I find that the Body Glove is perfect. It adds barely any bulk, it protects the phone (I've dropped it a ton of times and even thrown it with no damage to show for it), and the amount of grip that it gives is perfect. It never slips out of my hand, but yet it comes out of my pocket completely smoothly. Definitely go with that.

Originally Posted by kerick10

Been using the Otterbox Commuter since Nov. 2010. Like the cover for the headphone jack and lower profile face (have the Defender too but blocking the capacitive buttons was a bit annoying). It's survived multiple drops, constant dust from construction sites and my Cappy still looks new. Like that it's easier to access the battery compartment. Recently got re-addicted to flashing roms, but don't want to admit to it.

My defender doesn't block anything. You should have returned that s defective

Sent from my GT-P7510 using Tapatalk 2

Sorry wasn't too clear on the defender. I tend to use it one handed and with the way I type my thumbnail tends to hit the front of the case so it would take a couple tries before the skin of my finger hits the capacitive buttons. Only other reason I currently not using it is the outer shell. Pulling it out of a pocket while sitting down is a bit difficult.

From a Slimmed Captivate

Originally Posted by kerick10

Sorry wasn't too clear on the defender. I tend to use it one handed and with the way I type my thumbnail tends to hit the front of the case so it would take a couple tries before the skin of my finger hits the capacitive buttons. Only other reason I currently not using it is the outer shell. Pulling it out of a pocket while sitting down is a bit difficult.

From a Slimmed Captivate

I gotcha now. And concur with pocket removal. Luckily I've mastered exactly where to hit it on the capacative buttons

Sent from my SGH-I897 using Tapatalk 2

I am using case from Body Glove.

Currently using a Capdase Soft Jacket 2 Xpose. It's slim and fits well, and is not really in the way of the screen. Adds a little bit the thickness to the phone which I actually prefer.