Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,729,023 Members 41,080 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

Thoughts of let down with a hint of mutiny...

Tip us?
 
03stage2
Old
#1  
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 9
Posts: 45
Join Date: May 2011
Default Thoughts of let down with a hint of mutiny...

Odd title eh'?

So here is the boat I am swimming in. I jumped on the Xoom bandwagon when it was released. I immediately was fascinated with the tablet experience and enjoyed it. The Xoom certainly had its issues but was a very neat device. When I got word that the TF was coming out I jumped ship and bought a TF. Used it for a week and also liked it for the most part. However I was finding that productivity really lacked on all tablets on screen keyboard. Then I got my hands on a dock and the experience changed. Using the keyboard was infinately more productive and I found that from the day I first docked it I have yet to undock it (around a couple months now).
My problem is I basically just spent a ton of money on a netbook that isnt exactly a speed demon. Web browsing is often slow, updates have caused many issues, etc etc... The device still works but it feels like im playing with a toy instead of actually using the device as a tool. I enjoy Android but think it is very early in the game and it leaves allot to be desired. As I said at first i loved both devices but once the newness wears off you basically have a dumbed down netbook (in my opinion of course).
So now Im thinking about selling the TF as well and picking up one of the new Sandy Bridge Alienware M11x's. To be able to have an i7 processor, damn good video card, and best of all use all my programs in windows sounds like a breath of fresh air at this point.
I know tablets are meant to be stand alone but I never found a use for it for work purposes and the few times I did it was quite the let down. Again, dont read my words wrong. I like the device I just dont think it is good at being anything much more then a toy at this point.
After more thought the only real downside I see in switching is losing the touch screen. It is super nice to be able to just tap where you want to go but often on smaller links it would just pick the wrong one anyways.
So here I sit trying to figure if I should make the switch or not. I know im not comparing apples to apples hardware wise, but I am comparing portable device usefulness. Just curious if anyone has the same feelings or any further input before I make my decision.

Godspeed...
 
Bob Smith42
Old
#2  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 94
Posts: 674
Join Date: Jun 2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by 03stage2 View Post
Odd title eh'?

So here is the boat I am swimming in. I jumped on the Xoom bandwagon when it was released. I immediately was fascinated with the tablet experience and enjoyed it. The Xoom certainly had its issues but was a very neat device. When I got word that the TF was coming out I jumped ship and bought a TF. Used it for a week and also liked it for the most part. However I was finding that productivity really lacked on all tablets on screen keyboard. Then I got my hands on a dock and the experience changed. Using the keyboard was infinately more productive and I found that from the day I first docked it I have yet to undock it (around a couple months now).
My problem is I basically just spent a ton of money on a netbook that isnt exactly a speed demon. Web browsing is often slow, updates have caused many issues, etc etc... The device still works but it feels like im playing with a toy instead of actually using the device as a tool. I enjoy Android but think it is very early in the game and it leaves allot to be desired. As I said at first i loved both devices but once the newness wears off you basically have a dumbed down netbook (in my opinion of course).
So now Im thinking about selling the TF as well and picking up one of the new Sandy Bridge Alienware M11x's. To be able to have an i7 processor, damn good video card, and best of all use all my programs in windows sounds like a breath of fresh air at this point.
I know tablets are meant to be stand alone but I never found a use for it for work purposes and the few times I did it was quite the let down. Again, dont read my words wrong. I like the device I just dont think it is good at being anything much more then a toy at this point.
After more thought the only real downside I see in switching is losing the touch screen. It is super nice to be able to just tap where you want to go but often on smaller links it would just pick the wrong one anyways.
So here I sit trying to figure if I should make the switch or not. I know im not comparing apples to apples hardware wise, but I am comparing portable device usefulness. Just curious if anyone has the same feelings or any further input before I make my decision.

Godspeed...
Yep. I think people will be switching, and you should too.

The dock is addictive for productivity. Unless I tried it I would have not realized how much better is the experience. Yet, when reading a book I prefer only the tablet. This combination is awesome on the Transformer.
 
jonitfcfan
Old
#3  
jonitfcfan's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 34
Posts: 217
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: Find me...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bob Smith42 View Post
Yep. I think people will be switching, and you should too.

