the phone is still working fine with a Thai sim.

---------- Post added at 08:48 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:41 AM ----------

thanks for the insight.
but more seriously, can any one please supply me with credible sites where i can purchase the sim unlock code.
i emailed the Russian, but no replies till now. not even an acknowledgement of my mail.
i've also tried fastgsm.com, problem there is that youre supposed to pay usd25 via paypal, which does not operate in nigeria. i asked for an alternative modality of payment, but again, the guys at fast gsm just went mute on me!
my suppossedly "unlocked" sim-locked SM-N9005 arrived yesterday from saudi arabia. it was "activated" there with a saudi sim x1day, but still does not recognise any of my local provider sims here in nigeria- MTN, AIRTEL, GLO...!
can anyone please help

---------- Post added at 09:41 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:35 AM ----------


thanks for the insight.
but more seriously, can any one please supply me with credible sites where i can purchase the sim unlock code.
i emailed the Russian, but no replies till now. not even an acknowledgement of my mail.
i've also tried fastgsm.com, problem there is that youre supposed to pay usd25 via paypal, which does not operate in nigeria. i asked for an alternative modality of payment, but again, the guys at fast gsm just went mute on me!
my suppossedly "unlocked" sim-locked SM-N9005 arrived yesterday from saudi arabia. it was "activated" there with a saudi sim x1day, but still does not recognise any of my local provider sims here in nigeria- MTN, AIRTEL, GLO...!
can anyone please help

Try the Russian on Skype then.
Skype name: smsmts
 
Last edited:

Ahmads001

Member
Dec 6, 2008
26
3
Lagos
Stop buying Samsung....
...and what do we do with the ones we just spent a fortune to purchase?

---------- Post added at 10:15 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:55 AM ----------

Ok, so now I have been in Thailand for a little over three weeks and the phone is still working fine with a Thai sim.

---------- Post added at 08:48 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:41 AM ----------



Try the Russian on Skype then.
Skype name: smsmts
thanks.
tried that too, but he's still not replying!
 

dxzh

Senior Member
Sep 16, 2010
136
134
That press statement, in the first sentence of the second paragraph, states: "Nach der Erstaktivierung in der vorgesehenen Region ist eine Benutzung von SIM-Karten ausländischer Provider nach wie vor uneingeschränkt möglich". This can be understood as saying that after the device has been activated first within the region specified for that purpose, the use of SIM cards of foreign providers is possible without any restriction.

After receipt of that statement, I went ahead and purchased the device. A few days later, the issue came up again. I then noted that a careful reader can interpret the statement in different ways: I had wanted to understand it as saying that after the activation with my German SIM card, I am free to use the phone even with the most obscure SIM card I can find in the world. However, by taking a second look, the statement does NOT say that the device can be used by just any microSIM from just anywhere on this globe. It just says that it can be used with SIM cards from outside the originally designated region for the activation.

In short, dxzh: the statement in German is not clear at all. It is the same newspeak you find in the English version.

.

Thank you for pointing me in the direction of that press statement. Some equivalent sentences in the German press release seem more clear-cut than the English one - in that they are clearly referring to SIM cards from other regions as well as referring to other affected phone models. So:

"Welche Auswirkungen hat die Sperre bei der Benutzung außerhalb Deutschlands?

Mit einer SIM-Karte aus Deutschland kann der Roaming-Service des Providers genutzt werden.
Mit einer SIM-Karte aus einer anderen Region gilt:
Wenn das Gerät in Deutschland mit einer deutschen SIMKarte aktiviert und benutzt wurde, kann es ohne Einschränkung mit SIM-Karten aus anderen Regionen verwendet werden.
"

and

"Die regionale SIM-Karten-Sperre betrifft nur die folgenden Samsung Modelle, die ab Ende Juli 2013 hergestellt und mit einem entsprechenden Aufkleber versehen sind:

Samsung GALAXY S III, GALAXY Note II, GALAXY S4, GALAXY S4 mini und das GALAXY Note 3.

Geräte, die bereits von Samsung ausgeliefert wurden und sich in Lagern oder bereits bei Endkunden befinden, sind nicht betroffen.
"

Google translates this as:

" What impact has the lock in use outside Germany ?

