Attend XDA's Second Annual Developer Conference, XDA:DevCon 2014!
5,777,893 Members 50,466 Now Online
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum

[Q] Stock alarm clock is being unreliable?

Tip us?
 
aladd04
Old
#1  
Junior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 1
Posts: 13
Join Date: Jun 2013
Default [Q] Stock alarm clock is being unreliable?

Has anyone else been having problems with the stock alarm clock on the Galaxy S4? Mine seems to be unreliable. Goes off one morning, but not the next. But is random when it works and doesn't.

Current settings:
Android: 4.2.2
Carrier: Verizon
Time: 7am
Days: MTWTF
Repeat Weekly: Checked
Alarm type: Vibration and Melody
Alarm tone: Journey
Sound: Maxed
Location alarm: off
Snooze: off
Smart alarm: off
In "menu" outside that section I have "voice control" off.
Not rooted, no other ROM. Just default, stock Verizon Galaxy S4.

Before I go to bed I double check to make sure my alarm is on and sound is at the max (not in vibration or silent mode). Power saving mode is "off". I have no task killers. I do close all my apps using the default android task manager. But then I turn the alarm clock back on because I'm paranoid. But none of this seems to help.

I've tried factory reset, that didn't seem to help as it still sometimes goes off and sometimes doesn't. I have not tried any other alarms than the stock one. I will be trying one (any suggestions?) and updating this to let you know if it worked. But until then, it would be cool to see if I'm not the only one having this issue and to see if anyone else has solved this!

Thanks!
 
Tortuga
Old
#2  
Tortuga's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 154
Posts: 444
Join Date: Oct 2010
Quote:
Originally Posted by aladd04 View Post
Has anyone else been having problems with the stock alarm clock on the Galaxy S4? Mine seems to be unreliable. Goes off one morning, but not the next. But is random when it works and doesn't.

Current settings:
Android: 4.2.2
Carrier: Verizon
Time: 7am
Days: MTWTF
Repeat Weekly: Checked
Alarm type: Vibration and Melody
Alarm tone: Journey
Sound: Maxed
Location alarm: off
Snooze: off
Smart alarm: off
In "menu" outside that section I have "voice control" off.
Not rooted, no other ROM. Just default, stock Verizon Galaxy S4.

Before I go to bed I double check to make sure my alarm is on and sound is at the max (not in vibration or silent mode). Power saving mode is "off". I have no task killers. I do close all my apps using the default android task manager. But then I turn the alarm clock back on because I'm paranoid. But none of this seems to help.

I've tried factory reset, that didn't seem to help as it still sometimes goes off and sometimes doesn't. I have not tried any other alarms than the stock one. I will be trying one (any suggestions?) and updating this to let you know if it worked. But until then, it would be cool to see if I'm not the only one having this issue and to see if anyone else has solved this!

Thanks!
I use the alarm every day as well, and have not had a problem with it not going off. Are you using one of the stock alarm tones, or a custom song/sound? I have used both without issues, but if you're using something other than a stock tone, maybe try one of those to see if it's an issue with your audio file.

Edit: I see that it's called "Journey" so that may be a stock tone. I guess I'm not sure then
 
aladd04
Old
#3  
Junior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 1
Posts: 13
Join Date: Jun 2013
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tortuga View Post
I use the alarm every day as well, and have not had a problem with it not going off. Are you using one of the stock alarm tones, or a custom song/sound? I have used both without issues, but if you're using something other than a stock tone, maybe try one of those to see if it's an issue with your audio file.

Edit: I see that it's called "Journey" so that may be a stock tone. I guess I'm not sure then
Correct, the alarm tone I'm using is a stock tone. It's woken me up before, so I don't think I'm sleeping through it :P haha. My only guess is my phone is somehow going into a low power state that's not updating the time every minute, therefore the alarm time is sometimes getting skipped and therefore not getting triggered. I just don't know what would be causing this as I have "power saving mode" off and I haven't ran into any other settings that would do this... I do plug my phone in overnight too, so you'd think it would be going full force anyway. But I just recently switched from iOS so I'm still a bit new to the android side of things .
 
