Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,779,301 Members 50,079 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

Off-topic, other device, comparisons to other devices, and upgrading phone discussion

Tip us?
 
Naddict
Old
#1  
Naddict's Avatar
Forum Moderator - OP
Thanks Meter 13800
Posts: 8,541
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: 28.2S, 92.1W
Default Off-topic, other device, comparisons to other devices, and upgrading phone discussion

Please use this thread to discuss devices other than and any comparisons with other devices on or about the GS 5 in this thread and any other off-topic issues that are not needing a new thread.

Post with respect, this is a helpful community, hope we all learn from this stuff in here.
Every time you don't use search, a kitten, bunny, baby turtle, and fuzzy Harp Seal are killed.

Read the Rules! -- Search Before You Post! -- Learn about XDA -- Need A Moderators Help? -- Get the Most out of XDA! -- Curious about GPL?
The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to Naddict For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
barondebxl
Old
#2  
barondebxl's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 1476
Posts: 6,155
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Silver Spring, MD
Anyone has both the M8 and S5? Or had the M8 and now the S5 _(or the other way around? Although the S5 just came out)? How do they compare? Please try to be as objective as possible Thanks!

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
Jack Bauer is back!!!!!!!!!

Current Device: OnePlus One

Recently Owned


HTC One M8

Sony Xperia Z2

Samsung Galaxy S 5

Oppo Find 7a
 
besweeet
Old
#3  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 39
Posts: 331
Join Date: Dec 2009
I have both on me to review for a while. The M8 is obviously heavier, a little taller but not quite as wide as the GS5. I prefer something compact to better use in one hand, like an iPhone, but either one isn't as bad as I thought to use with one hand (although still somewhat difficult). I'm really enjoying the GS5's design. After using the M8 for a week, it already feels a bit dated for some reason. I'm glad the GS5 doesn't use virtual navigation buttons, allowing more screen space. Those are basically my initial impressions between the two for now.
The Following User Says Thank You to besweeet For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
lyrad12
Old
#4  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 23
Posts: 320
Join Date: Nov 2010
it's there any dedicated forum for galaxy gear fit? I just saw the forum of the first gen of the gear that's it

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N900A using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
 
Pure+
Old
#5  
Pure+'s Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 270
Posts: 776
Join Date: May 2013
I don't think this topic needs it's own thread so I'll post here. How fast does the S5 charge to full? I plugged mine in last night when i went to bed and it seemed like it was charging about 1% per minute or faster.
 
delawaredrew
Old
#6  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 73
Posts: 164
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: Olympia, WA
Quote:
Originally Posted by barondebxl View Post
Anyone has both the M8 and S5? Or had the M8 and now the S5 _(or the other way around? Although the S5 just came out)? How do they compare? Please try to be as objective as possible Thanks!

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
My gf has the M8 and I have the S5. Only a few days now but I like them both. We both had hung onto our original Rooted and ROMed Notes before these.
Some initial impressions:
  • S5 is lighter so maybe a bit easier to one hand, although after the Dell Streak and Note anything seems small and easy.
  • M8 feels more solid due to design/weight, but that is more a perception than function thing. The all plastic Note was fine so I don't expect an issue with the S5.
  • Screens are comparable, both very nice; different but one isn't distinctly better than the other in real life usage.
  • Speaker sound is obviously won by the M8, not even close. The S5 is ok, but the M8 is designed for sound and it shows.
  • Performance seems great for both, although I haven't had the M8 in my hand as much.
  • Reception (LTE) is the same in a side by side test on my table, just using the on screen indicator. Both are better than the Note.
  • I actually like the on screen keys on the M8 as they are the same as my tablets, I'm getting used to the S5 home button but I haven't had a physical home button in a long time (since the iPhone 3g- ...don't judge me!).

We both ditched the Stock UI for Nova and/or Apex Launcher immediately so I have no idea how Sense and Touchwiz compare in usage other than they felt both restrictive and simplistic off the bat.

Let me know if there is anything specific you want to know and I'll check it out; but after a few days around both I'd be happy using either device.
Drew
The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to delawaredrew For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
903tex
Old
(Last edited by 903tex; 18th April 2014 at 10:49 AM.)
#7  
903tex's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 178
Posts: 962
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Tyler, Texas
Here my review as I've had both devices in the past couples of days.

Design m8> s5

Both phones to me look great but the design on the m8 is sexy! When I saw the s5 all I've seen where white models, which to me made the phone look horrible cause of the added width made the screen look smaller than it actually is UNTIL I got my black s5 and loved it as soon as I traded my m8 in.

Camera s5> m8

Pics on the m8 ON THE PHONE look amazing but when crop you see the flaw in the 4mp shooter. S5 camera just clearly is the better point shoot camera if you want to use your pics past social media uploads. If not then M8 should do you fine.

