Originally Posted by Claudio67

Stock rooted, deodexed and zipaligned with dsixda kitchen. Downgrading now to froyo anyway this is my last LG product.

Correct me if I'm wrong but a stock that is "rooted, deodexed and zipaligned" is not exactly a "stock" anymore, is it?

This is my last LG product too but since I'm stuck with it at the moment, I'm trying to do the best out of it.

So far, many people have reported no ghost calls with the real stock V21E and only four reported ghost calls. All those four reports were claiming that "V21E has ghost calls" but after we've asked:

-the first has flashed only the 21E besaband, not the complete rom.
-the second has flashed a custom rom/kernel above the 21E.
-the third has reported a worse battery life than Froyo.
-the fourth has deodexed and zipaligned the stock rom.

So actually, none of the above had the stock rom, with the exception of the third report where clearly something went wrong because none of GB roms has worse battery than Froyo.

I'm sorry if I'm a little agitated but we're all in the same boat here. And reports that claim that "the V21E stock has ghost calls" while clearly they are not referring to the stock but a modified rom/kernel, are not really helpful.

Originally Posted by botson71

Correct me if I'm wrong but a stock that is "rooted, deodexed and zipaligned" is not exactly a "stock" anymore, is it?

This is my last LG product too but since I'm stuck with it at the moment, I'm trying to do the best out of it.

So far, many people have reported no ghost calls with the real stock V21E and only four reported ghost calls. All those four reports were claiming that "V21E has ghost calls" but after we've asked:

-the first has flashed only the 21E besaband, not the complete rom.
-the second has flashed a custom rom/kernel above the 21E.
-the third has reported a worse battery life than Froyo.
-the fourth has deodexed and zipaligned the stock rom.

So actually, none of the above had the stock rom, with the exception of the third report where clearly something went wrong because none of GB roms has worse battery than Froyo.

I'm sorry if I'm a little agitated but we're all in the same boat here. And reports that claim that "the V21E stock has ghost calls" while clearly they are not referring to the stock but a modified rom/kernel, are not really helpful.

Well mate if you want to consider "deodex and zipalign" as the reason of ghost calls no problem for me.

Originally Posted by botson71

Correct me if I'm wrong but a stock that is "rooted, deodexed and zipaligned" is not exactly a "stock" anymore, is it?

This is my last LG product too but since I'm stuck with it at the moment, I'm trying to do the best out of it.

So far, many people have reported no ghost calls with the real stock V21E and only four reported ghost calls. All those four reports were claiming that "V21E has ghost calls" but after we've asked:

-the first has flashed only the 21E besaband, not the complete rom.
-the second has flashed a custom rom/kernel above the 21E.
-the third has reported a worse battery life than Froyo.
-the fourth has deodexed and zipaligned the stock rom.

So actually, none of the above had the stock rom, with the exception of the third report where clearly something went wrong because none of GB roms has worse battery than Froyo.

I'm sorry if I'm a little agitated but we're all in the same boat here. And reports that claim that "the V21E stock has ghost calls" while clearly they are not referring to the stock but a modified rom/kernel, are not really helpful.

I am the thitd one. But my rom is realy stock. Not deodexed,zipalinged,nor custom rom,or kernel or anything. I just didn't wipe my froyo with cwm before installing v21e. After i installed v21e,i did a simple factory reset. A day after,had a gc. When i noticed that,i wiped everithing through cwm(except battery stats) and my phone seems to work now fine. If a get another gc,i'll let you know. Battery is great so far. 48% after almost 15 hours. And the rom seems faster now than after installing it.

Sent from my LG-P920 using XDA Premium App

Originally Posted by botson71

Correct me if I'm wrong but a stock that is "rooted, deodexed and zipaligned" is not exactly a "stock" anymore, is it?

This is my last LG product too but since I'm stuck with it at the moment, I'm trying to do the best out of it.

So far, many people have reported no ghost calls with the real stock V21E and only four reported ghost calls. All those four reports were claiming that "V21E has ghost calls" but after we've asked:

-the first has flashed only the 21E besaband, not the complete rom.
-the second has flashed a custom rom/kernel above the 21E.
-the third has reported a worse battery life than Froyo.
-the fourth has deodexed and zipaligned the stock rom.

So actually, none of the above had the stock rom, with the exception of the third report where clearly something went wrong because none of GB roms has worse battery than Froyo.

I'm sorry if I'm a little agitated but we're all in the same boat here. And reports that claim that "the V21E stock has ghost calls" while clearly they are not referring to the stock but a modified rom/kernel, are not really helpful.

Take it easy man. We are all frustrated about this GC issue but I think there is only so much that one can do to sort out the misleading information. Appreciate your efforts but there is just too many things can go wrong here with so many ROMs and kernels available. On top of that, everyone here has different technical skill levels.

Maybe it will be easier if you start another thread similar to
http://forum.xda-developers.com/show...1655327&page=1
And state your requirements there (post only if fully stock condition)

Besides, we've been living with this GC issue for many months now. I don't see it can get any worse than this. And I believe that you have a feeling the v21e is definitely the best solution at this moment.

appearently I had GC too

v21e,
custom rom, based on v21e, but no custom kernel (promethius)

on it for 3 days,
had at least one GC today

Originally Posted by Claudio67

Well mate if you want to consider "deodex and zipalign" as the reason of ghost calls no problem for me.

I don't want to consider anything. I just asked you if a stock rom which has been rooted, deodexed and zipaligned could be considered as a clean rom or a modified one.

Perhaps the deodexing and zipaligning is not the reason of the ghost calls but can we be 100% sure that it's not?

Originally Posted by douglam

Take it easy man. We are all frustrated about this GC issue but I think there is only so much that one can do to sort out the misleading information. Appreciate your efforts but there is just too many things can go wrong here with so many ROMs and kernels available.

Maybe it will be easier if you start another thread similar to
http://forum.xda-developers.com/show...1655327&page=1

And state your requirements there.

No problem but perhaps you didn't fully understand my previous message. I was not talking about the "many ROMs and kernels available", but just the one and latest V21E rom which apparently (according to numerous reports here) fixes the ghost calls.

There isn't any need to start another thread because I don't want to weaken this one here. And I don't have any requirements, apart from the obvious: when someone states that the new "V21E has ghost calls" it would be very helpful for the rest of us if he also states if he's referring to a clean V21E firmware, or a modified V21E.

So far, from the four people that have only said "V21E has ghost calls", after the rest of us have asked for a clarification, it was revealed that only one (@kekio84) has a clean V21E. The other three have either installed only the 21E baseband or modified the 21E with custom kernels/roms or by deodexing and zipaligning.

Also, please don't get me wrong. I'm the last person who will say that 21E is 100% ghost-call free. When the 21E was released, a few days later many people have started reporting that it is "100% ghost-call free". I was one of the very few who said that we can't be certain before some weeks pass w/o ghost calls. And still I'm not 100% sure that the V21E solves the issue. I'll have to wait a couple more weeks to say that.

Originally Posted by douglam

And I believe that you have a feeling the v21e is definitely the best solution at this moment.

You've added this after I posted my message. Actually the only feeling I have about the V21E is that the battery life has been improved and the battery stats are fixed. I'm not sure at all if the ghost-calls are fixed as many others claim. I'll have to wait at least a couple more weeks to be certain about that.

Well,as i said before and in the other thread,i wiped everything through cwm yesterday(except battery stats) and everything works fine. And the battery is great so far and no signs of gc so far either....

Sent from my LG-P920 using XDA Premium App

Originally Posted by deleeros

I think that LG is using us as beta testers for her new firmware update... That's great...

Yeah cause they know half of us already voided our warranty

sent from my acidhazard thrill

Originally Posted by wayno140

Yeah cause they know half of us already voided our warranty

sent from my acidhazard thrill

:)))))

Sent from my LG-P920 using XDA

Originally Posted by wayno140

Yeah cause they know half of us already voided our warranty

sent from my acidhazard thrill

Your warranty isn't voided if you root or flash custom roms... You can always revert it to stock and they would be none the wiser.

Sent from my LG-P920 using Tapatalk 2