Tortuga
Old
#4  
Tortuga's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 154
Posts: 444
Join Date: Oct 2010
Quote:
Originally Posted by aladd04 View Post
Correct, the alarm tone I'm using is a stock tone. It's woken me up before, so I don't think I'm sleeping through it :P haha. My only guess is my phone is somehow going into a low power state that's not updating the time every minute, therefore the alarm time is sometimes getting skipped and therefore not getting triggered. I just don't know what would be causing this as I have "power saving mode" off and I haven't ran into any other settings that would do this... I do plug my phone in overnight too, so you'd think it would be going full force anyway. But I just recently switched from iOS so I'm still a bit new to the android side of things .
Have you tried running some daytime tests to see if it rings on time? The clock on the lockscreen may only update when the screen is on, but the phone always knows what time it is. If you can get it to skip alarms reliably, maybe take it to a Verizon store and have them swap it out. I've used my cell phone as an alarm for quite a few years (I have a backup as well, but only because I'm pretty good at shutting alarms off in my sleep) and the only times I had trouble was with older phones when I was rooted and running a less-than-stable custom roms.
 
aladd04
Old
#5  
Junior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 1
Posts: 13
Join Date: Jun 2013
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tortuga View Post
Have you tried running some daytime tests to see if it rings on time? The clock on the lockscreen may only update when the screen is on, but the phone always knows what time it is. If you can get it to skip alarms reliably, maybe take it to a Verizon store and have them swap it out. I've used my cell phone as an alarm for quite a few years (I have a backup as well, but only because I'm pretty good at shutting alarms off in my sleep) and the only times I had trouble was with older phones when I was rooted and running a less-than-stable custom roms.
I did run various tests throughout the day yesterday, have a few set for today too. All went off fine so far. The stock alarm woke me up this morning too. Maybe I just had to break it in haha. I'm worried it will skip again, though, so I'm using my desktop as a backup alarm clock, lol. If it does skip I will more than likely take it to Verizon, as this doesn't seem normal. Haven't tried any non-stock alarm clock apps yet. Guess I should look for a good backup app just in case eh.
 
cubarican84
Old
#6  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 62
Posts: 260
Join Date: Jun 2010
No problems here. Use everyday on Stock ROM

Sent from my SCH-I545 using xda premium
 
gdude
Old
#7  
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 3
Posts: 13
Join Date: Apr 2010
Default Frustrated

Quote:
Originally Posted by aladd04 View Post
Has anyone else been having problems with the stock alarm clock on the Galaxy S4? Mine seems to be unreliable. Goes off one morning, but not the next. But is random when it works and doesn't.

Thanks!
I am running the stock ROM and like you have intermittent problems. Very very problematic.
 
aladd04
Old
#8  
Junior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 1
Posts: 13
Join Date: Jun 2013
Quote:
Originally Posted by gdude View Post
I am running the stock ROM and like you have intermittent problems. Very very problematic.
I ended up switching to an app called "Timely". I have had zero issues with myself ever not hearing this app or it not going off. Even if the phone is on vibrate or silent.
 
alexvv
Old
#9  
Member
Thanks Meter 2
Posts: 34
Join Date: Jan 2013
Location: Athens
Quote:
Originally Posted by aladd04 View Post
Has anyone else been having problems with the stock alarm clock on the Galaxy S4? Mine seems to be unreliable. Goes off one morning, but not the next. But is random when it works and doesn't.

Current settings:
Android: 4.2.2
Carrier: Verizon
Time: 7am
Days: MTWTF
Repeat Weekly: Checked
Alarm type: Vibration and Melody
Alarm tone: Journey
Sound: Maxed
Location alarm: off
Snooze: off
Smart alarm: off
In "menu" outside that section I have "voice control" off.
Not rooted, no other ROM. Just default, stock Verizon Galaxy S4.

Before I go to bed I double check to make sure my alarm is on and sound is at the max (not in vibration or silent mode). Power saving mode is "off". I have no task killers. I do close all my apps using the default android task manager. But then I turn the alarm clock back on because I'm paranoid. But none of this seems to help.

I've tried factory reset, that didn't seem to help as it still sometimes goes off and sometimes doesn't. I have not tried any other alarms than the stock one. I will be trying one (any suggestions?) and updating this to let you know if it worked. But until then, it would be cool to see if I'm not the only one having this issue and to see if anyone else has solved this!

Thanks!
yes it's really unreliable not only in your 4.2 s4. it often doesnt go off on my s3 mini too. just download another one.
 
thesoldier
Old
#10  
thesoldier's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 166
Posts: 829
Join Date: Nov 2012
I was just gonna say I've never had a problem with the stock alarm...and what do you know, this morning it didn't go off. I always wake up no matter how loud or quiet the alarm is so I'm fairly certain I didn't sleep through it.

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes