@ fastcx:
:laugh: My post is my personal idea. And I don't want to compare phones in this topic anymore because it will break the forum rules.
- Just said that I bought the Sony Experia P for my wife (a week after I could found it in my country) then I root that phone and do a lot of mod that phone.
- My brother stick with Samsung with collection of Galaxy Nexus, Note II, S3 and I do root that phones for him.
- My sister use IP5
D I do not touch to that, I hate Apple).
- Newest, Sony Z is on my table now to test for my friend.
--> I know a little about other devices out of HTC to try and compare.
For the case of Butterfly, believe me, One is in other rank. HTC One will replace One X and One X+ not Butterfly. Butterfly is not in PDA phone level, it is right at the border between phablet and smart phone with 5" screen.
I am designer and from my point of view, Butterfly have very carefully, detail and good design, but only black version (the white is acceptable but the red is terrible color mix).
Related to the hard button, I have used HD2, Samsung SII long enough to understand that the hard button easier to be wear out in hard use conditions and when it got problem it would be very big problem.
Related to root, easier is not means better (easier always comes with security faults as the case of Note II and S3) - that is my personal idea only. There are not so many smart phone users need to root their phone, could you guess how many percent? (20% I think). So in general, root is some thing for experiences users only.