Turns out for me, the problem was with the Skinomi screen protector. I noticed there were marks on the screen protector where it looked like it was catching. I pulled off the screen protector and it seems to fit better now. Sorry, I already yanked it off so I don't have pictures.
Equal Opportunity Hater
HTC Droid Incredible - Rooted - Running In-Sensitive Minimalist
ASUS Transformer Infinity TF700 - Rooted, Unlocked, Running CleanROM 2.0
Samsung Galaxy Nexus - Rooted - Running AOKP JB