Did both files on a normal device. Never saw this bevore. And I have tested both files on 2 Devices.
What Image you have installed bevore? It seems the comlete Image is somehow broken.
Uhhh... Anyone else with this problem??
I know this problem from my HD2 device. If you have to often flashed the device your Memory becomes corrupt.
Solution was to flash an official and untouched RUU to it which fix the partition layout.
My recomendation would be to flash ANY RUU to the device. Let it boot, do some settings & reboot.
When it's back, power off and flash my file again. Don't care about S-OFF because you will keep this even with RUU flashing.
If you can do it - would be great. Let me know what will happens.
Sent from my HTC Desire HD A9191 using XDA