With a SIM card from Germany to the roaming service provider's can be used .
With a SIM card from another region is :
If the device has been activated and used in Germany with a German SIM card , it can be used without restriction with SIM cards from other regions.
"

and

"The regional SIM card lock only affects the following Samsung models that are produced from the end of July 2013, and provided with a corresponding sticker :

Samsung GALAXY S III , II, GALAXY Note , GALAXY S4 , S4 GALAXY mini and the GALAXY Note 3

Devices that have been delivered by Samsung and are in camps or even at retail are not affected .
"

Whether all or only some such SIM cards from outside of the region can be used, is perhaps left open to doubt. However, at least the German statement is clear in its reference to SIM cards from outside the region. Also I note that the German press statement requires the SIM card to have been both activated AND used ('benutzt') - which tallies more closely perhaps with the delays seen in the release of the regional SIM lock.

Not sure if there is any equivalent translation in French or other European language which is out there.
 

midnite_blue

Senior Member
Jul 13, 2013
191
68
Seattle
...can any one please supply me with credible sites where i can purchase the sim unlock code.
i emailed the Russian, but no replies till now. not even an acknowledgement of my mail.
...
my suppossedly "unlocked" sim-locked SM-N9005 arrived yesterday from saudi arabia. it was "activated" there with a saudi sim x1day, but still does not recognise any of my local provider sims here in nigeria- MTN, AIRTEL, GLO...!

can anyone please help

Try the Russian on Skype then.
Skype name: smsmts


A. Did the Saudi vendor include the Saudi sim card when they sent the phone, and if so, are you able to make roaming calls with your phone in Nigeria, using that sim?

B. I'm surprised that puman.ru has been slow in getting back to you. They accepted my contact request on Skype almost immediately -- using the Skype name that flygaren suggests. And they answered my email in exactly 40 minutes. I assume you used smsmts@gmail.com when you emailed them.

C. What happens exactly when you try your local sims?

D. Would you check the build # under Settings / About phone and let us know what it is?
 

Ahmads001

Member
Dec 6, 2008
26
3
Lagos
sim restriction on galaxy note3 lte

:(:(
Ok, so now I have been in Thailand for a little over three weeks and the phone is still working fine with a Thai sim.

---------- Post added at 08:48 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:41 AM ----------



Try the Russian on Skype then.
Skype name: smsmts
thanks.
tried that too, but he's still not replying!

is there any place else, please?

---------- Post added at 10:33 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:20 AM ----------

A. Did the Saudi vendor include the Saudi sim card when they sent the phone, and if so, are you able to make roaming calls with your phone in Nigeria, using that sim?

B. I'm surprised that puman.ru has been slow in getting back to you. They accepted my contact request on Skype almost immediately -- using the Skype name that flygaren suggests. And they answered my email in exactly 40 minutes. I assume you used smsmts@gmail.com when you emailed them.

C. What happens exactly when you try your local sims?

D. Would you check the build # under Settings / About phone and let us know what it is?
thanks for the concern.

A. the phone was bought full-paid no contract. So, its commited to a particular network. A free Saudi sim, which i regularly use when i travel over there was used to power on the phone, and make a call to nigeria, which went through. the sim still worked in Nigeria, roaming, yesterday.

B. Yes i used smsmts@gmail.com. no replies. till now

C. "invalid sim card".
"ENTRE SIMLOCK CODE"

D. Build number: JSS15J.N9005XXUBMI7

there!

---------- Post added at 10:41 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:33 AM ----------

:(
A. Did the Saudi vendor include the Saudi sim card when they sent the phone, and if so, are you able to make roaming calls with your phone in Nigeria, using that sim?

B. I'm surprised that puman.ru has been slow in getting back to you. They accepted my contact request on Skype almost immediately -- using the Skype name that flygaren suggests. And they answered my email in exactly 40 minutes. I assume you used smsmts@gmail.com when you emailed them.

C. What happens exactly when you try your local sims?

D. Would you check the build # under Settings / About phone and let us know what it is?
thanks for the concern.

A. the phone was bought full-paid no contract. So, its NOT :(commited to a particular network. A free Saudi sim, which i regularly use when i travel over there was used to power on the phone, and make a call to nigeria, which went through. the sim still worked in Nigeria, roaming, yesterday.

