New: XDA launches forum for app developers. Discuss coding, tools, marketing, and more.
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum
Forgot your password?
View Poll Results: WP replacement options, what do you think? See the post below for breakdown...
Cheap HD2 - future for a better deal? 5 29.41%
Spanky New HD2 because... well its an HD2! 1 5.88%
Nokia 800 0 0%
Nokia 900 8 47.06%
Titan 0 0%
Titan II 2 11.76%
Other - similar to an HD2 options 1 5.88%
Voters: 17. You may not vote on this poll

 
Post Reply+
Tip us?
 
dazza9075
Old
(Last edited by dazza9075; 30th May 2012 at 08:16 AM.)
#1  
Recognized Contributor - OP
Thanks Meter 385
Posts: 2,594
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Glasgow

 
DONATE TO ME
Default What to do guys...

Righty, my HD2 is about to go to where all good phones go when they meet their maker, the African sub-continent

Yup its time has come, the USB socket seems to no longer except data connections, (probably broken PCB/tracks) and the digitiser has started to act erratically

as much as id like to get out the soldering Iron and replace the digitiser it doesn't cost that much more to get a new one.

So I guess im coming here to pick your brains and gather up what the community feels is the best options

So the choices above are
  • get a cheaper HD2 and wait out for the WP8 device launch when I could then choose to get a cheaper WP7 device or get a WP8 one
  • Keep the king of all phones the HD2 and shell out on brand spanky new one
  • Nokia 800(cheaper)
  • Nokia 900(would rather)
  • Titan (cheaper)
  • Titan II (Would rather)
  • Something else, perhaps a Smaller HD2 comparable gem
Ive put those 4 on because im interested in what the general feeling of the community is on them, obviously the 900 and the Titan II are better but I suppose the question is, for those that know is it worth the extra money?

In terms of spec I don't care, they are all good, but if your suggesting another one then 3.7in is the absolute minimum screen size and CPU spec around that of the 3 year old HD2 is acceptable, I don't play games so a 1GHz snapdragon is ok and around 512MB of RAM is fine too, the HD2 has a bit less which is fine. screen size is what's important

Im aware those newer ones are not as mod able as the HD2, but apart from web based XAP installing I don't do that much on it that needs the Full unlock so would I miss it...I dunno, side loading some of my custom XAPs would be handy I guess....

One last thing, yes I can and have researched them, but im open to suggestions and im more interested in what you guys have experienced with them, good or bad. We XDAers tend to know out stuff a lot more than the average review site!

sooo..... over to you great chaps and lasses, what do you think?
 
AndyFZ1S
Old
#2  
AndyFZ1S's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 44
Posts: 334
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: London
I loved my HD2 and would still be using it if it wasn't for the social integration that wp7 holds, No going back now, But if you can pick up a cheap HD2 for now then surely its the better option being what ur familiar with and knowing wp8 hopefully has some nice surprises to look forward to later in the year.
The Following User Says Thank You to AndyFZ1S For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
OtoTheBear
Old
(Last edited by OtoTheBear; 30th May 2012 at 01:27 PM.)
#3  
OtoTheBear's Avatar
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 1
Posts: 17
Join Date: Dec 2010
I've got an LG E900. It works smooth, but has so many little flaws, that I would go for a cheap HD2. I don't know about the Titans. But after using WP7.5 I wouldn't consider to buy a new WP device which isn't capable of WP8.
Maybe you get an used WP7.5 device cheaper than an HD2 and consider this as an opportunity to test WP. Because I guess Android isn't perfect either, but you know of its flaws and there aren't any surprises. Like when I've got my first call. WP vibrates, then rings, then vibrates. When I wanted to change this behaviour I considered myself lucky of being able to at least choose a different ringtone.
The Following User Says Thank You to OtoTheBear For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
chabun
Old
#4  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 22
Posts: 185
Join Date: May 2010
Quote:
Originally Posted by OtoTheBear View Post
But after using WP7.5 I wouldn't consider to buy a new WP device which isn't capable of WP8.
That story is not over yet Microsoft just kept quit and that's it...

Anyway, I'd buy another HD2. It's already quite cheap and still the best. And when WP8 hits the stores, I'd buy a shiny new phone with new specs (second gen devices have not made a big jump but WP8 is hopefully going to catch up with android handsets).

The HD2 will always be nice (even when you got a new phone) as you can really, really play with it.
The Following User Says Thank You to chabun For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
dazza9075
Old
#5  
Recognized Contributor - OP
Thanks Meter 385
Posts: 2,594
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Glasgow

 
DONATE TO ME
thanks guys, Its looking like a return to the king moment with half the vote suggesting getting a cheap HD2 and waiting for 1st gen WP8 devices to see what happens.....
 
dazza9075
Old
#6  
Recognized Contributor - OP
Thanks Meter 385
Posts: 2,594
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Glasgow

 
DONATE TO ME
Ok, ive had another thought, now there doesn't appear to be any development on this one but its unlockable to deploy xaps, I don't think its full unlock but as I said im not too bothered.

So, the phone im talking about, is the Samsung Focus s

From all information that I can gather its pretty good, all beit has a plastic feel about it, anyone have any additional thoughts on the matter?

ive got a day to decide before my phone will probably pack in, USB socket just fell off the PCB all together such an undignified end to the HD2 3 year reign
 
chabun
Old
#7  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 22
Posts: 185
Join Date: May 2010
Well that's sad - but even the hd2 is not invincible

I think Samsung makes pretty decent phones (I played around with an omnia 7 and galaxy s2). The only downside is that they feel really cheap and shaby as you said.

Don't know what you're paying for it, but if it's really cheap, I'd buy it. Otherwise I'd stick with an HD2 and wait for the WP8 release.
 
dazza9075
Old
#8  
Recognized Contributor - OP
Thanks Meter 385
Posts: 2,594
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Glasgow

 
DONATE TO ME
Quote:
Originally Posted by chabun View Post
Well that's sad - but even the hd2 is not invincible

I think Samsung makes pretty decent phones (I played around with an omnia 7 and galaxy s2). The only downside is that they feel really cheap and shaby as you said.

Don't know what you're paying for it, but if it's really cheap, I'd buy it. Otherwise I'd stick with an HD2 and wait for the WP8 release.
well ive gone with the Samsung Focus S imported from the states, the screen size was the deciding factor, combined with the fact that dev unlock is fairly straight forward and interop isn't much harder. Titan was just too big, and the 800 was too small and inconsistent with what I was expecting, the 900 would have been great if I could have got one cheep, the Focus S ticked all the boxes bar the slightly plastic feel to them

theres sweet bugger all going on in development so perhaps ill try give something back to the community and learn a bit from the Gods on here

The HD2 is still holding in there, if I squash the whole lower portion of the phone very hard and remove the battery to charge it, it still kinda works, it just doesn't want to die