Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,730,051 Members 53,522 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum
View Poll Results: How do you deal with DTS Audio?
Re-encode to smaller phone-friendly format 25 14.53%
Old version of player that still has DTS support 65 37.79%
I don't watch mkv video on my phone 18 10.47%
Other 64 37.21%
Voters: 172. You may not vote on this poll

DTS Audio for android == LAWSUIT

Tip us?
 
zmore
Old
(Last edited by zmore; 14th August 2012 at 06:33 AM.) Reason: yay/nah dts list; DicePlayer NOT abandoned
#1  
zmore's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 877
Posts: 1,572
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: NYC
Default DTS Audio for android == LAWSUIT

DTS audio *used* to work outofthebox in both DicePlayer (my old favorite), and in MX Player (my new fav), but both of them REMOVED the dts codec a few months ago apparently because of the threat of lawsuits from using unlicensed code.
(UPDATE: DicePlayer dev juami posted below that they were refused even the option to buy a license for DTS, because they prefer to deal with the big industry players instead; also, DicePlayer can still play dts IF you install an external codec plug-in)

Just curious what most people are doing out there in order to play their mkv videos with the very common DTS audio track (vs the less common AAC/MP3/etc audio tracks). Re-encoding phone-friendly versions with HandBrake; using an old app with DTS support; using a PAID app that paid the licensing fee (can't find one), or, something else...

EDIT: I'm going to keep a list here of players that are known to support DTS or not:

DTS IS SUPPORTED OTTB (for now):
VLC Beta - (h/w 1080p decode works! - BEST option, but, the app must be sideloaded, since it shows as incompatible with the US S3 in the Play store. See Time_Zone's post below for the attached VLC apk. Thanks!)
BS Player - (s/w ONLY (eats battery): h/w mode always falls back to s/w mode, but dts is ok. 720p s/w == ok; 1080p s/w == CPU can't keep up; too choppy)
Rock Player - (s/w ONLY (eats battery): no DTS when in h/w video playback mode, and s/w playback is blocky crap. Also, the app fails to playback a video when sent a video intent to play from another app)

DTS NOT SUPPORTED:
Video Player default - (Touchwiz, AOSP (CM10, AOKP, ...))
MX Player - (updated versions removed codec; google for old apk version)
Dice Player - (updated versions removed codec; google for old apk version (2.0.6), or try searching XDA for external plug-in support instead.)
Mobo Player
Primary Phone: Note3 (SM-N900T); ROM: CyanogenMod 11 (KitKat 4.4.*); kernel: Stock @ 2.3GHz; misc: Incipio DualPro; 64GB class10 microSDXC
Primary Tablet: Nexus 7 (2012); ROM: CM11
Working museum piece: SGS1 Captivate (SGH-i897); ROM: CM11; kernel: Stock @ 1.0GHz
(Other devices: Nexus 10 (stock); Retired devices: SGS3 (SGH-i747), Kindle Fire (otter), OG Galaxy Tab 7, ...)
 
The Following 8 Users Say Thank You to zmore For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
Time_Zone
Old
#2  
Time_Zone's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 67
Posts: 381
Join Date: Apr 2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by zmore View Post
DTS audio *used* to work in both DicePlayer (my old favorite; discontinued), and in MX Player (my new fav), but both of them REMOVED the dts codec a few months ago because of the threat of lawsuits.

Just curious what most people are doing out there in order to play their mkv videos with the very common DTS audio track (vs the less common AAC/MP3/etc audio tracks). Re-encoding phone-friendly versions with HandBrake; using an old app with DTS support; using a PAID app that paid the licensing fee (can't find one), or, something else...
VLC BETA... you have to search for it. It does work.
Samsung Galaxy S III AT&T
I747UCDLK3 (rooted)




(Waiting on a fully stable CM10 or a SLIM port, with working Bluetooth)
 
zmore
Old
(Last edited by zmore; 13th August 2012 at 06:25 PM.)
#3  
zmore's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 877
Posts: 1,572
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: NYC
Quote:
Originally Posted by Time_Zone View Post
VLC BETA... you have to search for it. It does work.
Awesome. I'll give it try, even through from what I've read the beta is still very buggy & laggy.

Wonder how long they'll "get away with it" before removing DTS support too.