B. Yes i used smsmts@gmail.com. no replies. till now

C. "invalid sim card".
"ENTRE SIMLOCK CODE"

D. Build number: JSS15J.N9005XXUBMI7

there!
 

penfold

Senior Member
May 20, 2010
758
261
I have reached an impasse with the Samsung UK technical support team (in NI) and the Samsung UK customer service and complaints team (in Gatesborough). Both teams confirm that they can say no more than is in their stock email (see http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=46193928&postcount=915) which is that users can use "other region's SIM" card when travelling. They cannot simply confirm that this means a SIM from any other region can be used rather than other SIMs from the [home] region - and the customer service team now deny the existence of a call I had with their own customer service rep at 5:48pm on 16 October, in which I was told that they would take the matter up with Samsung UK HQ in Chertsey as the only people who might clarify the region lock policy, and I can therefore see no clarity coming from Samsung UK HQ either.

Obviously, Samsung UK also cannot confirm the impact of the region lock feature on existing phones which are already in use and to be upgraded in selective markets with this regional lock feature. Again, this is because all the call centre staff know is limited to what is contained in the stock announcement. Perhaps not surprising for a call centre they have no discretion or indeed knowledge to enable them to vary from the stock script although some have clearly sought to try and find out more about the issue independently in the media.

Generally high marks go to Samsung UK call centre staff for willingness to listen. Low marks go to Samsung UK HQ and global management for ducking the issue and expecting it to go away. I still would like to buy this phone, but with the current level of customer support and the studied silence from those who run Samsung, I am not rushing out to do so - and I am now not sure I will do so for any other Samsung phone with the same issues.

What is slightly bizarre is Samsung seem intent on alienating long term users of their products who often are the only ones fighting a rearguard action for Samsung/android in the corporates in which Samsung is looking to win greater market share. Speaking personally as an advocate for Samsung against the overwhelming number of Apple enthusiasts with whom I work, I will not be so keen in future to eulogise its Galaxy phones, given Samsung UK's determined unwillingness to deal clearly and transparently with what is essentially a simple point.

A question for German speakers: is the equivalent German announcement clearer in its meaning? That is, does it clearly say that all SIMs from all other regions will be able to be used once the phone has been activated for the first time? Or might this just be a poor English translation of a Korean press release?

seriously mate? ....well if after all you went through you and how you agree samsung are behaving would still like to buy this or any other samsung phone I have no sympathies ...it just boggles my mind, but go for it, and you can keep whinging through your next six samsung phones that won't work.
 

sphuyal

Senior Member
Sep 1, 2009
757
134
OSLO
I purchased my Note 3 in Norway and used a Norwegian Tele Operator sim card in it for the first time. I then went away for three weeks long vacation, tried the "foreign" SIM card...Guess what! regional lock was still there!

Thanks for lying SAMSUNG! This will be the last device i purchase from you!
 

Ahmads001

Member
Dec 6, 2008
26
3
Lagos
:(
A. Did the Saudi vendor include the Saudi sim card when they sent the phone, and if so, are you able to make roaming calls with your phone in Nigeria, using that sim?

B. I'm surprised that puman.ru has been slow in getting back to you. They accepted my contact request on Skype almost immediately -- using the Skype name that flygaren suggests. And they answered my email in exactly 40 minutes. I assume you used smsmts@gmail.com when you emailed them.

C. What happens exactly when you try your local sims?

D. Would you check the build # under Settings / About phone and let us know what it is?
thanks for the concern.

A. the phone was bought full-paid no contract. So, its NOT :(commited to a particular network. A free Saudi sim, which i regularly use when i travel over there was used to power on the phone, and make a call to nigeria, which went through. the sim still worked in Nigeria, roaming, yesterday.

B. Yes i used smsmts@gmail.com. no replies. till now

C. "invalid sim card".
"ENTRE SIMLOCK CODE"

D. Build number: JSS15J.N9005XXUBMI7

there!
 

avenging

Senior Member
Sep 28, 2013
619
80
:(:(
thanks.
tried that too, but he's still not replying!

is there any place else, please?

---------- Post added at 10:33 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:20 AM ----------


thanks for the concern.

