New: XDA launches forum for app developers. Discuss coding, tools, marketing, and more.
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum
Forgot your password?
 
Post Reply+
Tip us?
 
scott0
Old
#1  
scott0's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 88
Posts: 746
Join Date: Dec 2011
Default battery drain: wi-fi v. LTE hmmmmmmmm

when I am here at work, I usually tap the wi-fi for streaming my music, consequently, wi-fi has always been at the top for battery use



I noticed on this graph that the LTE radio never shows up on it though.

Today, I turned off the wi-fi and using only LTE for the last 3+ hours streaming tunes



WTF!!1one
 
repherb
Old
#2  
repherb's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 43
Posts: 169
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Milky Way
i can assure everyone there is no debate.

If you run (from a root prompt):
# adb logcat
then look carefully, you will see that even with Wifi active, the phone is accessing the LTE network for updates and transmitting data to the network, therefore using 2x the battery usage. the best way to use only Wifi is to use Airplane mode then turn on your Wifi ONLY. this assures you of a near 100% Wifi only usage.

Only then can you produce accurate results for battery usage regarding LTE vs Wifi
__________________
Current Device: SGN2 i317M - Stock & Rooted
Past device(s):
SGSIII -SIM Unlocked/Stock ICS
SGS i9000 - CWM, XBeaned to HELL!!
Samsung Galaxy Nexus JRO03C:I9250XXLF1 - (blew it up)
SG Note i717m (sold it)
LG P930(killed it)

Please remember to click on THANKS! if my post here helped you in any way!!
Need a quick and free backup server? Try HERE!!
 
scott0
Old
#3  
scott0's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 88
Posts: 746
Join Date: Dec 2011
there must be some confusion, allow me to restate my original post.

I am curious why the LTE radio's battery usage does not show up on the graphs I posted while the wi-fi does.
 
scott0
Old
#4  
scott0's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 88
Posts: 746
Join Date: Dec 2011
7.5 hours on battery, 6 of those hours streaming music via LTE, + a bit of browserin- battery @ 38%
 
V@no
Old
#5  
V@no's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 115
Posts: 1,130
Join Date: Sep 2007
Probably because it would be so huge, all others graphs would be a pixel wide....
 
repherb
Old
#6  
repherb's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 43
Posts: 169
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Milky Way
because the 4G LTE radio usage is not tracked by an app, it is a system service. wifi is tracked because it has a separate app that controls the Wifi radio. the only way to shut off the cellular modem is by using airplane mode. make sense??

---------- Post added at 06:16 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:16 PM ----------

@V@no: ROTFLMAO!!!
__________________
Current Device: SGN2 i317M - Stock & Rooted
Past device(s):
SGSIII -SIM Unlocked/Stock ICS
SGS i9000 - CWM, XBeaned to HELL!!
Samsung Galaxy Nexus JRO03C:I9250XXLF1 - (blew it up)
SG Note i717m (sold it)
LG P930(killed it)

Please remember to click on THANKS! if my post here helped you in any way!!
Need a quick and free backup server? Try HERE!!
 
V@no
Old
#7  
V@no's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 115
Posts: 1,130
Join Date: Sep 2007
Quote:
Originally Posted by repherb View Post
the best way to use only Wifi is to use Airplane mode then turn on your Wifi ONLY. this assures you of a near 100% Wifi only usage.
And converts Nitro into overpriced iPod...
 
scott0
Old
#8  
scott0's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 88
Posts: 746
Join Date: Dec 2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by V@no View Post
Probably because it would be so huge, all others graphs would be a pixel wide....
lolz. it doesn't seem to be as bad as it's made out to be by reviews.
Quote:
Originally Posted by repherb View Post
because the 4G LTE radio usage is not tracked by an app, it is a system service. wifi is tracked because it has a separate app that controls the Wifi radio. the only way to shut off the cellular modem is by using airplane mode. make sense??

---------- Post added at 06:16 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:16 PM ----------

@V@no: ROTFLMAO!!!
yes, I am familiar with airplane mode, thank you, it does make sense.

Interesting that LTE is not considered a system service/left out while such things as android OS, cell standby and phone idle are displayed in the graph.
 
repherb
Old
#9  
repherb's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 43
Posts: 169
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Milky Way
@V@no: dude, you have a clarity of thought none of us have.
__________________
Current Device: SGN2 i317M - Stock & Rooted
Past device(s):
SGSIII -SIM Unlocked/Stock ICS
SGS i9000 - CWM, XBeaned to HELL!!
Samsung Galaxy Nexus JRO03C:I9250XXLF1 - (blew it up)
SG Note i717m (sold it)
LG P930(killed it)

Please remember to click on THANKS! if my post here helped you in any way!!
Need a quick and free backup server? Try HERE!!
 
aquariuz23
Old
#10  
aquariuz23's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 79
Posts: 829
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Clifton, NJ
I swear, we really need to somehow disable LTE on this phone and just run on either HSPA+ or 3G when we don't need LTE. I've always know that while it's not being used, it's still searching and updating constantly, and actually using up much more battery in the process.


Motorola Atrix 4G > Unlocked BL!! > GingerBlur 2.3.4 > Navalynt's Mod (v1.4) > Tenfar's CWM Recovery Mod > CM7

LG NITRO HD P930 >> Root via SuperOneClick v2.3.2 >> Bytecode64's CWM v.5.** >> KernelPan!c's v0.3