Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,780,165 Members 39,196 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

Aftermarket Chargers Causing Damage?

Tip us?
 
mail_e60
Old
#1  
Member - OP
Thanks Meter 2
Posts: 52
Join Date: Nov 2010
Default Aftermarket Chargers Causing Damage?

I am wondering if anyone has heard of aftermarket (non OEM) chargers causing damage to the Galaxy Tab. I bought a cheap car charger from China (via ebay), and it works but the charger heats up A LOT when it is plugged in.

My concern is the charger causing damage. Any thoughts?
 
TheATHEiST
Old
#2  
TheATHEiST's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 890
Posts: 4,079
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Hull
Quote:
Originally Posted by mail_e60 View Post
I am wondering if anyone has heard of aftermarket (non OEM) chargers causing damage to the Galaxy Tab. I bought a cheap car charger from China (via ebay), and it works but the charger heats up A LOT when it is plugged in.

My concern is the charger causing damage. Any thoughts?

Ofcourse it can/will.

Do not buy anything cheap/electrical from ebay that comes from China. Even the SD cards are fake, ie branding aswell as size.
Phone:
Galaxy Note II | CM11 (Unofficial)

Tablet
Nexus 7 | CM 10.2

Smartphone History:
HTC Touch > HTC Universal > HTC Touch HD > HTC HD2 > iPhone 4S > Samsung Galaxy S2 > Samsung Galaxy Note II

Tablet History:
Galaxy Tab 7.0 > iPad3 > Nexus 7

 
pw12f338c
Old
#3  
pw12f338c's Avatar
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 2
Join Date: May 2011
Location: Hong Kong
Quote:
Originally Posted by mail_e60 View Post
I am wondering if anyone has heard of aftermarket (non OEM) chargers causing damage to the Galaxy Tab. I bought a cheap car charger from China (via ebay), and it works but the charger heats up A LOT when it is plugged in.

My concern is the charger causing damage. Any thoughts?
As I know car charger about 12v output, our tab charging with 5v = normal usb can offer.
I think the device being heat up and for a period of time could cause damage, pls justify if I am wrong.

Sent from my GT-P7510 using XDA Premium App
 
Declan79
Old
#4  
Declan79's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 15
Posts: 449
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Padang
yes, some product (aftermarket) had a different power supply rather than oem one, it may potentially supply a different electric input to the device
-U36SD-RX232
-[Was]GT-P1000|CM9.1|4.0.4 --->[Was]GT-P6800|4.2.2|ParanoidAndroid 3.5|--->[Now] Official DXMD3
-[Was]GT-I9100|4.2.2|Revolt JB --->[Was]GT-I9300|4.3| Omega ---> [Now]GT-N7100|4.4.2 (DN3/Ressurection)
-A1429 IOS 7.0.4 JB
Sending from XDA Premium
 
Twister997
Old
#5  
Twister997's Avatar
Member
Thanks Meter 15
Posts: 47
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: New York
You want to make sure that it has the same volt/amp output, but even if it does i'd be wary of it heating up too much
 
noguru
Old
#6  
Member
Thanks Meter 1
Posts: 31
Join Date: Nov 2010
I don't think there's much risk to the Tab. The output of the various USB chargers (car, wall wart, etc.) is regulated at 5V, and they're usually rated at half an amp.

HOWEVER! The Samsung USB charger is rated to deliver 5V at TWO AMPS (mine is). Obviously, the Tab draws more than the half amp of a normal USB circuit. So, if you plug the Tab into a typical USB circuit, which was designed to deliver half an amp, something bad will happen - like an internal meltdown.

An inadequate charger might be damaged by heat due to excess current flow, but not the tablet.

But what do I know...?
 
hypa7ia
Old
#7  
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 2
Join Date: Aug 2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by noguru View Post
HOWEVER! The Samsung USB charger is rated to deliver 5V at TWO AMPS (mine is). Obviously, the Tab draws more than the half amp of a normal USB circuit. So, if you plug the Tab into a typical USB circuit, which was designed to deliver half an amp, something bad will happen - like an internal meltdown.

An inadequate charger might be damaged by heat due to excess current flow, but not the tablet.

