Banking app detects root on multiple devices.

[IcY~]

My banking app (PermataMobile X) is detecting root with Safetynet passed and Magisk Manager hidden. I asked some other people to install and see if they can pass the root detection to no avail.

I've tried some little things to narrow down the culprit like:
1. Installed Magisk Manager without flashing the magisk 20.4 zip file (unrooted). Detected as root. Uninstalling the manager immediately allows bank app to work.
2. Flashed Magisk 20.4 without installing Magisk Manager. Detected as root, obviously.
3. Went back to previous versions of Magisk and Magisk Manager. Still detected as root.

Anyone can give any tips on what else I can try to do?

 

[gringo80]

My banking app (PermataMobile X) is detecting root with Safetynet passed and Magisk Manager hidden. I asked some other people to install and see if they can pass the root detection to no avail.

I've tried some little things to narrow down the culprit like:
1. Installed Magisk Manager without flashing the magisk 20.4 zip file (unrooted). Detected as root. Uninstalling the manager immediately allows bank app to work.
2. Flashed Magisk 20.4 without installing Magisk Manager. Detected as root, obviously.
3. Went back to previous versions of Magisk and Magisk Manager. Still detected as root.

Anyone can give any tips on what else I can try to do?

If you can pass SafetyNet (cts profile) try to hide :
Magisk Manager with a random name (mandatory) ... and "Your banking app" must be hidden too along with Google Services of course !

 

[Didgeridoohan]

There are currently several ways of detecting Magisk that MagiskHide can't circumvent.

If the app isn't using one of those (if it is you'll just have to wait for a possible update to Magisk), you can find some tips and tricks here:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps

 

[IcY~]

Magisk cannot hide:
Other known root apps (see "Detecting apps requiring root"). (Shouldn't be a problem since even with a renamed manager and magisk unflashed it still works.)
Remnants of previous root method, including any root management apps (a good way to remove most remnants of root is osm0sis unSU script). (Magisk is unflashed and app immediately works.)
Unlocked bootloader (see Unlocked bootloader). (Magisk is unflashed and bootloader unlocked, app still works. I also tried custom rom and the stock rom.)
A tripped Samsung Knox counter. (Not a samsung phone.)
Xposed (deactivate it or uninstall). It doesn't matter if it's systemless, Magisk can't hide it. (Never used.)
EdXposed. Detection of EdXposed can sometimes be worked around with newer release of EdXposed and/or features like the EdXposed Manager blacklist. (Never used.)
USB/ADB Debugging (disable under Developer options in Android settings). (Magisk unflashed and debugging on, app works.)
Developer options. (Magisk unflashed and developer options is on, app works.)
Some Magisk modules - Depending on what the module does, it may not be able to be hidden by MagiskHide. (Tried core only mode which should disable all modules, still don't work.)
Some modifications to /system. Make sure to use Magisk modules... (I'm not sure what this means :c)

From that list it looks like it's something from Magisk itself that's tripping the detection :/
Im going bald from this.

 

[Didgeridoohan]

From that list it looks like it's something from Magisk itself that's tripping the detection :/
Im going bald from this.

If you've tested and confirmed everything else, it is very likely that the app is using a detection method that Magisk currently can't hide from.

Solution? Wait for @topjohnwu to possibly update Magisk/MagiskHide (alternatively, don't install Magisk). When? Whenever he feels like it...

 

[IcY~]

If you've tested and confirmed everything else, it is very likely that the app is using a detection method that Magisk currently can't hide from.

Solution? Wait for @topjohnwu to possibly update Magisk/MagiskHide (alternatively, don't install Magisk). When? Whenever he feels like it...

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/2406

Looks like someone posted a potential fix. Will wait for it to reach the master branch!

 

[gaban05]

Have you find the workaround? I am using the same app and face same problem. This app last update gives headache

 

[Tomek0000]

I am hidding root and edxposed using Island and installing intune inside the sandbox. Maybe the same will be with bank apps.

 

[deta312]

@kubis111

i'm happy for you, but please...this isn't your thread so do not OOT, OP problem isn't solving yet

---------- Post added at 11:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:03 AM ----------

I am hidding root and edxposed using Island and installing intune inside the sandbox. Maybe the same will be with bank apps.

can you share the apps link?

 

[vibrastic]

Any updates on this banking app? I've tried many TaiChi Magisk, Sudohide and Zuper module but no success.
ctsProfile all green, Rootbeer Fresh all green.

 

[Heatexplorer]

citi app also detected my rooted device( Mi 8 Pro) after update , even hide the App ..useless....

 

[-SKYLINE-]

citi app also detected my rooted device( Mi 8 Pro) after update , even hide the App ..useless....

Had the same problem. Updated magisk manager and fixed it (even before updating my modules).

 

[timofonic]

Anyone lucky on it? What about BBVA Spain app?

 

[CounterC]

My banking app (PermataMobile X) is detecting root with Safetynet passed and Magisk Manager hidden. I asked some other people to install and see if they can pass the root detection to no avail.

I've tried some little things to narrow down the culprit like:
1. Installed Magisk Manager without flashing the magisk 20.4 zip file (unrooted). Detected as root. Uninstalling the manager immediately allows bank app to work.
2. Flashed Magisk 20.4 without installing Magisk Manager. Detected as root, obviously.
3. Went back to previous versions of Magisk and Magisk Manager. Still detected as root.

Anyone can give any tips on what else I can try to do?

Have you found a solution? With latest Permata and Magisk (23) the banking app still does not work...

 

[Spartacus500]

Anyone lucky on it? What about BBVA Spain app?

For me work

 

[Spartacus500]

My banking app (PermataMobile X) is detecting root with Safetynet passed and Magisk Manager hidden. I asked some other people to install and see if they can pass the root detection to no avail.

I've tried some little things to narrow down the culprit like:
1. Installed Magisk Manager without flashing the magisk 20.4 zip file (unrooted). Detected as root. Uninstalling the manager immediately allows bank app to work.
2. Flashed Magisk 20.4 without installing Magisk Manager. Detected as root, obviously.
3. Went back to previous versions of Magisk and Magisk Manager. Still detected as root.

Anyone can give any tips on what else I can try to do?

Found a solution, but can't publish yet. Excuse me

 

[hallo dare]

Found a solution, but can't publish yet. Excuse me

Why?

 

[Spartacus500]

Why?

So I ran the test quickly and it turns out that it works, for those who are interested, I will provide a solution, but a little later.

 

[timofonic]

I managed to make it work,

For me work

For me work

No idea how. I'm worried about that Knox logo these days, but we'll..

Thanks!

 

[Spartacus500]

My banking app (PermataMobile X) is detecting root with Safetynet passed and Magisk Manager hidden. I asked some other people to install and see if they can pass the root detection to no avail.

I've tried some little things to narrow down the culprit like:
1. Installed Magisk Manager without flashing the magisk 20.4 zip file (unrooted). Detected as root. Uninstalling the manager immediately allows bank app to work.
2. Flashed Magisk 20.4 without installing Magisk Manager. Detected as root, obviously.
3. Went back to previous versions of Magisk and Magisk Manager. Still detected as root.

Anyone can give any tips on what else I can try to do?

Sorry to be just now, but to the point of solution to this,
1. Install the disable services app and disable a process called "S17"
2. Done