New: XDA launches forum for app developers. Discuss coding, tools, marketing, and more.
XDA Developers Android and Mobile Development Forum
Forgot your password?
 
Post Reply+
Tip us?
 
f4b1ck
Old
#1  
Junior Member - OP
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 2
Join Date: Jul 2010
Default [Q] Compatibility with car charger on 1.5A and 5V

Hi,
a friend of mine have gifted to me a car charger that is incompatible with my Legend, because is miniusb (with output: 5V - 1.5A) and the regular charger in bundle with the phone is microusb with output: 5V - 1A.
Can I use the car charger, with a differte cable (the car charger can use usb cables), or the current in output is to much for the phone?
 
Dr.Romca
Old
#2  
Dr.Romca's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 203
Posts: 746
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Prague
It doesn't actually matter how powerful the PSU (power source unit) is, even if it was 5V / 10A you could still use it... To put it to easy talk, the phone will just take what it needs. The important parameter is Voltage, which is OK - 5V
HTC One X, maXXimus, Nokia X3-02.5 for work
Before: HTC Desire S (my wife's now...), HTC Legend, Asus P750, SE W800i, SE K700i, SE T610i, Panasonic GD67, Ericsson T10...
_________________________________
Click "THANKS" if your read anything helpfull, that's the least you can do
My BatteryMOD, BootAnim and Splash
 
mtdnelson
Old
#3  
Junior Member
Thanks Meter 0
Posts: 3
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: London
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr.Romca View Post
It doesn't actually matter how powerful the PSU (power source unit) is, even if it was 5V / 10A you could still use it...
That's not quite true. The power does matter, but only in a limited way. The voltage (volts) must match. The current (amps) or power (watts) rating of the supply must be at least that which the device draws.

So in this case; yes, you are absolutely fine. You just need an adaptor to make the plug fit.

My work phone has a mini-USB socket, but requires 1.5A to charge successfully, which is three times as much as standard USB. My personal phone has the same socket, but will charge when connected to a conventional USB host like a laptop, which only supplies up to 0.5A. I can use any USB charger with my own phone, but I can only charge my work phone from its own charger.

Apparently I've not made enough posts to include links, but you can google "Charging Batteries Using USB Power - Maxim" and click on the first link, as long as you don't mind reading a moderately technical document.
 
Dr.Romca
Old
#4  
Dr.Romca's Avatar
Senior Member
Thanks Meter 203
Posts: 746
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Prague
Don't nitpick I'm an engineer so I know how these things work end to end, If you have power and a good charger (not meaning the car charger, but the actual charging circuit handling the battery charging inside the phone) you can charge even from 5V / 200mA It'll just take more time, of course you'd have to add more than the phone consumpts, but if you do that you're basically OK...
What you're referring to is USB charging, we all know USB doesn't have to have full 5V but in case of charger, there will be 5V...(possibly even more when open)
HTC One X, maXXimus, Nokia X3-02.5 for work
Before: HTC Desire S (my wife's now...), HTC Legend, Asus P750, SE W800i, SE K700i, SE T610i, Panasonic GD67, Ericsson T10...
_________________________________
Click "THANKS" if your read anything helpfull, that's the least you can do
My BatteryMOD, BootAnim and Splash
 
ladidaaa
Old
(Last edited by ladidaaa; 31st March 2011 at 01:58 PM.) Reason: discovered sth new
#5  
Member
Thanks Meter 12
Posts: 33
Join Date: Sep 2010

 
DONATE TO ME
I have this car charger with 5V and 1000mAh

http://www.ansmann.de/cms/de/consumr...micro-usb.html

and i must say it is worse than the Original charger for the Wall outlet from HTC -- it takes about twice as long to charge the phone.
And when i use my phone for Navigation it even slowly discharges the phone - which is truly annoying!

EDIT:
I did some research: on original HTC Chargers the Data+ and Data- pins on the micro-USB-connector are short-circuited to tell the HTC-Phone that it connected to an original charger - only when the phone realizes this, it charges with 1000mA!!! Otherwise it only charges with the USB-specificated 500mA

You can easily check this when you charge your Phone with a 3rd-Party charger, go to:
Settings-> Telephone-Status -> Battery
Here is usually written charging (USB)
only with original chargers you get "charging" (AC)

I opened the connector of my Car-charger and short-circuited the Data+ and Data- --> Now it says charging (AC)
I still have to test if charges faster now, and charges the phone while navigation - because until now it discharges while navigation, despite being connected to the Car-charger.

So to say it short: If you want to quickly charge your phone in your car buy a original HTC Car charger, or short-circuit a 3rd-Party one.
 
aamhm
Old
#6  
Member
Thanks Meter 6
Posts: 35
Join Date: Dec 2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by f4b1ck View Post
Hi,
a friend of mine have gifted to me a car charger that is incompatible with my Legend, because is miniusb (with output: 5V - 1.5A) and the regular charger in bundle with the phone is microusb with output: 5V - 1A.
Can I use the car charger, with a differte cable (the car charger can use usb cables), or the current in output is to much for the phone?
don't worry you can charge your phone with no problem
i have the same 5V 1.2 A ,it's charging with no problem

XDA PORTAL POSTS

Dos and Don’ts of Android Design

As long as you’re coming from some type of programming background, the unseen part of app … more

Expand Your Choice of Icons with Icon Themer

Icons are some of the most commonly themed elements of the Android UI, and there is certainly no … more

MicrowaveTimePicker Brings 4.2 TimePicker to 2.1+ Devices

It’s frustrating to see slick new features that you can’t use when … more

What’s Possible with CASUAL & How to Make Your Own CASUAL – XDA Developer TV

XDA Elite Recognized Developer AdamOutler is known … more