Lightbulb Case Quality Comparison

I just recieved my Innocase II Surface from here: http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d.html/r...t&a=B0036DDDCA

Though nice, at $26, pricy(please no $600 Mega phone rants) in comparison to other options, quality options, available. One such available option is the DCMUGEN casefound here: http://cgi.ebay.com/WHITE-Soft-TPU-H...#ht_3647wt_557

Now, at 5 bucks including shipping, for a case that I have seen on other sites for quadruple the price, that sounds nice. When I am basically looking at the same quality, just a slightly different design.

Can I ask others opinions about these two cases? They seem to be the best in our lot. If anyone has both? Comparisons. If only the Dcmugen, any pros or cons on that case. And if only t innocase, any pros or cons as well.

I am thinking of returning this one and with the price difference buying two or three of the other.

Thanks in advance guys
NOTE2

Old phones:
iPhone 4s(Blech!! SOLD!)
G2(BackUp)
SAMSUNG VIBRANT(Returned)
RHODIUM(Again, Sold On Craigslist)
S743 Rose(Sold on XDA)
DASH 3G(So happy to have discovered Windows Mobile Standard. Sold on Craigslist)
NEXUS ONE(Sold on XDA)
RHODIUM(Was So Happy to be Done With Windows)
FUZE(Should have stayed with this one, why did I keep upgrading? Sold on XDA)
WING(The Beginning)

Quote:
Difficulties can never be greater than our capacity to solve them!
P.R. Sarkar