The dock is addictive for productivity. Unless I tried it I would have not realized how much better is the experience. Yet, when reading a book I prefer only the tablet. This combination is awesome on the Transformer.
+1, and if anyone is that worried about selecting the wrong link by accident they can always use the mouse pointer via the trackpad. I've had no problem doing it this way and it's a big plus for the TF.
Samsung Galaxy S3 i9300 16GB (main phone)

ROM: AllianceROM ICS Final
Kernel: Siyah v1.5.3lm
Baseband: XXLH1

Samsung Galaxy S i9000 16GB

ROM: AllianceROM JW4 base ROM
Kernel: Semaphore v2.7.4bmfr
Baseband: ZSJV5
Lagfix enabled

Asus Eee Pad Transformer 16GB (with keyboard dock )

ROM: Revolver v4.2.0
Kernel: [default with above]
 
GeLopez
Old
#4  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 18
Posts: 375
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: dallas
Sounds to me like you have no business owning a tablet and windows fits your needs. I'm glad you got that figured out.
Samsung Galaxy 4 T-MOBILE M919
 
xTRICKYxx
Old
#5  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 20
Posts: 228
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Jericho
Quote:
Originally Posted by GeLopez View Post
Sounds to me like you have no business owning a tablet and windows fits your needs. I'm glad you got that figured out.
I think the TF is perfect for his needs. The problem is, that this tablet HAS SO MANY PROBLEMS. This tablet is much slower than any tegra 2 tablet as there is no hardware acceleration! And the fact that there is light bleed, dock issues, battery issues, charging issues, sound issues, etc. Asus really screwed up..
 
Anonnie
Old
#6  
Member
Thanks Meter 1
Posts: 40
Join Date: Dec 2010
Lets put things into perspective here...

The tablet is not a laptop, it can perform many functions of a laptop, but it is truly not one.

It does have a place in the field. I have found that for business, being able to show information instantly to partners without having to 'boot up' or 'plug in' is essential when I want to get a point across.

It is great for email, messaging, movies, light surfing, reading, and even playing some good casual games on.

The dock makes it appear to be more like a laptop, but again.. go back to my 2nd sentence, and do not put it in a category it does not belong in.

If I need to develop, I use my Alienware mx17-r2, if I need to demo products I have my Inspiron. If I need to take notes, read a quick email, show a slide deck / video, or just look something up real quick, I have my TF101.

So this is more about how you set your expectations above what a product is intended to do, and now have buyer's remorse because of it.
 
brandon...
Old
#7  
brandon...'s Avatar
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 3
Posts: 15
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Colorado Springs
Sounds like you put expectations on the device geared towards what it is not. Go get a netbook or start hackin up the ROM and tailor it to your needs.
 
newtybar
Old
#8  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 10
Posts: 232
Join Date: May 2011
Instant On
16 hours of battery life.

Love it.

True though...I barely ever undock it now ahahahah...so we've kind of went full circle...

It's nice to know that I can undock it though.

Even as a netbook it is sleek...IPS screen...touchscreen. The interface is just nice for what it's meant to be...a light portable machine.

I can listen to music/pandora...type up some docs...play some games...browse some web...watch some movies....read some magazines...

Edit: oh yeah...I can mount it in my car and use it as a GPS....use yelp to find nearby food places then map a route to it...(yes this can be done on phone too)...but it's kind of cool.

It's kind of nice.
 
GeLopez
Old
#9  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 18
Posts: 375
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: dallas
Quote:
Originally Posted by xTRICKYxx View Post
I think the TF is perfect for his needs. The problem is, that this tablet HAS SO MANY PROBLEMS. This tablet is much slower than any tegra 2 tablet as there is no hardware acceleration! And the fact that there is light bleed, dock issues, battery issues, charging issues, sound issues, etc. Asus really screwed up..
I dont know of any problems you speak of ,mine is perfect
Samsung Galaxy 4 T-MOBILE M919
 
xTRICKYxx
Old
#10  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 20
Posts: 228
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Jericho
Quote:
Originally Posted by GeLopez View Post
I dont know of any problems you speak of ,mine is perfect
I don't have those problems either, but thousands do.

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes


XDA PORTAL POSTS

Remove Unnecessary WhatsApp Elements with Xposed

In modern life, you can’t underestimate the power ofthe dark sidemessaging … more

MaR-V-iN to Talk Google and Android APIs at XDA:DevCon 2014

Our international xda:devcon 14in Manchester, UK on the weekend of September … more

But First, Let Me Take a #Selfie

“Today while browsing XDA,I’m going tocheck to seeif my favorite ROM has been updated–but … more