Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,781,506 Members 39,424 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

[All XDA Members] Feedback/Recommendations for XDA

Tip us?
 
sgt. slaughter
Old
#11  
sgt. slaughter's Avatar
Retired Forum Moderator
Thanks Meter 2,898
Posts: 5,629
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Raleigh
-gary

While I agree with some of what you have said I feel if you want strictly 100% development talk then that is reserved for the RD forum for RDs to have amongst themselves... Yes there are developers that are not RDs and to that I say they should apply to become RDs. There needs to be a place to allow users to provide feedback and suggestions on things that are developed.

Sent from my EVO using Tapatalk 2
 
reinbeau
Old
#12  
reinbeau's Avatar
Retired Forum Moderator
Thanks Meter 4,690
Posts: 7,374
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: South of Boston, MA
Quote:
Originally Posted by sgt. slaughter View Post
-gary

While I agree with some of what you have said I feel if you want strictly 100% development talk then that is reserved for the RD forum for RDs to have amongst themselves... Yes there are developers that are not RDs and to that I say they should apply to become RDs. There needs to be a place to allow users to provide feedback and suggestions on things that are developed.

Sent from my EVO using Tapatalk 2
There is a place for that. The problem is there isn't a place for real development talk. Any real discussions get drowned out by inanity. I think with the influx of new people that noise to real development ratio has finally reached a tipping point. Then again, just how much input can Jon Q. Public have in development other than saying "I want this" or "How do I do that"? Those are user issues. We need to develop better developer solutions.
Ann - Not a man

Did you read the first post of the thread?

The real purpose of XDA explained in one post - Click here!

| Samsung US/Canada GSM|

Μολὼν Λαβέ
 
sgt. slaughter
Old
#13  
sgt. slaughter's Avatar
Retired Forum Moderator
Thanks Meter 2,898
Posts: 5,629
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Raleigh
Quote:
Originally Posted by reinbeau View Post
There is a place for that. The problem is there isn't a place for real development talk. Any real discussions get drowned out by inanity. I think with the influx of new people that noise to real development ratio has finally reached a tipping point. Then again, just how much input can Jon Q. Public have in development other than saying "I want this" or "How do I do that"? Those are user issues. We need to develop better developer solutions.
Hence my initial suggestion, that if you want 100% dev talk take up and use the RD forum and discuss in there...

Sent from my EVO using Tapatalk 2
 
garyd9
Old
#14  
garyd9's Avatar
Recognized Developer
Thanks Meter 1,979
Posts: 1,951
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Quote:
Originally Posted by sgt. slaughter View Post
Hence my initial suggestion, that if you want 100% dev talk take up and use the RD forum and discuss in there...
Xda DEVELOPERS. Why would a site called xda DEVELOPERS push development talk off into a corner, while non development talk reigns free?


Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I317 using Tapatalk 2

Donations: I don't accept donations, but if you are feeling charitable, help a child by going to http://www.shrinershospitalsforchildren.org/
and click the "Donate Now" link at the top.
The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to garyd9 For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
sgt. slaughter
Old
#15  
sgt. slaughter's Avatar
Retired Forum Moderator
Thanks Meter 2,898
Posts: 5,629
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Raleigh
Quote:
Originally Posted by garyd9 View Post
Xda DEVELOPERS. Why would a site called xda DEVELOPERS push development talk off into a corner, while non development talk reigns free?


Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I317 using Tapatalk 2
Adapt with the times as things change.... Change and adjusting is tough at times but if done so correctly its for the better of all those involved...

It is absolutely impossible to have purely 100% code talk in the dev sections. The size of the userbase is way too large for the mod team to regulate that.

Hence the RDs section will be best if you want no nonsense dev talk.

Sent from my EVO using Tapatalk 2
The Following User Says Thank You to sgt. slaughter For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
garyd9
Old
#16  
garyd9's Avatar
Recognized Developer
Thanks Meter 1,979
Posts: 1,951
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Quote:
Originally Posted by sgt. slaughter View Post
Adapt with the times as things change.... Change and adjusting is tough at times but if done so correctly its for the better of all those involved...
...
Hence the RDs section will be best if you want no nonsense dev talk.
You may be right, but I don't want to consider the possibility that XDA-Developers might become a non-developers forums. If your suggestion is carried out, I'd predict that it'd slowly (but surely) lose it's developer core and become more and more another "android central" or other generic handheld forum.

My reasoning is simple: XDA doesn't give birth to developers - they are born and bred before they get here. However, you're suggesting that they won't have a place to "talk shop" here unless and until they achieve RD status, which I'm assuming involves a certain application and requires that some projects have already been hawked here on XDA. I'm making some assumptions about RD here, but I think it'd be fairly safe to assume that a person can't submit a professional non-XDA resume to get it. As well, you are also always going to have some devs that simply refuse to "apply" for what they consider a "silly title." More especially those that see "ROM cooks" called RD and look the other way.

What is a real developer going to do in that case? Simple: find someplace else to talk shop.

(It's almost comical the way I talk about RD here. I've been doing professional dev for a very long, have given back to the android and ppc communities, and been an XDA member for a long time - but never bothered with RD status here when the program started. So, I honestly don't know what it might involve. I might be wrong about any type of requirements.)

I guess this question moves beyond my suggestions. I've been basing things on a developer-centric forum. That's what XDA-Developers was when I joined, and quite a few FAQ's we point users to indicate that it's still intended to be. If XDA is going to move away from that, then please disregard my suggestions.

Take care
Gary

Donations: I don't accept donations, but if you are feeling charitable, help a child by going to http://www.shrinershospitalsforchildren.org/
and click the "Donate Now" link at the top.
The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to garyd9 For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
reinbeau
Old
#17  
reinbeau's Avatar
Retired Forum Moderator
Thanks Meter 4,690
Posts: 7,374
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: South of Boston, MA
Quote:
Originally Posted by sgt. slaughter View Post
Hence my initial suggestion, that if you want 100% dev talk take up and use the RD forum and discuss in there...

Sent from my EVO using Tapatalk 2
Not everyone who develops is an RD - and why would you remove the ability for people to learn and share?

Quote:
Originally Posted by garyd9 View Post
Xda DEVELOPERS. Why would a site called xda DEVELOPERS push development talk off into a corner, while non development talk reigns free?


Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I317 using Tapatalk 2
Exactly.
Ann - Not a man

Did you read the first post of the thread?

The real purpose of XDA explained in one post - Click here!

| Samsung US/Canada GSM|

Μολὼν Λαβέ
The Following User Says Thank You to reinbeau For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
garyd9
Old
#18  
garyd9's Avatar
Recognized Developer
Thanks Meter 1,979
Posts: 1,951
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
It seems obvious that one specific issue that everyone agrees on is that *something* needs to be done to handle "developer discussion." While there are different opinions on the best way to do that, I haven't seen anyone post anything implying that dev's talking shop is a bad thing.

Fallen Spartan, perhaps this thread can branch that particular conversation to a separate thread? That would allow this thread to deal with the other issues without confusion.

Thanks
Gary

Donations: I don't accept donations, but if you are feeling charitable, help a child by going to http://www.shrinershospitalsforchildren.org/
and click the "Donate Now" link at the top.
 
Fallen Spartan
Old
#19  
Fallen Spartan's Avatar
Moderator Committee - Irish Pride, Spartan Legacy - OP
Thanks Meter 4,350
Posts: 22,996
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Belfast, Ireland Likes: Whiskey & XDA Dislikes: No whiskey

 
DONATE TO ME
Quote:
Originally Posted by garyd9 View Post
It seems obvious that one specific issue that everyone agrees on is that *something* needs to be done to handle "developer discussion." While there are different opinions on the best way to do that, I haven't seen anyone post anything implying that dev's talking shop is a bad thing.

Fallen Spartan, perhaps this thread can branch that particular conversation to a separate thread? That would allow this thread to deal with the other issues without confusion.

Thanks
Gary
For the time being I'm inclined to let the discussion continue in this thread as there isn't much else being discussed here atm. If more idea's/recommendations appear, we can then create a new thread....if needed. Also, if a set way has been agreed on a particular idea/recommendation, I can create a second post updating users so its not lost within the thread
If I have helped you, support Parkinson's
“When I was 5 years old, my mother always told me that happiness was the key to life. When I went to school, they asked me what I wanted to be when I grew up. I wrote down 'happy'. They told me I didn't understand the assignment, and I told them they didn't understand life.” ~ John Lennon
 
jb_wisemo
Old
#20  
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 3
Posts: 14
Join Date: Mar 2011
Lightbulb Making room for real developers again

Quote:
Originally Posted by reinbeau View Post
Not everyone who develops is an RD - and why would you remove the ability for people to learn and share?

Exactly.
Hello,

I am one of those professional developers in real life, who don't have the time to play silly points games just to get access to the developer part of a forum. So my "XDA status" is stuck at "noob", but I am really here to look for a place to share technical discussion with other developers.

Looking around (I have been lurking for years now), I think the following improved structure would be a good idea:

In each area (General, OS, device) there should be 4 development subforums rather than the current 1 or 2:

1. Firmware and theme releases.
One thread for each firmware/theme series, hosting download links in the top 3 posts, and support discussions in the rest of the thread.
For instance the Android Samsung Galaxy III "Firmware and theme releases" forum would have exactly one "Cyanogenmod" thread and at most one "Cyanogenmod kang by temasek" thread.

Real cooks can post new threads and create the first two replies in their own thread. Non-noob users can post in existing threads after the 3. post in the thread.

2. Free App releases.
One thread for each free app, hosting download links in the top 3 ports, and support discussions in the rest of the thread.
For instance the Android Free App releases forum would have exactly one "ROM Manager" thread.

Real developers can post new threads and create the first two replies in their own thread. Non-noob users can post in existing threads after the 3. post in the thread.

3. Unreleased experiments
One thread for each unreleased firmware/theme/free app, hosting only discussion of what should go into it, difficulties in making it etc. When released the thread is moved to 1 or 2 as appropriate, at the thread OPs command.

Only real cooks and real developers can post here, there is a limit on new threads per user per month depending on the posters general standing.

4. Developer to Developer
This hosts regular forum style discussion threads where developers for that target (OS/phone) can ask each other questions about technical details for the target, one thread per subject matter, no threads about specific projects. This is the place to discuss stuff like ("Which wceload variants are in which upstream firmwares" in a WM forum or "How are the GPIO pins on the SoC connected to other parts of the phone (in a phone specific forum) or "How does the foo() API work" (in an OS forum)).

Only real cooks and real developers can post here.

Determining access:

Now as to determining the "real cook" and "real developer" status of a user, there could be a quiz and a number of extrinsic tests for each OS. Quiz questions would be multiple choice that a real cook/devel would answer easily, but a poser would get wrong. Other tests could be "prove that you have a developer account on Market/AppStore/OVI/Marketplace" "Show that you can sign an empty sis/cab/etc. with a valid developer certificate" Because getting a new certificate/account for some of the platforms may no longer be possible or may be otherwise restricted, such
tests would just count as N correct quiz answers in determining the pass/fail.

The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to jb_wisemo For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes