Introducing XDA:DevCon – A Conference For Developers By Developers
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum
Forgot your password?
 
Tip us?
 
Keystone
Old
#11  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 12
Posts: 405
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Victoria, BC
no2chem's 5060 build uses 3.35.04 on up, but I can't remember which older build switched from radio 3.27....
Have a Mogul/P4000/Titan and need help??? Read the XDA-Wiki <--- oh so long ago...moved then on to a Touch Pro, Touch Pro 2, Desire HD, now a Motorola Defy using Euroskank's cherry picks for CM7.2 & a Transformer TF101 on Team EOS JB.
______________________
Key's cleaned 3.35 Titan kitchen
 
maskedlion
Old
#12  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 138
Join Date: Feb 2008
How about some links on the front post to each of the ROMs and Radios.
 
Keystone
Old
(Last edited by Keystone; 14th May 2008 at 12:26 AM.)
#13  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 12
Posts: 405
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Victoria, BC
Quote:
Originally Posted by maskedlion View Post
How about some links on the front post to each of the ROMs and Radios.
Naw....on that point my opinion is to discourage it. General items can be great but at what point do too many sticky threads at the top become too cluttered and actually discourage their intent of quick glancing info...?

General stickies require less maintenance for administrators to remove the outdated or supplemented ROM/Kitchen sticky threads and replace with another. Plus who's ROM/Kitchen or app get's the bonus of a sticky thread? This forum is fantastic without competition between developers and everyone working respectfully together. I can see one person making a request for their thread to become a sticky and then the dominoes falling of others doing the same and moderators eventually getting frustrated at being called up to maintain it. We could try and get one of our regulars moderator status, but I don't think that's necessary.

For ROMs/Kitchens/Apps, I think the way we have it now works just fine. The Wiki already has links to ROMs and radios, where all kitchen builders and any member here can update at will. To find any of that from the first page of the forum it is only 2 links deep (from the Titan Wiki sticky thread). The forum search function also gets neglected by some. gcincotta could keep updating the first post in this thread with direct links to the mentioned builds, but that can be a lot of extra & regular work for one person. The current ROM/Kitchen threads don't get sunk too far back in the forum as long as interest and posts to those threads remain active.

The worst case scenerio is to have the first page of this upgrading forum confused and full of stickies....almost like that found at PPGeeks....
Have a Mogul/P4000/Titan and need help??? Read the XDA-Wiki <--- oh so long ago...moved then on to a Touch Pro, Touch Pro 2, Desire HD, now a Motorola Defy using Euroskank's cherry picks for CM7.2 & a Transformer TF101 on Team EOS JB.
______________________
Key's cleaned 3.35 Titan kitchen
 
maskedlion
Old
#14  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 138
Join Date: Feb 2008
Maybe you mis-read my post or meant to quote someone else.
Each of the ROMs and Radios are already referred to in the first post of this thread. My suggestion is to make the text in the first post for each of the ROMs and Radios referenced into a hyperlink that would allow the reader to link to the forum thread where the ROM or Radio that they are interested in is detailed. In no way would I like to see more sticky threads, I think the one is fine.
 
maskedlion
Old
#15  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 138
Join Date: Feb 2008
Also, by what account is the 3.39.10 Radio considered to be the best? Is there any benefit to it over the 3.35 radio or are we flashing for the sake of flasing?
 
Keystone
Old
#16  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 12
Posts: 405
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Victoria, BC
Sorry maskedlion, yeah I rushed & barely glanced at your post... That's up to gcincotta if he wants to take on the load or not. As it is, I think he's done a fine job.

My preference would be for each of the ROM/Radio groupings to link directly to the Wiki pages for Titan with GPS Home Page, Titan older pre-GPS ROMs Home Page, and Titan Stock Home Page. Only one place then to maintain but still returning the info and links to the needed threads/files.
Have a Mogul/P4000/Titan and need help??? Read the XDA-Wiki <--- oh so long ago...moved then on to a Touch Pro, Touch Pro 2, Desire HD, now a Motorola Defy using Euroskank's cherry picks for CM7.2 & a Transformer TF101 on Team EOS JB.
______________________
Key's cleaned 3.35 Titan kitchen
 
gc14
Old
(Last edited by gc14; 14th May 2008 at 01:57 AM.)
#17  
gc14's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 7
Posts: 1,815
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Boston, MA
The purpose for this sticky is for reference for newcomers to our community. Yes, the information is available on the wiki, but most people who come here don't bother to read much as it is before flashing, nevermind go to another site to read up on it.

I've seen post after post after post flooding dcd's kitchen thread from people who have flashed a 3.x.x rom and are using the 3.27 radio, or worse, come from stock and just flash a 3.x.x rom. My intent for this was/is for it to catch their eye beforehand.

I'm not posting instructions on how to aquire said roms/radios, nor am I posting where to find them, that's what the search function is for and that's why we have a wiki.

To maskedillion regarding radio 3.39.10, when Sprint/HTC released their update activating GPS/RevA they also released radio 3.35.04. With their recent update, they have released radio 3.39.10. New firmware is new firmware. I'm sure Sprint/HTC wouldn't have bothered to release a new radio if there wasn't SOME improvement. Radio 3.37.20 was released from Alltel/HTC with their update activating GPS/RevA. My question to you is, if you're an engineer writing radio firmware, would you bother to sit down and write new firmware just for the sake of it? Or would you write new firmware if you have additions/updates to make to the old firmware? I'm an engineer myself and I write firmware for a living, and I would choose the latter. If people don't want to use the new radio they don't have to, but I'm personally recommending it due to pure common sense.
Motorola Droid X
---------------------------------
Motorola Droid - Retired
HTC Touch Pro - Retired
HTC Titan - Retired
HTC Apache - Retired

---------------------------------
GC's Touch Pro ROMs & Kitchen
If you're pleased with me or my work...leave me a donation
---------------------------------
Twitter: @gcincotta


 
Keystone
Old
#18  
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 12
Posts: 405
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Victoria, BC
Quote:
Originally Posted by gcincotta View Post
With their recent update, they have released radio 3.39.10. New firmware is new firmware. I'm sure Sprint/HTC wouldn't have bothered to release a new radio if there wasn't SOME improvement.
It should be noted that the Sprint 3.39.10 radio and associated OS was leaked (as 3.27) from their internal testing and hasn't been released to the public.
Have a Mogul/P4000/Titan and need help??? Read the XDA-Wiki <--- oh so long ago...moved then on to a Touch Pro, Touch Pro 2, Desire HD, now a Motorola Defy using Euroskank's cherry picks for CM7.2 & a Transformer TF101 on Team EOS JB.
______________________
Key's cleaned 3.35 Titan kitchen
 
gc14
Old
#19  
gc14's Avatar
Senior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 7
Posts: 1,815
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Boston, MA
Right...it was leaked...but it's probably not as "experimental" as was 3.27. When 3.27 was leaked it was while testing GPS/RevA...now that both have been released (with 3.35.04), I highly doubt 3.39.10 is as buggy as 3.27. Sprint may release an even newer radio when they officially release this update, and if so I'll indicate that on the first page. I will indicate that it is a pre-released radio though.
Motorola Droid X
---------------------------------
Motorola Droid - Retired
HTC Touch Pro - Retired
HTC Titan - Retired
HTC Apache - Retired

---------------------------------
GC's Touch Pro ROMs & Kitchen
If you're pleased with me or my work...leave me a donation
---------------------------------
Twitter: @gcincotta


 
ebb
Old
#20  
ebb's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 3
Posts: 164
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Denver
My 2 cents:

On the stock rom radios, at least on verizon, I had problems with 1.40, but found 1.47 and 2.13 the best of that bunch.

On the latest rom radios, again with verizon, I would rank them 3.39>3.35>3.37. I found them all similar on cell, and wifi; but found 3.35 a little better than 3.37 on gps and bluetooth, and 3.39 to be better on gps and much better on bluetooth than either of the other two.

I don't pay a lot of attention to battery life (always prepared after 2.5 years with the battery poor samsung i730) and imo it depends alot on your location, but 3.39 seems a little better in that category as well.

 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Go to top of page...

XDA PORTAL POSTS

Flash Custom ROM and Recovery to Samsung Galaxy S 4

After reading about Dan Rosenberg’s bootloader exploit for the Samsung Galaxy S 4,I … more

Windows-Based Multi-Tool for the Sony Xperia U

If you are a flashaholic and an owner of the Sony Xperia U, you may be interested in the … more

XDA University: Crafting Recovery-Flashable Packages

Those of us who use Linux on a day to day basis don’t think twice about sinking … more