One hand use s5> m8

As sexy as the m8 is the back is slippery and I felt very uncomfortable one hand using the phone and the fact that the m8 is narrow and taller reaching the top of the screen was a scary thing to do as I was running the phone with no case whatsoever. Case Will solve the slippery back but with the s5 I don't feel like I need a case as the back is nice to touch and being that the phone is lighter than the m8 makes me feel I have one hand control of the phone at all time.

Speakers m8> s5

Don't really need to go into this and one of the features I miss on the m8 as I do listen to a lot of music.

Screen draw

Both are beautiful

Features s5> m8

S5 more featured packed but the features in the m8 are no slouch
Wish the s5 had the double tap to wake the phone but since it has the finger print I can see why they didn't go with that feature. Overall while some think their gimmicky the features on the s5 are fun and very useful to use when need be.

Internal memory m8> s5

More internal storage for the same price as a 16gb s5 is always gonna be better for some. NOW the SD card slot is working great for me so my Internal memory can be just for apps but those that don't like SD then note the s5 32gb will be slightly more on contract and off contract than the m8.

Battery life s5 > m8

My s5 is doing great and I love the feature with the power saving option offering a extended mode for those needs when Your at 10% and won't be near a charger for period of time.
But the m8 battery life is just as good as the s5 with my units I had.

Custom Roms m8> s5

One of the big reason xda was started for and unless u have the t-mobile variant then root and maybe a stock tw rom is all your gonna get from the s5 att model. But the experience with the new tw is very nice and I'm not seeing lag as previous galaxy phones in the past

So basically it comes down to this

Features or custom roms?
Top build quality or water resistant plastic?
4mp or 16mp camera?
Boomsound or fingerprint?

I don't think you can go wrong with any of the two flagships. Custom roms are great but some don't function and leave features that sold you into the phone from the beginning. Samsung is becoming apple which is not a bad thing. I remember when HTC was doing the locked bl and fans went nuts then they slowly changed their ways of tactics. as a phone the s5 and the m8 IS that plus some. now I'm more than happy with my s5, you may need your root and that's it which I see s5 having at some point very soon. But if u need your custom kernels and aosp roms then don't even look at the s5. Hope this helps those deciding between the two....



Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G900A using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Current Device

Nexus 5



Previous Devices
TO MANY TO LIST!!! LOL



IF I HELPED YOU WITH ANYTHING HIT THAT THANKS BUTTON.......
The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to 903tex For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
 
Skv012a
Old
#8  
Skv012a's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 36
Posts: 433
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: MD
Still mad at ATT gutting the chipset for the stupid LTE, but such is life. Good to see a waterproof flaship, at long last. Korea's finally starting to catch up to Japan in physical features.
Oh, what's this? A blog? Wanna click? Click it! Do it!!
Nokia E6 to do WERK, Galaxy S2 to fool around.
 
johnkirchner
Old
#9  
johnkirchner's Avatar
Member
Thanks Meter 14
Posts: 36
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Montana
Tutorial GS5 Typo

Not sure if this is just on the ATT variant but I found this amusing...

Click image for larger version

Name:	typo.png
Views:	389
Size:	196.3 KB
ID:	2698337
 
bailey37821
Old
(Last edited by bailey37821; 21st April 2014 at 02:52 PM.) Reason: accuracy
#10  
bailey37821's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 24
Posts: 125
Join Date: Sep 2012
Quote:
Originally Posted by barondebxl View Post
Anyone has both the M8 and S5? Or had the M8 and now the S5 _(or the other way around? Although the S5 just came out)? How do they compare? Please try to be as objective as possible Thanks!

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
Coming from an Lg optimus G Pro..... got an M8 on 4/17 and started having issues with it resetting the home screens for no reason. Im sure it is probably just a rare bad unit but since it is my first HTC, I decided to return it and get an S5.

Really no reason to write several paragraphs on the comparisons as most of the comparisons done so far is what I have seen as well. To sum it up

*The HTC is elegant, cleaner interface, not as "gimmicky", looks and feels better made (although covering it in a case takes away all that beauty advantage), and has better external sound (by a lot). This not only applies to music but also to speaker phone calls. For those that are still confused about the sd card The US version DOES HAVE an SD slot on the left side opposite to the sim tray, so that argument is mute. The onscreen buttons are a pain to get used to unless you are coming from something with the same.

* The S5 takes better pics (not by a lot and you really only notice when they are side by side unless you have a photographers eye), the s5 is water and dust resistant (this is a biggie impo), i think the s5 battery is going to be a bit better, I dont see any real world difference in the screen clarity or color between the two. You will never notice any difference in speed rather in everyday apps or playing something like riptide, the s5 operates hotter and does not dissipate processor heat as well as the m8. Im worried about the charging port cover breaking on the s5. Too bad they did not get rid of the fp scanner and the hr monitor and spend the money on dual speakers.

*Photos and water resistance important = S5
*Sound and cleaner less gimmicky important = M8

"All readers should consider that every word stated here is a matter of opinion. I am not explicitly promoting either phone or brand, and only making statements of fact as they apply to my personnel observations"

The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to bailey37821 For This Useful Post: [ Click to Expand ]
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes