You're right, I did get the wrong version. They acknowledged this and that the case was faulty based on the photo I sent them of the damage. They sent me a replacement immediately. Too bad the replacement they sent sent me is for a Galaxy Note. Why is it so hard to get the right case from these guys?
I don't recommend this case or the silicone Ringke, that one lasted 2 months before the surface started to wear off and the sides loosened up significantly.