EDIT: VLC beta is currently incompatible with the US SGS3
Primary Phone: Note3 (SM-N900T); ROM: CyanogenMod 11 (KitKat 4.4.*); kernel: Stock @ 2.3GHz; misc: Incipio DualPro; 64GB class10 microSDXC
Primary Tablet: Nexus 7 (2012); ROM: CM11
Working museum piece: SGS1 Captivate (SGH-i897); ROM: CM11; kernel: Stock @ 1.0GHz
(Other devices: Nexus 10 (stock); Retired devices: SGS3 (SGH-i747), Kindle Fire (otter), OG Galaxy Tab 7, ...)
 
 
zmore
Old
#4  
zmore's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 877
Posts: 1,572
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: NYC
FWIW, BS Player is one of the few I've found that can handle DTS Audio, however, it fails to playback do h/w accelerated playback of the video, and falls back to s/w, so it's choppy with 720p, and fails with 1080p
Primary Phone: Note3 (SM-N900T); ROM: CyanogenMod 11 (KitKat 4.4.*); kernel: Stock @ 2.3GHz; misc: Incipio DualPro; 64GB class10 microSDXC
Primary Tablet: Nexus 7 (2012); ROM: CM11
Working museum piece: SGS1 Captivate (SGH-i897); ROM: CM11; kernel: Stock @ 1.0GHz
(Other devices: Nexus 10 (stock); Retired devices: SGS3 (SGH-i747), Kindle Fire (otter), OG Galaxy Tab 7, ...)
 
 
Time_Zone
Old
#5  
Time_Zone's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 67
Posts: 381
Join Date: Apr 2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by zmore View Post
Awesome. I'll give it try, even through from what I've read the beta is still very buggy & laggy.

Wonder how long they'll "get away with it" before removing DTS support too.

EDIT: VLC beta is currently incompatible with the US SGS3
huh... This one seems to be working for me...
Attached Files
File Type: apk VLC-ARMv7-NEON.apk - [Click for QR Code] (7.58 MB, 6545 views)
Samsung Galaxy S III AT&T
I747UCDLK3 (rooted)




(Waiting on a fully stable CM10 or a SLIM port, with working Bluetooth)
The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to Time_Zone For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
zmore
Old
(Last edited by zmore; 13th August 2012 at 08:47 PM.)
#6  
zmore's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 877
Posts: 1,572
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: NYC
Quote:
Originally Posted by Time_Zone View Post
huh... This one seems to be working for me...
Whoa! That works! Wonder why the Play store shows it as incompatible...

So, after enabling h/w acceleration (disabled by default), my 720p & 1080p vids play without a hiccup. Smooth video & crisp dts audio. I'm not seeing all the bugs that are warned about. Thanks man.
Primary Phone: Note3 (SM-N900T); ROM: CyanogenMod 11 (KitKat 4.4.*); kernel: Stock @ 2.3GHz; misc: Incipio DualPro; 64GB class10 microSDXC
Primary Tablet: Nexus 7 (2012); ROM: CM11
Working museum piece: SGS1 Captivate (SGH-i897); ROM: CM11; kernel: Stock @ 1.0GHz
(Other devices: Nexus 10 (stock); Retired devices: SGS3 (SGH-i747), Kindle Fire (otter), OG Galaxy Tab 7, ...)
 
 
Time_Zone
Old
#7  
Time_Zone's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 67
Posts: 381
Join Date: Apr 2011
If I try to skip ahead or behind off a cifs mount across network the audio goes out of synch... Thats the only bug I have seen.
Samsung Galaxy S III AT&T
I747UCDLK3 (rooted)




(Waiting on a fully stable CM10 or a SLIM port, with working Bluetooth)
 
juami
Old
#8  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 83
Posts: 234
Join Date: Sep 2007
Quote:
Originally Posted by zmore View Post
DTS audio *used* to work in both DicePlayer (my old favorite; discontinued), and in MX Player (my new fav), but both of them REMOVED the dts codec a few months ago apparently because of the threat of lawsuits from using unlicensed code.

Diceplayer is not discontinued. ( https://play.google.com/store/apps/d...player.a&hl=en )

and there are a way to enable un-supported codec
search "xda diceplayer dts"
 
zmore
Old
#9  
zmore's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 877
Posts: 1,572
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: NYC
Quote:
Originally Posted by juami View Post
Diceplayer is not discontinued. ( https://play.google.com/store/apps/d...player.a&hl=en )

and there are a way to enable un-supported codec
search "xda diceplayer dts"
The impression I got is that DicePlayer switched from AdSupported&Paid versions to DonationWare in preparation of becoming AbandonWare. In any case, they removed DTS, so it's out of the running, and from the comments I read about the external dts workaround you mentioned: it doesn't work as well. VLC wins for now. Thanks, though.
Primary Phone: Note3 (SM-N900T); ROM: CyanogenMod 11 (KitKat 4.4.*); kernel: Stock @ 2.3GHz; misc: Incipio DualPro; 64GB class10 microSDXC
Primary Tablet: Nexus 7 (2012); ROM: CM11
Working museum piece: SGS1 Captivate (SGH-i897); ROM: CM11; kernel: Stock @ 1.0GHz
(Other devices: Nexus 10 (stock); Retired devices: SGS3 (SGH-i747), Kindle Fire (otter), OG Galaxy Tab 7, ...)
 
 
NZtechfreak
Old
#10  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 913
Posts: 2,349
Join Date: Sep 2008
For myself I have a backed up apk of the last MX Player to ahve DTS and I simply install that on new devices.
Twitter: @nztechfreak
Blogs: androidnz.net, blog.clove.co.uk
Facebook: http://goo.gl/baZHQ



Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes