I work as a att customer care rep and used to be a verizon tech support rep. I've felt a lot with asurion and 99% of the time they send out crap refurbs. Scratched, glitchey, ext. I would either search for a screen online and do it my self, find a phone repair center where I live or have htc do it.
Sent from my HTC Sensation 4G using XDA App