A. the phone was bought full-paid no contract. So, its commited to a particular network. A free Saudi sim, which i regularly use when i travel over there was used to power on the phone, and make a call to nigeria, which went through. the sim still worked in Nigeria, roaming, yesterday.

B. Yes i used smsmts@gmail.com. no replies. till now

C. "invalid sim card".
"ENTRE SIMLOCK CODE"

D. Build number: JSS15J.N9005XXUBMI7

there!

---------- Post added at 10:41 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:33 AM ----------

:(
thanks for the concern.

A. the phone was bought full-paid no contract. So, its NOT :(commited to a particular network. A free Saudi sim, which i regularly use when i travel over there was used to power on the phone, and make a call to nigeria, which went through. the sim still worked in Nigeria, roaming, yesterday.

B. Yes i used smsmts@gmail.com. no replies. till now

C. "invalid sim card".
"ENTRE SIMLOCK CODE"

D. Build number: JSS15J.N9005XXUBMI7

there!


did you by chance buy yours at jarir bookstore? as far as I know so far they re among the few who sell region locked phones, others are selling them unlocked
 

Ahmads001

Member
Dec 6, 2008
26
3
Lagos
:(
thanks for the concern.

A. the phone was bought full-paid no contract. So, its NOT :(commited to a particular network. A free Saudi sim, which i regularly use when i travel over there was used to power on the phone, and make a call to nigeria, which went through. the sim still worked in Nigeria, roaming, yesterday.

B. Yes i used smsmts@gmail.com. no replies. till now

C. "invalid sim card".
"ENTRE SIMLOCK CODE"

D. Build number: JSS15J.N9005XXUBMI7

there!


NO. NOT FROM JARIR.

THE PHONE WAS PURCHASED FROM EL-MUTAHIDOON COMMUNICATIONS, Palestine Road Jeddah
suggestions?
 

midnite_blue

Senior Member
Jul 13, 2013
191
68
Seattle
...Also I note that the German press statement requires the SIM card to have been both activated AND used ('benutzt') - which tallies more closely perhaps with the delays seen in the release of the regional SIM lock....


By 'used' do you mean, for example, making a phone call using the proper sim while within the region that's identified on the sticker?

(Both fergusstrachan and RbbCHan have reported here that they've heard the same from their contacts with Samsung customer service... these Samsung reps have said you need to "register" the phone by using it first in the home region.)

I'm not clear about how you see this factor relating to 'the delays seen in the release of the regional SIM lock.' Do you mean that, if the person received their phone while they're out-of-region, activation may be delayed until the person returns to the home region to use their phone?
 

dxzh

Senior Member
Sep 16, 2010
136
134
By 'used' do you mean, for example, making a phone call using the proper sim while within the region that's identified on the sticker?

(Both fergusstrachan and RbbCHan have reported here that they've heard the same from their contacts with Samsung customer service... these Samsung reps have said you need to "register" the phone by using it first in the home region.)

I'm not clear about how you see this factor relating to 'the delays seen in the release of the regional SIM lock.' Do you mean that, if the person received their phone while they're out-of-region, activation may be delayed until the person returns to the home region to use their phone?

The distinction I was trying to highlight is that while the UK statement requires "activation" of the phone, the German statement expressly requires its "activation" and "use" with a home region SIM card.

If the German statement is closer to the truth, then it would perhaps explain (not excuse) the continued blocking of the SIM-free phones by a usage test, after the user has activated the phone - activation, in this sense, meaning simply to put a home region SIM in the phone. If the German statement is correct that there is a usage test in addition to an activation requirement, then the terms of such usage test have been hidden away by Samsung to the needless disadvantage of its customers who have bought in good faith an unlocked phone, activated it with a home region SIM and then found that Samsung's regional SIM lock continues deliberately and incompetently and without explanation to block the phone's use with SIMs from other regions.

Fyi, Apple UK have a somewhat more transparent unlocked device policy than Samsung UK. Apple UK say: "Can I use my iPhone outside my home country? Yes. iPhone is enabled to work on networks using GSM around the world. Because the iPhone sold by the Apple Online Store is unlocked, you can purchase a SIM card and service from a local carrier at your destination. Or check with your home carrier regarding international roaming charges." There is an activation step it seems but no usage requirement.
 

Top Liked Posts

  • There are no posts matching your filters.
  • 21
    give me a N3 and we will see...

    i don't get what all the fuss is about, people in israel keep getting USA phones that are locked and just unlock them to sim free
    no one ever said a thing about it, USA cellphone is locked to a single operator is OK for every one
    now samsung made it locked to all EU operators but did the mistake and called it "unlocked" and not "eu unlocked" or "eu locked" big deal

    i unlocked USA phones and will unlock EU phones, the earth still goes on.... no one died


    why?

    The reason people are nervous is straightforward:

    1) The phones claim to be "Unlocked' - they are not.

    2) There is no evidence that traditional unlock methods will work -
    a) I have discussed this with my source for unlocking phones by code - he unlocks about 100,000 phones a year, and has access to all the databases. He has never heard of such a thing, and is not confident that codes will be available.
    b) Software solutions may or may not be available. Even so, not everybody is technical enough (or wants) to start butchering their phones. Further, we have customers who need these phones unlocked for network-testing purposes. They are aware of the software-unlock methods and do not want that as they claim it messes with the phone's firmware.

    3) No one was informed of this before they purchased the device. Even the largest distributors (10s of thousands of phones - not retailers) only found out about it today.and have no answers

    This is totally different than just purchasing an AT&T phone from the USA and getting it unlocked in Israel. Everybody knows how to do it and where to get it done. However, nobody knows how to do this phone, or if it even can be unlocked as this is a new type of lock that nobody yet understands or has successfully unlocked.

    We also have these phone on our website, and we had to call each one of our customers that pre-ordered and explain the situation. Some didn't mind, and some were really pissed off and cancelled the orders.

    I hope you are correct, and we can all pay our $20.00 and get the code. However, that remains to be seen.

    And, on an OEM, carrier-unbranded device that can cost $900, and claims to be "factory unlocked" but is not, it is just bad business IMHO.


    Dovid Feldman
    On The Go Solutions, Inc
    16
    From my Twitter ...

    Aaaaand.... I just region unlocked my Note 3. FU Samsung.

    ( I locked out my current carrier, tested I could no longer make phone calls, then unlocked it again, et voila )

    I need a tester (with root) who has a SIM card that isn't working in his or her Note3. For verification. Then, app incoming.

    'nuff said !
    15
    There'll be an app release soon enough.

    If you don't want root for other reasons, it is indeed unfortunate you currently need it for this. Rooting (via CF-Auto-Root) does void KNOX warranty (irreversable), however, if you use the unroot option in SuperSU, and flash back a stock kernel and recovery, OTAs will work again. Note that it is possible to root without tripping KNOX warranty using a customized system partition, I'm sure someone has made or will make one sooner or later.

    It is theoretically feasable to do this without root, but a lot tougher to make and maintain, with the information I currently have. I'm certain there is a way to improve this, I just haven't found it yet - and as I'm a full on root user, I doubt I will spend more time looking for it.
    14
    Latest News - Oct 9th 2013 - Clove, who specialise in sim-free/unlocked phones have suggested
    that the Russian unlocking service at:
    http://puman.ru/?selectlanguage=English
    may be a solution for those concerned about the regional lock.
    More info in the Clove blog at:
    http://blog.clove.co.uk/2013/09/25/samsung-galaxy-note-3-sim-limitations/


    Whether or not the Note 3 Verizon (US) "Developer Edition" will be regionally locked remains to be seen,
    At least the bootloader will, according to reports, be unlocked.
    More skimpy details at the Samsung/Verizon page at: http://www.samsung.com/us/mobile/cell-phones/SM-N900VMKEVZW

    More Recent News - Oct 6th 2013 - Chainfire appears to have created an app to
    get round region locking for the Galaxy Note 3 SM-N9005 (MI7 firmware) and rooted
    You can buy Chainfire a beer (£1.99) by downloading the app from the Play Store at:
    http://pkg.to/eu.chainfire.regionlockaway

    There is also a thread started by Chainfire at: http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?p=46187852 where meanies(!) can download it free.


    Recent News (01:30 Oct 3rd 2013)
    Android Authority: Galaxy Note 3 region lock is an issue after all, Android 4.4 update may lock older Galaxy handsets http://goo.gl/KjgVwc


    Previous news (1st Oct 2013)

    A significant number of users still claim they can't use "out of region" sims despite having first used a sim for the region the Note 3 was intended for which is the way Samsung have said is the way to 'unlock' the regional sim lock.

    A number of users in this thread who found their Note3 was still region locked despite following the Samsung advice have successfully unlocked their Note3 regional lock using a Russian unlocking web site at http://puman.ru/ Although I am the OP of this thread, I do not have an out of region Sim to test this out myself - so no guarantees but read the posts!

    Pics say it all. The Note 3 "unlocked" models are still locked to regions like DVD's and thus not very attractive to globetrotters or international purchasers who are being asked to pay £600 or so for a crippled device.
    u5abydaz.jpg

    qe3atyge.jpg
    9uja6y5e.jpg
    13
    Health warning: the message below is worrying.

    I spoke yet again to the Samsung UK customer service team (+44 330 726 7864) this afternoon (at 5:40pm GMT) as I had not received the email I had been promised this morning with a statement on the region lock. A different rep spoke to me and had the following news to report to me:

    - the Samsung UK telephone staff have had problems sending out emails today and therefore have not sent out the statement to me - which was fine by me as these things happen.

    - the SIM limitation sticker really is meant to mean what it says - the N9005 is not meant to be compatible with SIMs issued by operators outside the European region - I believe at least some owners are using the Note 3 with SIMs issued by operators outside the EU but the rep was adamant that the Note 3 was not intended by Samsung to be used with SIMs issued by operators outside of the European region, even following first activation.

    - the European region Note 3s are only meant to be compatible with SIMs issued by operators from the European region, and this applies equally after activation - I asked repeatedly her to confirm this which she did each time. I tried practical examples too and it got worse: So if I go to Australia I must use a European region SIM in my Note 3 even if I buy the Note 3 SIM-free for £620? Yes according to the rep. So I asked if I go to Florida on vacation, I have no choice but to use a European region SIM in my Note 3? Yes again according to rep.

    - it makes no difference if here in the UK I buy the Note 3 from Carphone Warehouse, Phones 4U, EE or Clove.

    - I could buy another phone if I wanted to use a SIM from an operator outside the EU in my mobile - the rep volunteered this to me as it never occurred to me that they might seriously suggest such a policy.

    - the rollout of Kitkat is to extend the regional lock to existing SGS3s and Note 2s - I asked if my existing unlocked SGS3 bought unlocked over a year ago is to be subject to the same regional lock if I upgrade. Yes according to rep. So I would not be able to use a SIM from outside the European region in it when travelling? Yes according to the rep.

    - no statement can be sent in an email to me by the Samsung UK telephone team to confirm this in writing.

    - I can email uk.help@samsung.com with any questions but it might take up to 24 hours to respond. When I pointed out to the rep that I had already done just this, emailing uk.help@samsung.com on Friday evening (27th) and not had a response in over 50 hours (including after checking my spam folder), I was told that sometimes the email team are very busy and she could not say for sure when I would receive a response to any question.

    I have asked to get a call back from the Tier 2 rep who I spoke to on Friday (27th) but in the meanwhile I can only stand gobsmacked by the apparent madness of this corporate policy. For example:

    - Samsung cannot even implement a draconian region lock policy (if that is what they really intend) properly and consistently - given that some European Note 3s with the European regional lock sticker are reported to be being activated and then successfully used outside the home region with SIMs issued by operators outside the home region - while others are able to activate with home region SIM but not then able to use out of region SIMs when travelling.

    - Samsung (whether through its local offices, PR companies or employees) can brief against itself so that some Samsung offices will say one thing and others possibly within the same office, something completely different, on the same day, and day after day.

    - the utter, utter lack of leadership from Samsung Global (Electronics) to coordinate and communicate their own policy (whether that policy is good or bad is almost irrelevant) clearly, consistently and transparently - or to communicate it at all.

    - complete confusion among retailers, and among Samsung reps talking to retailers, here in the UK as to Samsung's region lock policy, to the extent they are even aware in the first place of the region lock policy and how it operates - which, from first hand exerience, I can say many are not.