But what do I know...?
The Samsung charger seems to refuse to power other devices, which is mildly annoying. There are plenty of USB devices which can handle more than 500mA, Blackberries for example, and generally speaking chargers won't offer more amperage than the device asks for.

And a lower-amp charger won't be damaged, as it simply won't be able to give more than the rated amperage. It'll just charge your Tab much more slowly
 
Declan79
Old
#8  
Declan79's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 15
Posts: 449
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Padang
Perhaps it could be considered


Has a same voltage(it said), using 4pcs AA battery, save us while far away from charging

sent from my 2.3.3|dxkg3 DJGalaxy S2
-U36SD-RX232
-[Was]GT-P1000|CM9.1|4.0.4 --->[Was]GT-P6800|4.2.2|ParanoidAndroid 3.5|--->[Now] Official DXMD3
-[Was]GT-I9100|4.2.2|Revolt JB --->[Was]GT-I9300|4.3| Omega ---> [Now]GT-N7100|4.4.2 (DN3/Ressurection)
-A1429 IOS 7.0.4 JB
Sending from XDA Premium
 
waltibaba
Old
#9  
waltibaba's Avatar
Member
Thanks Meter 2
Posts: 66
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Vienna
Quote:
Originally Posted by noguru View Post
I don't think there's much risk to the Tab. The output of the various USB chargers (car, wall wart, etc.) is regulated at 5V, and they're usually rated at half an amp.

HOWEVER! The Samsung USB charger is rated to deliver 5V at TWO AMPS (mine is). Obviously, the Tab draws more than the half amp of a normal USB circuit. So, if you plug the Tab into a typical USB circuit, which was designed to deliver half an amp, something bad will happen - like an internal meltdown.

An inadequate charger might be damaged by heat due to excess current flow, but not the tablet.

But what do I know...?
A standard PC USB gives 5V at 500mA or 0.5A. Why would a car charger giving the same cause internal meltdown? If you plug the SGT into a PC with the data cable it doesn't suffer internal meltdown either... The SGT definitely has an internal charge controller and overcharge protector so there is really no danger. Unless its a cheap chinese product that either has power surges (unlikely) or incorrect voltage (or extreme current like 5A or so...). To be sure, check the outputs with a multimeter.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Declan79 View Post
Perhaps it could be considered


Has a same voltage(it said), using 4pcs AA battery, save us while far away from charging

sent from my 2.3.3|dxkg3 DJGalaxy S2
That is a TERRIBLE idea! I suggest you stop immediately! If you're unlucky you could really screw up electronic components in your tab. Unless I am missing something like voltage/current regulation in the battery adapter. Is there a pcb in the battery case or is it just wired directly to the usb? And have you ever actually done the math on the voltage? 1.5V x 4 = 6V or with rechargeables, 1.2 x 4 = 4.8V, not 5V!! Although a cell/battery alone usually won't mind that difference, you are sending electricity through complex electronics, not directly charging the battery. The Tab is expecting 5V exactly and stepping up/down the voltage accordingly (to 3.7 or 7.4V for the internal Li battery).

Tl;dr
@ noguru: check your outputs with a multimeter,
@ Declan79: I suggest you stop using that contraption at once! (for your own good)
Galaxy Note II N7100 16GB Titanium Grey
Past primaries: Google Nexus 4 302K, Galaxy Note N7000, Nexus S i9023, Evo 3D, Galaxy Tab P1000, Galaxy S i9000, Acer S200 neoTouch, Omnia i900
Others: HTC HD2, Omnia 2 Pro B7610, Touch Pro 2/Rhodium, TyTn 2/Kaiser, G1/Dream, TyTn/Hermes,
 
Declan79
Old
#10  
Declan79's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 15
Posts: 449
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Padang
Even it only using 4pcs aa battery?

sent from my 2.3.3|dxkg3 DJGalaxy S2
-U36SD-RX232
-[Was]GT-P1000|CM9.1|4.0.4 --->[Was]GT-P6800|4.2.2|ParanoidAndroid 3.5|--->[Now] Official DXMD3
-[Was]GT-I9100|4.2.2|Revolt JB --->[Was]GT-I9300|4.3| Omega ---> [Now]GT-N7100|4.4.2 (DN3/Ressurection)
-A1429 IOS 7.0.4 JB
Sending from XDA Premium

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes