Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,742,816 Members 38,911 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

Camera comparison: One X vs Galaxy S II vs Nexus vs N8 vs iPhone 4S

Tip us?
 
android_master
Old
(Last edited by android_master; 11th April 2012 at 07:02 AM.)
#1  
android_master's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 251
Posts: 1,070
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Mumbai Indians

 
DONATE TO ME
Thumbs up Camera comparison: One X vs Galaxy S II vs Nexus vs N8 vs iPhone 4S

When HTC was announcing the One X, it made it sound as if the new ImageSense camera is the best camera on a phone you may get. Well, since we now have the One X in our hands and have been using it for a while, we decided to put his new camera to the test. Winning this comparison, though, won't be easy, as we've chosen some of the best camera phones out there to be its competition: the Samsung Galaxy S II, Galaxy Nexus, Nokia N8 and Apple iPhone 4S. Let the games begin!





Details:

The devil is in the details, and when it comes to taking photos, having great level of details is indeed one of the most important elements. Interestingly, the new ImageSense camera of the One X performed terribly in this area, presenting us to muddier-looking images compared to all of the other contestants here. Here's how all five handsets rank in this category:

1. Apple iPhone 4S
2. Nokia N8
3. Samsung Galaxy S II
4. Samsung Galaxy Nexus
5. HTC One X

Color reproduction:

This was a very close one, at least for the first 3 positions. The N8, Galaxy S II and Nexus manages to produce very natural colors, with the N8 excelling slightly overall. The iPhone 4S snatched the 4th position here since it's images are quite warm, but still closer to reality (and more appealing) compared to the pics from the One X, which were too cold.

1. Nokia N8
2. Samsung Galaxy S II
3. Samsung Galaxy Nexus
4. Apple iPhone 4S
5. HTC One X

Exposure:


We're once again seeing some pretty equal performance here, although there are still some anomalies observed. While most of the smartphones tend to deviate from the natural exposure by overexposing the image at times, the One X is the only one that underexposes it, and thus comes up with an overall dark photo. Interestingly, this also happens with normal daylight shots, which aren't taken in some more specific lighting situations that would make it difficult for the phone's camera to do its thing properly. Nope, the One X's camera simply underexposes the pictures, making them somewhat less pleasant to look at, compared to what we get from the other contenders here.

1. Nokia N8
2. Samsung Galaxy Nexus
3. Apple iPhone 4S
4. Samsung Galaxy S II
5. HTC One X

Indoor shots:

Ranking our five handsets in the Indoor shots category wasn't very easy, because they achieved different results when shooting in different light conditions. The ranking you see below represents their overall score. The Nokia N8 is our favorite here, since it manages to retain a pretty good detail and overall quality level throughout all lighting variations, whereas the shots from all the other handsets become much worse when the lights get weaker. We think the One X performs equally to the iPhone 4S and Galaxy Nexus in this respect, since all three are good in a different respect – the Nexus has the most natural colors, the iPhone 4S capture more detail than the Nexus, but its exposure is a bit off, while the One X has an OK exposure, good details and colors that are a bit off. The Galaxy S II is last here because its colors were too yellowish, save for those pics taken in very dark conditions.

1.Nokia N8
2.Apple iPhone 4S, HTC One X, Samsung Galaxy Nexus
3.Samsung Galaxy S II

Night shots:

Choosing the best handsets for taking night photos wasn't that hard. It's clear that the One X is a top performer in this category, along with the iPhone 4S, which produces similar results. They excelled in color reproduction and details, plus both of them offer easy exposure setting when doing touch-to-focus, which helps them in various situations. In the samples below, we've used touch-to-focus on the cathedral, which made the handsets set the exposure in such a way that would have the cathedral properly exposed. Both phones may produce varying results when using this function, so it's best to experiment in order to get to know your handset's behavior. The Nokia N8 couldn't top this category, since its photos are somewhat greenish and not as sharp.

1.HTC One X, Apple iPhone 4S
2.Samsung Galaxy S II, Nokia N8
3.Samsung Galaxy Nexus


Macro:

When it comes to macro, we managed to achieve best results with the N8 and Galaxy S II, where both devices captured some wonderfully-details shots, but the N8 had the upper hand thanks to its higher resolution. The One X wasn't too far behind, although its somewhat smoother images couldn't compete with the first two.

1.Nokia N8
2.Samsung Galaxy S II
3.HTC One X
4.Samsung Galaxy Nexus
5.Apple iPhone 4S

Video:

Of all five smartphones, the iPhone 4S has the best video-recording capabilities. Its 1080p video simply looks great and is very smooth. The second place is shared by the Galaxy S II and N8. Although the N8 is limited to producing 720p video, its clips are incredibly smooth, and of very high quality overall, whereas the Galaxy S II is competitive, but a bit choppier and inconsistent. The third place is shared by the One X and Galaxy Nexus, which produce pretty much the same results – mediocre.

1.Apple iPhone 4S
2.Samsung Galaxy S II, Nokia N8
3.HTC One X, Samsung Galaxy Nexus

Ease of use and speed:

In terms of ease of use, speed, and overall greatness of the camera UIs, our favorite one is the HTC One X, as it is very comfortable and features some cool additional stuff like filters and various settings. Then comes the iPhone 4S with its ultra-fast and ultra-simple design. We'd place the Nokia N8 third here, because of its dedicated camera shutter, which makes the process of taking photos feel a bit more natural and straightforward.

1.HTC One X
2.Apple iPhone 4S
3.Nokia N8
4.Samsung Galaxy S II
5.Samsung Galaxy Nexus

Conclusion:

This was it, shutterbugs. Apparently we don't have an ultimate camera phone here, but even if we had one, it wouldn't have been the new HTC One X. The handset did arrive with a very fast ImageSense camera, which made photo-taking very intuitive and fast, but it's not up to snuff when it comes to the quality of the actual photos and video. You'll be able to achieve much better results with the iPhone 4S and even with the oldie-but-goodie Galaxy S II. The real shock actually came when we saw the Galaxy Nexus beat the One X in many of the categories, which wasn't really expected. If you are taking a lot of photos and video with your cell phone and hoped that the One X's ImageSense camera will raise the bar in this respect, better look elsewhere.

Phonearena
 
android_master
Old
#2  
android_master's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 251
Posts: 1,070
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Mumbai Indians

 
DONATE TO ME
Quality of Nokia N8 images still can't be beaten by the others in this test.

But i am really surprised by these results,what the hell is wrong,is the camera that bad on htc one x or phonearena is doing bull****
 
Vcolassi
Old
#3  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 31
Posts: 426
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Whitehall
Wow interesting. I was looking to perhaps sell my Galaxy Nexus for a One X. I was hoping for a better camera and originally thought the one X was superior in that section. This was my excuse and buttering up to the GF letting me lay down the extra cash lol. As she's uses my camera phone a lot when we are out and about and snap pictures of the dog. Damn

I know our cell phones aren't appose to replace point and shoots but they say the best camera is the one that always with you. And most of the photos I take are spur of the moment when I'm out and about.
 
gordongartrell
Old
#4  
gordongartrell's Avatar
Member
Thanks Meter 7
Posts: 81
Join Date: Sep 2010
The pictures that I saw in the "Post your best picture" thread were very good imo. I wonder if the reviewer knew what he was doing.

Sent from my HTC Desire using Tapatalk 2
The Following User Says Thank You to gordongartrell For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
android_master
Old
#5  
android_master's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 251
Posts: 1,070
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Mumbai Indians

 
DONATE TO ME
Quote:
Originally Posted by Vcolassi View Post
Wow interesting. I was looking to perhaps sell my Galaxy Nexus for a One X. I was hoping for a better camera and originally thought the one X was superior in that section. This was my excuse and buttering up to the GF letting me lay down the extra cash lol. As she's uses my camera phone a lot when we are out and about and snap pictures of the dog. Damn

I know our cell phones aren't appose to replace point and shoots but they say the best camera is the one that always with you. And most of the photos I take are spur of the moment when I'm out and about.

really its a pain to see it performing like this
 
WhiteHartMart
Old
#6  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 73
Posts: 575
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Cornwall, UK
Phonearena have had a massive negative attitude about this phone from day one - wouldn't trust a word they say.

The camera in my experience is fantastic and considerably better than the Galaxy Nexus that I had!

Sent from my HTC One X using xda premium
Nexus 5 Black
The Following User Says Thank You to WhiteHartMart For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
Vcolassi
Old
#7  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 31
Posts: 426
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Whitehall
Quote:
Originally Posted by WhiteHartMart View Post
Phonearena have had a massive negative attitude about this phone from day one - wouldn't trust a word they say.

The camera in my experience is fantastic and considerably better than the Galaxy Nexus that I had!

Sent from my HTC One X using xda premium

Guess its based on user opinion. You said you had a Nexus and the One X performs better. As long as it looks good and the colors are good works for me. In reality I'm not going to be zooming in and having 4 phones next to me to compare lol.
 
finduz
Old
#8  
finduz's Avatar
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 29
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Norway
Damn, and I sold my N8 for this. Haven't had time to test the camera so much, but it's sad that a phone 1.5 years old still isn't beaten.
Wanted all the popular apps which Android offers and a decent camera, but I'm already bored of the apps. Guess I'll go for the next Nokia with Windows and a good camera.
 
Vcolassi
Old
(Last edited by Vcolassi; 11th April 2012 at 08:08 AM.)
#9  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 31
Posts: 426
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Whitehall
Quote:
Originally Posted by finduz View Post
Damn, and I sold my N8 for this. Haven't had time to test the camera so much, but it's sad that a phone 1.5 years old still isn't beaten.
Wanted all the popular apps which Android offers and a decent camera, but I'm already bored of the apps. Guess I'll go for the next Nokia with Windows and a good camera.
If you want the best apps/ camera combo the iPhone is gonna be the way to go, even though I hate to say it. I use a Android phone daily but have a 4s laying around. And as far as games and app support it's clearly dominant.

Not saying the Play store doesn't have a lot of Apps. But you can literally sit around for days and download different iOS apps that the Play store does not have and there good ones too. The play store has the apps for my needs though.

I'd trade ya a new Samsung Galaxy Nexus for you One X hahaha.
 
hungcolin
Old
#10  
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 1
Posts: 25
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: Ho chi minh
Pls read this thread in this forum to see how amazing One X camera.

http://forum.xda-developers.com/show....php?t=1585398

Tags
android, apple, htc, nokia, samsung
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes